Wikipedia

User:Jm34harvey/wip/signof3

< User:Jm34harvey

To do edit

Orphans edit

  • #10. (Eco 1984, pp. 198–220): Horns, Hooves, Insteps: Some Hypotheses on Three Types of Abstraction

Historical background edit

(Pinault 1992, pp. 86-91) also pp=93, 95, 97; p=91; pp=91-2; p=96-7
Special:Search/David_Pinault 79 hits!!! no authorlink???
(Silverman 1991, p. 171)
Edgar_Allan_Poe#CITEREFHarrowitz1984 - ADDed cite but no inline reference
Process of establishing beginning of the genre requires defining method of detecting
MOS:LEAD - Wikipedia:Template_messages/Cleanup#Introduction
#4. (Ginzburg 1984, pp. 81–118): Morelli, Freud, and Sherlock Holmes: Clues and Scientific Method
(Pinault 1992, pp. 86–91) also pp=93, 95, 97; p=91; pp=91-2; p=96-7
  • #4. (Ginzburg 1984, pp. 103.?): Morelli, Freud, and Sherlock Holmes: Clues and Scientific Method

Dupin !!! edit

Sign of Three, Harvardizing, etc.
Article Year Signof3
pages 		Signof3
wikied 		harvardized Comments
Edgar Allan Poe n/a ? =0000!00000 =====!====0 (notes), portok
Edgar Allan Poe bibliography n/a ? =0000!00000 =====!==000 ===Notes, portNOT
C. Auguste Dupin April 1841... ? ===00!00000 =====!===== ==Notes(2), portNOT
The Murders in the Rue Morgue April 1841 ? ===00!00000 =====!====0 ==Notes, portNOT
A Descent into the Maelström April 1841 ? 00000!00000 =====!===== (notes), portok
The Mystery of Marie Rogêt November 1842 ? 00000!00000 =====!===== (notes), portNOT
The Gold Bug June 1843 ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 comment
The Black Cat August 1843 ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 comment
Thou Art the Man November 1844 ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 comment
The Purloined Letter 1844-1845 ? 00000!00000 =====!===== (notes), portok
x 18?? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 comment

C. Auguste Dupin edit

  • #9. (Harrowitz 1984, pp. 179–197): The Body of the Detective Model: Charles S. Peirce and Edgar Allan Poe
  • Dupin's Method: Nancy Harrowitz discusses Dupin's method in the light of Peirce's logic of making good guesses or abductive reasoning.#9.(Harrowitz 1984, pp. 179–197)
  • Dupin's Method
Poe defines Dupin's method, ratiocination, using the example of a card player: "[T]he extent of information obtained; lies not so much in the validity of the inference as in the quality of the observation."(Poe 1927, p. 79), #9.(Harrowitz 1984, pp. 186–187) Poe then provides a narrative example where Dupin explains how he knew the narrator was thinking about the actor Chantilly.(Poe 1927, pp. 82–83), #9.(Harrowitz 1984, pp. 187–192) Dupin then applies his method to the solving of this crime.
Harrowitz observes that "Poe's exposition of the analytic method is a three-step one: ..."
  • Sherlock Holmes
Holmes emulates Dupin in the opening pages of The Adventure of the Cardboard Box of The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes. The first London editions of Memoirs did not include the story. The first U. S. edition did but was omitted very quickly. (Because it included adultery?) When he story was removed from the Memoirs, its opening pages, where Holmes emulates Dupin, were transferred to the beginning of The Adventure of the Resident Patient. In some later U.S. editions of the Memoirs, which still omit "The Adventure of the Cardboard Box", this transfer still appears.
  • Detective Dupin (children's fiction)
Count Olaf disquises him self as Detective Dupin, a "famous" detective obsessed with what's cool, including ridiculous sunglasses which cover up his eyebrow and green plastic shoes with yellow lightning bolts on them to cover his tattoo. He is the primary antagonist in the series A Series of Unfortunate Events by Lemony Snicket (nom de plume for Daniel Handler).
Disquised as Dupin (Joseph Cotton), a fictional Edgar Allan Poe helps Madeline Minot (Leslie Caron), a young French woman on a mission.

Edgar Allan Poe edit

  • #9. (Harrowitz 1984, pp. 179–197): The Body of the Detective Model: Charles S. Peirce and Edgar Allan Poe

