Wikipedia

User:ThaddeusB/Admin coaching/MichaelQSchmidt/Assignment1

< User:ThaddeusB‎ | Admin coaching/MichaelQSchmidt

Case 1

edit
  • Page title: How to find an alien
  • Content:

How to find an alien this is a step by step process that takes much concentration and effort. Many may find this to be stupid. but it is true. Steps are listed below. 1. Go to location of believed alien suspicion. 2. Wave hand to believed direction of alien. 3. Offer current food supply(Ham works best). (By: Luke bush. expert in field of science, aka.numba one balla

  • Tagged as: A1 (Insufficient context)
  • Your action(s):
Well... in has content and thus context, and one can understand what it is about, so I would not go with an A1. I'd say it merits a G1 as an implausible theory, though a G3 as obvious misinformation could apply as well.
  • My comments: You correctly identified that A1 is incorrect. I think G1 is best, although be careful using G1 for "nonsense" as it doesn't really apply to "implausible theories" in general - just something that is literally incomprehensible (random words/characters) or something that is obviously a joke like this way. G3 would also be acceptable. --ThaddeusB (talk) 14:36, 23 September 2009 (UTC)

Case 2

edit
  • Page title: Greater Pittsburgh Literacy Council
  • Content:

Greater Pittsburgh Literacy Council - organization and program information coming soon.

Category:Organizations based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

  • Tagged as: A3 (No content)
  • Your action(s):
Sure enough... no content. A name and a link. It was a good prod and I would not even question the good faith of the prodder. But you know my methods. I'd probably myself slap a HANGON and tag it as under construction, then spend a few minutes adding some content and sources per a g-news search which showed notability, and THEN deprod. Maybe even drop a note to the author.


  • My comments: A3 is a correct. As it happened the article had stood in this state for several months, so I just deleted it. In general though, I'd drop the article creator a note and give them some time to actually make good on the "coming soon" promise. Please note, however, that a hangon tag isn't needed - just remove the speedy tag. Only the article's creator is obligated to use a hangon tag. (Also, these aren't prods so make sure to use the correct language ["remove the tag" or "decline the speedy"] in actual RfA questions.) --ThaddeusB (talk) 14:41, 23 September 2009 (UTC)

Case 3

edit
  • Page title: The nightgowns
  • Content:
The Nightgowns
OriginTacoma, Washington, USA  
Genreselectronic, psychedelic, indie, pop/rock
Years active2008 to Present
LabelsTeam Unicorn
MembersTrevor Dickson
Cody Jones
Kyle Brunette
B.J.

'The Nightgowns are a four-piece electronic indie rock band based out of Tacoma, Washington, comprised of the members Trevor Dickson (Guitar, Vocals), Cody Jones (Keyboard, Guitar, Bass), Kyle Brunette (Guitar, Bass, Keyboard), and B.J. (Drums). Voted "best band" in Tacoma in 2009[1] The Nightgowns music is a nice mix of mostly uplifting, if occasionally moody, electro-pop. The band's music is seemingly heavily influenced by '80s pop.[2] The band's first album experienced a large amount of airplay on college radio station KEXP in seattle.[3]

The Nightgowns formerly The Elephants (2005-2008) included member Jason Freet now of The Drug Purse.[4] After Freet they added members B.J. and Kyle Brunette who had also previously played drums in The Drug Purse. [5]


In 2009 The Nightgowns played alongside Frank Black's Grand Duchy.[6]

Discography

References

  1. ^ http://www.weeklyvolcano.com/2009-08-06/best-of-tacoma-sex-drugs-and-rock-and-roll/4059/#nightgowns
  2. ^ http://www.npr.org/blogs/allsongs/2009/09/second_stage_the_nightgowns.html
  3. ^ http://www.kexplorer.com/artist/85940
  4. ^ http://www.weeklyvolcano.com/2009-01-08/music-main/3253/
  5. ^ http://i.feedtacoma.com/AngelaJossy/have-you-ever-heard-study/
  6. ^ http://blogs.thenewstribune.com/ej/2009/05/03/grand_duchy_nightgowns_review

Category:Musical groups from Tacoma, Washington Category:American rock music groups

