Open main menu

This Sweet Sickness (1960) is a psychological thriller novel by Patricia Highsmith, about a man who is obsessed with a woman who has rejected his advances. It is a "painful novel about obsessive imaginary love".[1]

This Sweet Sickness
ThisSweetSickness.jpg
First edition
AuthorPatricia Highsmith
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Genrenovel psychological thriller psychological horror
PublisherHarper & Brothers, US; Heinemann, UK
Publication date
1960
Media typePrint (Hardback & Paperback)
Pages240 pp (hardback edition)
OCLC310569021

CompositionEdit

Highsmith dedicated the novel to her mother Mary: "To my mother".[2]

SynopsisEdit

Scientist David Kelsey is infatuated with Annabelle, with whom he had a short relationship before leaving the town in which they met to take a job. The job, he hopes, will allow him to have a decent amount of money coming in, in preparation for marriage to Annabelle. The two never actually discussed marriage and, while he is away, Annabelle marries another man, Gerald. Unable to accept the turn of events and move on, David labors in the vain, increasingly self-deluding, hope that she will leave her new husband. Under the assumed identity of William Neumeister, a freelance journalist who frequently travels, he buys a cabin in the country to serve as their eventual home. He furnishes it for her and spends weekends there, cooking and serving meals and generally acting as if he is doing everything for two. He sends her letters, visits her home and asks her to divorce her husband even after she has had a son by him. Eventually, Gerald discovers David's house and arrives to confront the situation. The two men get into an altercation; they scuffle and Gerald falls, breaking his neck. David reports the death to the police, identifying himself as Neumeister and describing Gerald as a total stranger who showed up at his door, belligerent and spoiling for a fight, and was killed accidentally.

Two of David's friends, Wes Carmichael, a coworker who has his own unhappy home life, and Effie Brennan, who is infatuated with David - once secretly followed him to his house and, after the death of Gerald, they suspect him of a duality about which they question him over time and with escalating incisiveness. Effie, being in love with David and hoping he will ultimately give up on Annabelle, often supports him at key points during his attempts to maintain his two identities. He builds a web of lies, betrayal and denial. Annabelle wants to meet Neumeister, to learn more about the circumstances of her husband's death; David fends her off successfully. He secures a new job, sells his house and buys a new one, in his own name, nearer to Annabelle. He repeats his intrusive behavior with her new beau, Grant.

One weekend, David, who is beginning to occasionally lose touch with reality, invites Wes and Effie to visit in his new home. After some heavy drinking and quarreling, their relationships deteriorate rapidly, followed by more violence and David on the lam in New York City. There, he fantasizes that Annabelle is with him as they sight-see, shop and dine. When, in a restaurant, he is recognized as a wanted man, he imagines the two of them are fleeing together, but David's time has run out.

ReceptionEdit

Writing in the New York Times, Anthony Boucher called the novel "an impressive psychological study". He wrote:[3]

Objectively yet compassionately she examines a young chemist who spends his weekends in a make-believe in which that girl did not marry somebody else; and relentlessly she shows how his rejection of reality leads to disaster and death. The book has the compulsion of truth; and probably only a professional reviewer in a heavy season would protest that she might have got the same results in something under 100,000 words.

AdaptationsEdit

This Sweet Sickness was adapted in 1962 for an episode of the anthology television series The Alfred Hitchcock Hour. The episode, titled "Annabel," starred Dean Stockwell as David Kelsey. The novel was also the basis for the 1977 French-language film Dites-lui que je l'aime (Tell Her I Love Her), starring Gérard Depardieu as David, which Highsmith did not like.[4]

Matt Damon, who starred in the 1999 film adaptation of Highsmith's novel The Talented Mr. Ripley, expressed interest in writing "a really strict adaptation" of This Sweet Sickness.[5]

ReferencesEdit

  1. ^ Harris, Elise (August 31, 2003). "Her Well of Loneliness". New York Times. Retrieved 11 December 2015.
  2. ^ Schenkar, Joan. The Talented Miss Highsmith: The Secret Life and Serious Art of Patricia Highsmith. p. 359.
  3. ^ Boucher, Anthony (February 7, 1960). "Criminals at Large" (PDF). New York Times. Retrieved December 11, 2015.
  4. ^ Schenkar, Joan. The Talented Miss Highsmith: The Secret Life and Serious Art of Patricia Highsmith. p. 584.
  5. ^ Ripley: my part in his downfall - Profiles, People - The Independent[dead link]