User:Senra/Sandbox/Malleus2012/Motion to close

Proposals by user:Senra

edit

Proposed motion to close

edit

I propose that this case is closed on the following grounds

  1. The statement by Alexandria (talk · contribs) in the original case* was poorly stated
  2. The original case* was not supported by diffs, thus the evidence is scattered 'wiki-wide'. There are even attempts to include off-wiki[1] evidence
  3. Evidence was presented before any reasonable scope was defined[2]
  4. If scope does include any historic civility violations[3] and resulting admin actions or inactions, then 500 words in evidence per editor may not be enough

*I do not know how to link to the original diff for this case. Please feel free to re-factor that diff and remove this note

Comment by Arbitrators:
Comment by parties:
Comment by others: