The Scorpion and the Frog
The Scorpion and the Frog is an animal fable which teaches that vicious people often cannot resist hurting others even when it is not in their interests. This fable seems to have emerged in Russia in the early 20th century, although it was likely inspired by more ancient fables.
A scorpion, which cannot swim, asks a frog to carry it across a river on the frog's back. The frog hesitates, afraid of being stung by the scorpion, but the scorpion argues that if it did that, they would both drown. The frog considers this argument sensible and agrees to transport the scorpion. Midway across the river, the scorpion stings the frog anyway, dooming them both. The dying frog asks the scorpion why it stung despite knowing the consequence, to which the scorpion replies: "I couldn't help it. It's in my nature."
In the English-speaking world, the fable was made famous by the 1955 movie Mr. Arkadin. It is recounted in a soliloquy by Gregory Arkadin (played by Orson Welles) and serves as a metaphor for the tragic and self-destructive natures of the movie's principal characters. In an interview, Welles mentioned that the fable is Russian in origin.
The fable appears in the 1933 Russian novel The German Quarter by Lev Nitoburg. The fable also appears in the 1944 novel The Hunter of the Pamirs, and this is the earliest known appearance of the fable in English. The Hunter of the Pamirs is an English translation of the 1940 Russian novel Jura by Georgii Tushkan, but the fable does not appear in the original Russian.[a]
The Scorpion and the TurtleEdit
A likely precursor to The Scorpion and the Frog is the Persian fable of The Scorpion and the Turtle. This earlier fable appears in the Anvaar Soheili, a Persian collection of fables written c. 1500 by Hossein Va'ez Kashefi.[b] The Anvaar Soheili is in part a translation of fables from the Panchatantra, a collection of Indian fables written in Sanskrit, but The Scorpion and the Turtle does not appear in the Panchatantra, which means it was added to the Anvaar Soheili by Kashefi and is thus likely Persian in origin.
In the Scorpion and the Turtle, it is a turtle that carries the scorpion across the river, and the turtle survives the scorpion's sting thanks to its protective shell. The turtle is baffled by the scorpion's behavior because they are old friends and the scorpion must have known that its stinger would not pierce the turtle's shell. The scorpion responds that it acted neither out of malice nor ingratitude, but merely an irresistible and indiscriminate urge to sting. The turtle then delivers the following reflection:
- "Truly have the sages said that to cherish a base character is to give one's honor to the wind, and to involve one's own self in embarrassment."
The moral of this fable is thus stated explicitly, and not left to interpretation. An important difference with The Scorpion and the Frog is that, in this fable with the turtle, the scorpion does not expect to drown. In some later versions of the fable, the turtle punishes the scorpion by drowning it anyway.
The Scorpion and the Frog has often been attributed to Aesop, but it does not appear in any collection of his fables prior to the 20th century. However, there are earlier fables attributed to Aesop which teach similar morals regarding trust. These include The Farmer and the Viper, which warns that kindness will not stop a scoundrel from hurting its benefactor, and The Frog and the Mouse, which warns that treacherous friends often hurt themselves in the process.
The fable does not explicitly state the moral it tries to teach, and thus it is left to interpretation. A common interpretation is that people with vicious personalities cannot resist hurting others, even when it is not in their interests. The Italian writer Giancarlo Livraghi has commented that while there are plenty of animal fables which warn against trusting vicious people, in none of these other fables is the villain suicidal. The Scorpion and the Frog is unique in that the scorpion is irrationally self-destructive and fully aware of it.
For Freudian psychoanalysis, "it seems like a textbook illustration of the death drive — are we not all, on some level, self-sabotaging scorpions?" The French philosopher Gilles Deleuze, by contrast, saw the scorpion not as a character structure but as a fictional character made a victim of circumstance: "his desire becomes fatal destiny owing to an unfortunate combination of contingent factors." To a social psychologist, the fable may present a dispositionist view of human nature because it seems to reject the idea that people behave rationally according to circumstances. The French sociologist Jean-Claude Passeron saw the scorpion as a metaphor for Machiavellian politicians who delude themselves by their unconscious tendency to rationalize their ill-conceived plans, and thereby lead themselves and their followers to ruin.
Orson Welles felt that the scorpion's lack of hypocrisy gave it a certain charm: "I will always like a man who admits to being a bastard, a murderer, or whatever you want, and tells me: 'I killed three people'. He is immediately my brother, because he is frank. I think that frankness does not excuse the crime, but it makes him very attractive, it gives him charm."
Since the fable's narration in Mr. Arkadin, it has been recounted as a key element in other films, including Skin Deep (1989), The Crying Game (1992), Drive (2011), and The Devil's Carnival (2012). In addition, references to the fable have appeared in comics, television shows, and in newspaper articles, some of which have applied it to the relationship between big business and government and to politics, especially the bitter nature of Middle Eastern politics such as the Arab–Israeli conflict and in Iran.
- Tushkan (1944). The Hunter of the Pamirs, p. 320.
- Takeda (2011)
- on YouTube. Retrieved August 2, 2016.
- Richard Brody (March 30, 2010). "DVD of the Week: Mr. Arkadin". The New Yorker. Retrieved February 25, 2020.
- Fitzgerald (2000). Orson Welles: The Pocket Essential Guide, p. 57.
- Callow (2015). Orson Welles Vol 3.
- Bazin et al. (1958). "Interview with Orson Welles", pp. 24-25: French: "Primo, la grenouille est un âne! [...] Rien au monde de plus charmant qu'une crapule admettant qu'elle est une crapule. [...] L'histoire du scorpion, elle, est d'origine russe.", lit. 'Firstly, the frog is an idiot! [...] Nothing in the world is more charming than a scoundrel who admits he is a scoundrel. [...] The story of the scorpion is Russian in origin.'
- Nitoburg (1933). The German Quarter.
- Ruymbeke (2016). Kashefi's Anvar-e Sohayli, p. 292.
- Eastwick (1854), pp. 133-134
- Dutton (1908). The Tortoise and the Geese, pp. 12-13.
- Giancarlo Livraghi (March 2007). "The Scorpion and the Frog". gandalf.it. Retrieved February 25, 2020.
- James (1852). Aesop's Fables. A New Version, Chiefly From Original Sources, p. 14.
- Takeda (2011): German: Die Moral der Fabel besagt: Manche Menschen handeln von Natur aus mörderisch und selbst-mörderisch zugleich., lit. 'The moral of the fable says: Some people act naturally murderous and self-murderous at the same time.'
- Schuster (2016). The Trouble with Pleasure, p. 70.
- Lasine (2012). Weighing Hearts, p. 110.
- Passeron (2001), section VI, paragraph 101.
- Wasson (2011). A Splurch in the Kisser, p. 296.
- Norman N. Holland. "Neil Jordan, The Crying Game, 1992". A Sharper Focus. Retrieved March 19, 2020.
- Peter Canavese (September 16, 2011). "Review: 'Drive'". Mountain View Voice. Retrieved March 19, 2020.
- Lenika Cruz (August 17, 2012). "How the Creators of The Devil's Carnival Said 'Screw You' to Hollywood and Gained a Cult Following". LA Weekly. Retrieved July 23, 2020.
- As Grimm Fairy Tales #39 (June 2009). Zenescope Entertainment.
- 1997's "Scorpion" episode of Star Trek: Voyager; 2005's episode 1, Season 6 of Gilmore Girls; 2006's episode 2, Season 2 of How I Met Your Mother; 2016's episode 5, Season 4 of Motive; 2017's episode 8, Season 13 of Supernatural; 2019's episode 10, Season 2 of teen wolf.
- Maurice Saatchi (May 29, 2007). "Google data versus human nature". Financial Times. Retrieved March 19, 2020.
