User:Paco BRG/Bocage/Jacob Atkinson Peer Review

Peer review

edit

This is where you will complete your peer review exercise. Please use the following template to fill out your review.

General info

edit

Lead

edit

Guiding questions:

There is no lead. Probably in the original article already

edit

Content

edit

Guiding questions:

  • The content is relevant .

Content evaluation

edit

Tone and Balance

edit

Guiding questions:

  • Content is from a neutral perspective.

Tone and balance evaluation

edit

Sources and References

edit

Guiding questions:

  • There are no sources as of yet.

Sources and references evaluation

edit

Organization

edit

Guiding questions:

  • content is mostly in bullet format currently. But ideas are in a coherent sequence.

Organization evaluation

edit

Images and Media

edit

Guiding questions: If your peer added images or media

  • Does the article include images that enhance understanding of the topic?
  • Are images well-captioned?
  • Do all images adhere to Wikipedia's copyright regulations?
  • Are the images laid out in a visually appealing way?

Images and media evaluation

edit

For New Articles Only

edit

If the draft you're reviewing is a new article, consider the following in addition to the above.

  • Does the article meet Wikipedia's Notability requirements - i.e. Is the article supported by 2-3 reliable secondary sources independent of the subject?
  • How exhaustive is the list of sources? Does it accurately represent all available literature on the subject?
  • Does the article follow the patterns of other similar articles - i.e. contain any necessary infoboxes, section headings, and any other features contained within similar articles?
  • Does the article link to other articles so it is more discoverable?

New Article Evaluation

edit

Overall impressions

edit

Guiding questions

overall, I think there are some very interesting ideas you plan on adding to the article. Just maybe some sources for clarity would be helpful.