This is to analyze if and how the PROD mechanism puts at risk reasonable articles.

Search: "Contested PROD" in AfD from July 2009 to May 2010

Overall stats:

  • Total articles: 64
  • Articles kept/surviving after incubation or userification/no consensus: 15 (23.43%)
  • Articles deleted or redirected: 47 (73.43%)
  • Merged: 2 (3.125%)


AfD Date of closure Outcome
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Commercial_credit_reporting 2009-11-20 Keep
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Nida_Sameer 2010-03-06 Redirect
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Diego_Orduña 2009-08-09 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Senyacism 2009-07-27 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jackie Owens 2010-02-16 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Yoon Seong-Min 2009-09-26 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Daniel Farnworth 2010-02-28 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Hollywoods_Divas 2010-05-17 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Open_The_Gate 2010-01-16 Redirect
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/The valley cr3w 2009-07-25 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sophie Essmat 2009-08-22 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Passepartout (publishing) 2009-08-16 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Fitness_fanatic_(2nd_nomination) 2009-08-09 No consensus
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/EpZilla 2009-09-17 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Team_touchdown 2009-11-18 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/LEVELURZ 2009-12-01 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Engine (boogie-rock band) 2009-11-24 Kept after incubation
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Def Jam Street Legend 2009-09-04 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Robert Williams (geometer) 2009-12-14 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Angel_Kozlev 2010-02-10 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Nicholas_Perrin 2009-12-26 No consensus
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Reece_Jones_(artist) 2010-05-06 Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bill Verna (2nd nomination) 2009-07-12 No consensus after DRV and 2nd AfD
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Zendesk 2010-04-21 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Don't_Be_Such_a_Scientist_(book) 2009-12-22 Keep (withdrawn)
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hardanger Sunnhordlandske Dampskipsselskap 2009-11-25 Keep (withdrawn)
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Epona (IRC services) 2009-12-19 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tedhi Baat Shekhar Ke Saath 2009-08-22 Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Harry N. MacLean 2009-11-29 Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/National Endowment for Alzheimer's Research 2009-09-20 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Mike_Pilat_(Pilot)_(2nd_nomination) 2009-10-20 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/We Are The Audience 2010-05-10 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/GW Patriot 2009-09-14 Redirect
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Goldilocks_Mission 2009-09-10 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Sara Erikson 2009-09-02 Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ruehl Airlines 2010-04-26 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Chasys Draw IES 2009-09-12 Userfied, then kept
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Promotional education 2009-07-27 Merge and redirect
Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Alex_Ferguson_Testimonial 2010-04-06 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/West Midlands bus route 1 (Birmingham) 2010-04-07 8 deleted, 1 kept
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hopkins West Junior High School 2009-12-21 Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Jack Parkinson (footballer born 1986) 2009-07-29 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/T. Stacy Condo Tower 2009-07-09 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Shahbaz music videos 2009-11-22 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Search Engine Advertising (Book) 2010-05-04 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Intellectus language centre 2009-10-21 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Mountain Wrestling Association 2010-02-19 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/America First Credit Union 2009-11-22 Keep
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of multiple world heavyweight champions in professional wrestling (2nd nomination) 2009-11-11 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tree of life garden 2009-07-21 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/High-flyer wrestler 2010-03-18 Redirect
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Forensic and Medico-legal Aspects of Sexual Crimes and Unusual Sexual Practices 2009-08-09 Redirect
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Meat on the Bone (2nd nomination) 2009-11-21 Delete
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/There Is No Normal Anymore 2010-03-24 Merge
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/APPA (programming language) 2009-12-15 2 delete