  • [1] NPR song of the day
  • [2] Myspace
  • [3] Last.fm
  • [[4]] KEXP.ORG
  • Tagged as: A7 (No indication of possible importance)
  • Your action(s):
Deprod. A7 does not apply if there any credible claim of significance or importance... and voted "best band" in Tacoma in 2009" is a definite and credible claim of such. Would set a watch in case it got re-prodded, and is so would then open a discussion with the re-prodder over his reasoning. If re-prodder has issues, I'd then suggest AfD for community decision. No need to tussle.
  • My comments: You correctly identified that the article doesn't qualify for speedy deletion. In addition to the claim you pointed out, the article does have 2 independent sources. Actually notability is unclear, but importance is clearly asserted. One quick way to improve the article would be to unlink the band members and album titles. --ThaddeusB (talk) 14:49, 23 September 2009 (UTC)

Case 4

edit
  • Page title: Copa simon bolivar 2009
  • Content:

The 2nd tier in the Bolivian Football pyramid consists of 9 regional leagues (one for each department), the number of participants varies depending on the department, It usually has between 8 and 12 teams. Both winner and runner-up of each league compete in the Copa Simón Bolívar, with the winner of such tournament gaining promotion to the 1st Division, and the runner-up playing a play-off match with the 11th placed team in the 1st Division. Until 1976 all 8 regional championships (Pando didn't have an organized tournament back then) were the top in the national football pyramid, with the winner of the Copa Simón Bolívar being crowned as national champion.

The oldest regional championship is the one played in La Paz, it started in 1914 and it was considered for many years as the top Bolivian league, even more when it turned into a semi-pro tournament in 1950 and started including teams from Oruro and Cochabamba.

First phase

Group A

Team Pts Pld W D L GF GA GD
Enrique Happ 3 1 1 0 3 4 0 +3
Universitario 3 1 1 0 0 2 0 +2
Oruro Royal 3 1 1 1 1 1 0 +1
31 de octubre 0 1 0 1 0 0 -2 -2
Deportivo Crystal 0 1 0 0 1 0 -2 -2
Fraternida Tigres 0 1 0 0 1 0 -2 -2

Group B

edit
Team Pts Pld W D L GF GA GD
Club Ciclon 3 1 1 0 3 4 0 +4
Real Charcas 3 1 1 0 0 2 0 +2
Independiente F.C 3 1 1 1 1 1 0 +1
Fancesa 0 1 0 1 0 0 -2 -1
Club San Lorenzo 0 1 0 0 1 0 -2 -2
Universitario de Potosi 0 1 0 0 1 0 -2 -4

Group C

edit
Team Pts Pld W D L GF GA GD
Guabira 6 2 2 0 3 4 0 +2
Club Destroyer 0 2 0 2 0 0 -4 -3
  • Tagged as: A1 (Insufficient context)
  • Your action(s):
Deprod. A1 inapplicable, as article has both content and context. Would tag it for sourcing.
  • My comments: You correctly identified that the article doesn't qualify for speedy deletion. In my opinion, the article should be deleted since 1) the prose is mostly unrelated to article title and 2) The league itself - Copa Simón Bolívar - doesn't have a page, so an individual season shouldn't need a page. However, that is a matter of editorial action/community discussion not administrator action. --ThaddeusB (talk) 14:53, 23 September 2009 (UTC)

Case 5

edit
  • Page title: Tet Wada
  • Content:
Tet Wada
BornJanuary 20, 1973
Tokyo, Japan
NationalityJapanese

Tet Wada (born January 20, 1973) is a Japanese fashion model/actor.

Person

  • Residence: New York, New York Tokyo 1973~1991, Florida 1991-1997, New York 1997~Present
  • Member of the firm: Q Models Management (fashion model New York & Los Angeles), C.E.S.D Talent Agency (commercial model: New York), FM Models Management (fashion model London, United Kingdom), Wild Orange Artists (screen actor: Tokyo, Japan)
  • Graduated from Baruch College in New York, New York (BBA in International Marketing, minor in Philosophy)
  • Languages: Japanese, English, and Spanish
  • Hobbies: Motorcycle engineering, traveling, Aikido (martial art), architecture, observation of abandoned buildings, automobiles, ships, and aircraft
  • Beloved vehicle: Honda VF1000F Interceptor and British made Triumph Daytona 955i
  • Works primarily in the US, and active in Europe and Asia

Model Activities

Model (print)

  • VOGUE (Paris France, United States)
In a Vogue Paris edition with Madonna on a cover, he appeared in a spread with the super model Daria in 2004. (photographed by Terry Richardson)
  • GQ (United States)
  • GLAMOUR (United Kingdom)
  • FLAIR (Italy)
  • COMPLOT (Venezuela)
  • ROLLING STONE 1000 issue Special Collector's Edition (United States)
  • i-D (United States)
  • TRACE (United States)
  • SURFACE (United States)
  • AUGUST MEN (Singapore)
  • GQ (Taiwan)
  • TARZAN (Japan)
  • PHOTO ART BOOK by Leslie Kee (Japan) etc

Model Campaign

Runway Shows

Cast

TV series

Movies

  • The Tenor of Edmond Fontier (2008) (directed by Josell Ramos) Independent - New York
  • Dungeon (2007) (directed by Josell Ramos) Independent - New York
  • Winter Butterfly (directed by Marcus Tozini) Independent - New York
  • One Night with You (directed by Joe D'Augustine) Independent - Los Angeles

CM


{{Fashion-bio-stub}}

ja:TET

  • Tagged as: A7 (No indication of possible importance)
  • Your action(s):
Deprod. Very first sentence is indicator of possible importance. I'd tag it for sources, the lede for expansion, and not oppose if prodder took it to AfD for discussion.
  • My comments: Clearly not an A7 candidate as there are several claims to importance here - numerous modeling credits, a couple TV credits, independent sources (masquerading as external links), etc. Also, a transwiki link to an article that has existed for a while is usually enough to avoid speedy deletion since that indicates some other Wikipedia thinks the subject is notable. --ThaddeusB (talk) 14:56, 23 September 2009 (UTC)

Case 6

edit
Youtube Best Rapper
Contest Information
Contest NameYoutube Best Rapper (YBR)
Established22 September 2009
GenreHip Hop
Below text


Youtube Best Rapper is a youtube contest, that

  • Tagged as: A7 (No indication of possible importance)
  • Your action(s):
A7 might be inapplicable, as the article seems web related and makes a reference to "Best rapper".... a claim of importance. I would feel happier with either a G2 as the author seems to have stopped typing mid-sentence, suggesting a test page... or a G8 because it seems to rely on a non-existant page.
  • My comments: Putting the page title in [[]] was unintentional, so sorry to give you the wrong (G8) impression there. It's an A7 candidate as "best rapper" is part of the contest name & doesn't indicate importance. A Google search should quickly confirm the lack of importance. G2 would also acceptable, as it does resemble a test.

Case 7

edit
  • Page title: სკოლა
  • Content:

{{notenglish|[[Georgian_language|Georgian]]}} სკოლაში არსებობს ბევრი დაავადება ან ტკივილები ორგანოების, უფრო ხშირად თავის ტკივილი. ბევრი სწავლის გამო ბავშვებს თავი სტკივათ ხოლმე.თუ მათ ძალიან ასტკივდათ თავი და სამჯერ დასჭირდათ ექიმი ისინი ზომბირდებიან 1 დგით და ჯობიათ მოერიდოთ და არ გაამწაროთ თორე გიკბენთ. კბენა ზომბირებული ადამიანის შედის სისხლში და ადამიანი მუტაციას განიცდის. ანა ენშტეინ ვარძიაშვილი.


  • Tagged as: G1 (nonsense)
  • Your action(s):

Deprod. Georgian is not nonsense, so G1 does not apply. I do not know what it does say... but its not a G1, unless a Georgian Wikipedian translates and says its nonsense. However, would suggest it either be translated or be transwikied to Georgian Wikipedia, as this one is English.

  • My comments: Your correctly identified that it doesn't meet the G1 speedy criteria. (Unless translated text also meets it, which is highly unlikely.) If the not English tag wasn't already there, the correct action would be to add it. The tag will hopefully attract someone who can actually raed it & act accordingly. --ThaddeusB (talk) 15:06, 23 September 2009 (UTC)

Case 8

edit
  • Page title: Unesco must for farouk hosni egypt no no irina bokova
  • Content:

unesco must for farouk hosny no no irina bokova farouk hosny maslom because eroupe contain each other

conact us at example@example.com

  • Tagged as: G11 (advertising)
  • Your action(s):

The "contact us" supports the G11... though it might meet G1 as well.

