- Jack Gregory (football manager)/John Gregory (footballer born in Birmingham) (?-?) – QPR 1912–23 – 241 (59) – 1923–28
- Alan Herritty / Alan Herrity (1941–2006) – spelt both Herritty/Herrity – Newport County 1959–62 – 28 (0) – Yeovil 1962–73 – 523 (2) – 2nd most appearances
- John Clancy (footballer) (born 1949) – Bradford Park Avenue 1967–69 – 56 (2) – Yeovil 1969–77 – 483 (79) – 4th most appearances
- Johnny McKay (footballer) (1927–1988) – QPR 1949–52 – 17 (1) – Yeovil 1952–1960 – 329 (65)
- George Muir (footballer, born 1937) (1937–2008) – Hibernian 1955–60 – 49 (0) – Yeovil 1960–1968 – 317 (48)
- Jeff Sherwood (footballer) (born 1959) – Bristol Rovers 1982–83 – 18 (0) – Yeovil 1986–1991 & 1992–1995 – 286 (6)
- Paul Wilson (footballer, born 1960) (born 1960) – Scunthorpe United 1996 – 1 (0) – Yeovil 1989–1995 – 210 (60)
- Peter Conning (born 1964) – Rochdale 1986–87 – 40 (1) – Yeovil 1989–1993 & 1994–1995 – 191 (22)
- Steve Harrower (born 1961) – Exeter City 1983–90 – 187 (10) – Yeovil 1990–1994 – 174 (4)
- Chris White (footballer) (born 1970) – Peterborough United, Doncaster Rovers & Exeter City – Yeovil 1994–1998 – 152 (3)
- Micky Reid / Mick Reid (1927–1975) – Bournemouth, Portsmouth & Watford – Yeovil 1953–1956 – 132 (83)
- Al-James Hannigan (born 1971) – Torquay United (loan) 1990 – 7 (0) – Yeovil 1996–1999 – 104 (7)
- Miklos Nagy (1929–1993) - Scunthorpe United 0, Swindon Town 2