Holmes edit

Sign of Three, Harvardizing, etc.
Article Year Signof3
pages 		Signof3
wikied 		harvardized Comments
Arthur Conan Doyle n/a ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
Arthur Conan Doyle bibliography n/a ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
Canon of Sherlock Holmes n/a ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
Sherlock Holmes 1887 ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 18?? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
A Study in Scarlet, a novel 1887 STUD? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Sign of Four, a novel 1890 SIGN? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 18?? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, a collection 1892 S ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
A Scandal in Bohemia 1892 (1/12) SCAN? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Red-Headed League 1892 (2/12) REDH? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
A Case of Identity 1892 (3/12) IDEN? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Boscombe Valley Mystery 1892 (4/12) BOSC? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Five Orange Pips 1892 (5/12) FIVE? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Man with the Twisted Lip 1892 (6/12) TWIS? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle 1892 (7/12) BLUE? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Speckled Band 1892 (8/12) SPEC? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Engineer's Thumb 1892 (9/12) ENGR? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Noble Bachelor 1892 (10/12) NOBL? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Beryl Coronet 1892 (11/12) BERY? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Copper Beeches 1892 (12/12) COPP? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 18?? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes, a collection 1894 S? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
Silver Blaze 1894 (1/12) SILV? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Cardboard Box
(aka His Last Bow (story)) 		1894 (2/12) CARD?
LAST? 		00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Yellow Face 1894 (3/12) YELL? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Stockbroker's Clerk 1894 (4/12) STOC? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Gloria Scott 1894 (5/12) GLOR? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Musgrave Ritual 1894 (6/12) MUSG? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Reigate Squire 1894 (7/12) REIG? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Crooked Man 1894 (8/12) CROO? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Resident Patient 1894 (9/12) RESI? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Greek Interpreter 1894 (10/12) GREE? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Naval Treaty 1894 (11/12) NAVA? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Final Problem 1894 (12/12) FINA? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 18?? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Hound of the Baskervilles, a novel 1901-2 HOUN? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 18?? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Return of Sherlock Holmes, a collection 1905 ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Empty House 1905 (1/13) EMPT? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Norwood Builder 1905 (2/13) NORW? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Dancing Men 1905 (3/13) DANC? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Solitary Cyclist 1905 (4/13) ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Priory School 1905 (5/13) PRIO? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of Black Peter 1905 (6/13) BLAC? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of Charles Augustus Milverton 1905 (7/13) CHAS? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Six Napoleons 1905 (8/13) SIXN? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Three Students 1905 (9/13) 3STU? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Golden Pince-Nez 1905 (10/13) GOLD? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Missing Three-Quarter 1905 (11/13) ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Abbey Grange 1905 (12/13) ABBE? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Second Stain 1905 (13/13) SECO? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 18?? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
His Last Bow, a collection 1913 NOT!? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of Wisteria Lodge 1913 (1/7) WIST? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Red Circle 1913 (2/7) REDC? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Bruce-Partington Plans 1913 (3/7) ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Dying Detective 1913 (4/7) DYIN? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Disappearance of Lady Frances Carfax 1913 (5/7) LADY? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Devil's Foot Root?? 1913 (6/7) DEVI? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
His Last Bow (story) 1913 (7/7) LAST? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 191? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Valley of Fear, a novel 1914-5 VALL? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 191? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes, a collection 1921 ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Mazarin Stone 1921 (1/12) MAZA? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Problem of Thor Bridge 1921 (2/12) THOR? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Creeping Man 1921 (3/12) CREE? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Sussex Vampire 1921 (4/12) SUSS? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Three Garridebs 1921 (5/12) ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Illustrious Client 1921 (6/12) ILLU? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Three Gables 1921 (7/12) 3GAB? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Blanched Soldier 1921 (8/12) BLAN? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Lion's Mane 1921 (9/12) LION? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Retired Colourman 1921 (10/12) RETI? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of the Veiled Lodger 1921 (11/12) ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
The Adventure of Shoscombe Old Place 1921 (12/12) SHOS? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT
x 192? ? 00000!00000 00000!00000 notesNOT, portNOT

Sherlock Holmes edit

  • Lead
 
Look up Holmesian or Sherlockian in Wiktionary, the free dictionary.


(Murch 1958, p. 158)


  • #2. (Sebeok & Umiker-Sebeok 1984, pp. 11–54): 'You Know My Method': A Juxtaposition of Charles S. Peirce and Sherlock Holmes
  • #3. (Truzzi 1984, pp. 55–80): Sherlock Holmes, Applied Social Psychologist
  • #4. (Ginzburg 1984, pp. 81–118): Morelli, Freud, and Sherlock Holmes: Clues and Scientific Method
  • #6. (Carettini 1984, pp. 135–153): Peirce, Holmes, Popper
  • #7. (Hintikka & Hintikka 1984, pp. 154–169): Sherlock Holmes Confronts Modern Logic: Toward a Theory of Information-Seeking through Questioning
  • #8. (Hintikka 1984, pp. 170–178): Sherlock Holmes Formalized
  • #9. (Harrowitz 1984, pp. 179–197): The Body of the Detective Model: Charles S. Peirce and Edgar Allan Poe

Arthur Conan Doyle edit

Charles S. Peirce edit

Giovanni Morelli edit

  • #9. (Ginzburg 1984, pp. 81–118): Morelli, Freud, and Sherlock Holmes: Clues and Scientific Method

Sigmund Freud edit

  • #9. (Ginzburg 1984, pp. 81–118): Morelli, Freud, and Sherlock Holmes: Clues and Scientific Method

Karl Popper edit

References edit

  1. ^ (Murch 1958, p. 158) quoted by #3.(Truzzi 1984, p. 55)

Sources edit

See also: Citations, Dupin and Poe, and Holmes and Conan Doyle

The Sign of Three edit

Eco & Sebeok 1984, 236 pages. Ten essays on methods of abductive inference in Poe's Dupin, Doyle's Holmes, Peirce and many others. - isbn.nu
author(s) - describes - stresses the significance of - this in his discussion of the conjectural paradigm as evidenced by the methods of Giovanni Morelli, Sigmund Freud and Sherlock Holmes in the light of Charles Sanders Peirce's logic of making good guesses or abductive reasoning.
  1. Sebeok 1984, pp. 1–10
  2. Sebeok & Umiker-Sebeok 1984, pp. 11–54
  3. Truzzi 1984, p. 55-80
  4. Ginzburg 1984, p. 81-118
  5. Bonafantini & Proni 1984, p. 119-134
  6. Carettini 1984, p. 135-153
  7. Hintikka & Hintikka 1984, p. 154-169
  8. Hintikka 1984, p. 170-178
  9. Harrowitz 1984, p. 179-197
  10. Eco 1984, p. 198-220
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Jm34harvey/wip/signof3&oldid=481155442"