  • My comments: It definitely meets G1 and that's how I'd delete. I have no idea what they are trying to say here. The "conact us at" is probably sufficient to warrant g11, but it is also true that sometimes people put their personal email simply to identify who wrote the article, so not knowing what the heck they are trying to say means G1 is better. --ThaddeusB (talk) 15:09, 23 September 2009 (UTC)

Case 9

edit
  • Page title: Dime 65
  • Content:

Dime 65 Is An OS That Is Created In The Linux Kernel.The Founder Of Dime 65 Is Royce Ng,Who Is A Programmer At A Company Called RRF Software.Dime 65 Wants To Create Operating Systems That Is Useful From Home Users To World Companies And At A Affordable Price.

The Features Are: 1.)Supports Old And New Computers. 2.)Drivers Are Already Installed. 3.)Users Can Recover From Problems Easily. 4.)Programs Will Not Crash Easily In Dime 65. 5.)Windows Executables Are Supported. 6.)Many Types Of Hardware Are Supported.

This Is The List Of Operating Systems They Created With The Price Stated. Desktops: Dime 65 PL Desktop - S$59.99 Dime 65 Desktop For Older Computers - S$59.99 Dime 65 Desktop For 64 Bit CPU's - S$70.91 Dime 65 Command Prompt - S$23.30 Dime 65 DAM Desktop S$89.90

Servers: Dime 65 PL Server - S$89.90 Dime 65 Server For Older Server's - S$59.99 Dime 65 Server For 64 Bit Server's - S$150.59 Dime 65 Server Command Prompt - S$56.67 Dime 65 DAM Server With Virtualisation Techonology - S$178.87

  • Tagged as:
  • Your action(s):

Would tag as G11, advert.

  • My comments: You are correct - this is a clear G11

Case 10

edit
  • Page title: Emil Brumaru
  • Content:

Emil Brumaru (born on 25 December 1939, Bahmutea, Basarabia) is a contemporary Romanian writer and poet.


Works

  • Versuri (Stanzas), 1970
  • Detectivul Arthur (Detective Arthur), 1970
  • Julien Ospitalierul (Julien the Hospitable), 1974
  • Cântece naive (Naive Songs), 1976
  • Adio, Robinson Crusoe (Adios, Robinson Crusoe), 1978
  • Dulapul îndrăgostit (Enamoured Cupboard), 1980
  • Ruina unui samovar (The Ruin of a Samovar), 1983
  • Dintr-o scorbură de morcov (From the Hollow of a Carrot), 1998
  • Poeme alese (Picked Poems), 2003
  • Opera poetică (2 vol., 2003, 3 vol., 2006) (Poetic Works)
  • Fluturii din pandişpan (The Butterflies from the Cake), 2003
  • Poezii (carte la borcan) (Poems. Jarbook), 2003
  • Cerşetorul de cafea (Coffee Beggar), 2004
  • Submarinul erotic (Erotic Submarine), 2005
  • Infernala comedie (Infernal Comedy), 2005
  • Dumnezeu se uită la noi cu binoclul (God Looks at Us With a Binocular), 2006
  • O brumă de paiete şi confetti (Spangle and Confetti Dust), collaboration with Şerban Foarţă, 2007
  • Cântece de adolescent (Teen Songs), 2007
  • Povestea boiernaşului de ţară şi a fecioarei... (The Story of the Country Page and of the Virgin...), 2008
  • Ne logodim cu un inel din iarbă (We Betroth With a Grass Ring), 2008
  • Opere I. Julien Ospitalierul (Works I. Julien the Hospitable), 2009
  • Opere II. Submarinul erotic (Works II. Erotic Submarine), 2009


Category:Romanian poets

  • Tagged as: A7 (no indication of possible importance)
  • Your action(s):
Deprod, as with case #5, first sentence gives indication of possible importance, and this is supported by list of works. I'd tag for expansion and sources and not oppose it going to AfD for discussion.
  • My comments: You are mostly correct. Merely stating someone is a writer isn't an indication of importance, but the list of works is sufficient to suggest importance ("published writer" might be enough though.) A GNews or GBooks search makes it pretty clear she is notable, so it wouldn't hurt to point to those searches when declining speedy (either in edit summary or article's talk page). --ThaddeusB (talk) 15:14, 23 September 2009 (UTC)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:ThaddeusB/Admin_coaching/MichaelQSchmidt/Assignment1&oldid=678101689"