Jemather
NPOV tag on Bhopal Disaster edit
I reverted some vandalism and it looked to me like the vandal had added the template. Re-add it if you wish. I am curious about what you think is POV in this article. You seem to have removed a lot of text that was cited and referenced. Generally, if something is sourced, it's okay (except, obviously, in the case of racist and hate speech mediums and the like). TheQuandry 18:08, 28 January 2007 (UTC)
- Most of the content I removed was plagiarized from its references that I would call questionable at best. Beyond that, I don't like the article's approach. I feel like it should be relatively simple and matter-of-fact, with criticisms put into the "Criticisms" section, instead of a having a running commentary throughout the whole article. It also extensively uses a "we-say, they-say" duality I don't think does an adequate job of framing the situation. Thoughts? Jemather 14:26, 29 January 2007 (UTC)
- That seems to make sense. So it's not so much POV as it is just a poorly written article with some copyright infringing text? In any case, good luck with your rewrite! TheQuandry 15:01, 29 January 2007 (UTC)
- Most of the content I removed was plagiarized from its references that I would call questionable at best. Beyond that, I don't like the article's approach. I feel like it should be relatively simple and matter-of-fact, with criticisms put into the "Criticisms" section, instead of a having a running commentary throughout the whole article. It also extensively uses a "we-say, they-say" duality I don't think does an adequate job of framing the situation. Thoughts? Jemather 14:26, 29 January 2007 (UTC)
Michigan Wikipedians! edit
Greetings Jemather! I noticed that you made mention of the University of Michigan on your userpage. If you are a current undergraduate or graduate student there, I would like to welcome you, on behalf of the Wikipedians of the University of Michigan, to a group meeting on Wednesday October 20, 2010. The meeting will be held at 7:00 PM (EST) in the University of Michigan Chemistry Building, room 1201. New and experienced editors alike are most welcome to come and partake in the collaboration and outreach of Wikipedia in a real-life setting. Questions? Leave me a message here or at my talk page on Wikimedia Outreach, and feel free to email the group at wikipedians@umich.edu. The Wikipedians of the University of Michigan are excited to see you there! Arbitrarily0 (talk) 21:48, 7 October 2010 (UTC)
Michigan Wikipedians edit
Greetings Jemather! I noticed that you made mention of the University of Michigan or Ann Arbor on your userpage. If you are a current student, faculty, or other affiliate at the University of Michigan, I would like to welcome you, on behalf of the Michigan Wikipedians, to our next weekly meeting on Monday September 30 (and every Monday thereafter). The meetings are held at 8:00 PM (EDT) in the University of Michigan Shapiro Library, room 4041. New and experienced editors alike are most welcome. Do not hesitate to leave me a message if you have any questions, and feel free to stop by the MWiki talk page. The Michigan Wikipedians are excited to meet you! Arbitrarily0 (talk) 00:40, 24 September 2013 (UTC)