- Ryan Ellis (April 24, 2015). "The Scorpion And The Frog: A Tale Of Modern Capitalism". Forbes. Retrieved March 20, 2020.
- Murray Forseter (June 9, 2017). "GOP Effort to Control Trump Is the Embodiment of the Fable "The Scorpion and the Frog"". HuffPost. Retrieved March 19, 2020.
- Anon. "Compromise is still seen as surrender". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved March 19, 2020.
- Patrick Kiker (July 16, 2006). "...Because It's The Middle East". CBS News. Retrieved March 19, 2020.
- Anon. (June 30, 2017). "'Scorpion & frog': Haley uses fable to blast Iran as UN & EU say Tehran complies with nuclear deal]". RT. Retrieved March 19, 2020.
- United Nations (June 29, 2017). "Accord on Iran's Nuclear Programme Remains on Track, Political Affairs Chief Tells Security Council". United Nations, SC/12894. Retrieved March 19, 2020.
- Aaron Schuster (2016). The Trouble with Pleasure. Deleuze and Psychoanalysis. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press. p. 70. ISBN 9780262528597.
- André Bazin; Charles Bitsch; Jean Domarchi (September 1958). "Entretien avec Orson Welles" [Interview with Orson Welles]. Cahiers du Cinéma (in French). Vol. 15 no. 87. Editions de l'Etoile.
- Arata Takeda (March 2011). "Blumenreiche Handelswege: Ost-westliche Streifzüge auf den Spuren der Fabel Der Skorpion und der Frosch" [Flowery Trade Routes: East-Western forays into the footsteps of the fable The Scorpion and the Frog] (PDF). Deutsche Vierteljahrsschrift für Literaturwissenschaft und Geistesgeschichte (in German). 85 (1): 124–152. doi:10.1007/BF03374756.
- Christine van Ruymbeke (2016). Kashefi's Anvar-e Sohayli: Rewriting Kalila wa-Dimna in Timurid Herat. Brill. ISBN 9789004314757.
- Georgii Tushkan (1940). Джура [Jura] (in Russian).
- Georgi Tushkan (1944) [Original Russian edition published in 1940]. The Hunter of the Pamirs: A Novel of Adventure in Soviet Central Asia. Translated by Gerard Shelley. Hutchinson & Co.
- Ḥusain Vá'iẓ u'l-Kashifí (1854) [First published c. 1500]. The Anvar-i-Suhaili; or The Lights Of Canopus. Translated by Edward B. Eastwick. Stephen Austin.
- Jean-Claude Passeron (2001). "La forme des preuves dans les sciences historiques" [The form of evidence in the historical sciences]. Revue européenne des sciences sociales (in French). 39 (120): 31–76. doi:10.4000/ress.655.
- Lev Nitoburg (1933). Немецкая слобода [The German Quarter] (in Russian). Советская литература [Soviet literature].
- Martin Fitzgerald (2000). Orson Welles: The Pocket Essential Guide. Summersdale Publishers LTD - ROW. ISBN 9781848396807.
- Martin Litchfield West (1984). "The Ascription of Fables to Aesop in Archaic and Classical Greece" (PDF). In Olivier Reverdin (ed.). La Fable (Entretiens Sur L'Antiquité Classique vol. 30). Fondation Hardt.
- Maude Barrows Dutton (1908). The Tortoise and the Geese : and Other Fables of Bidpai. Houghton Mifflin Company.
- Sam Wasson (2011). A Splurch in the Kisser. The Movies of Blake Edwards. Middletown, Connecticut: Wesleyan University Press. p. 296. ISBN 9780819569776.
- Simon Callow (2015). Orson Welles, Volume 3: One-Man Band. Random House. ISBN 9781473545762.
- Stuart Lasine (2012). Weighing Hearts: Character, Judgment, and the Ethics of Reading the Bible. T & T Clark International. ISBN 9780567426741.
- Sylvia M. Vardell (2019). Children's Literature in Action: A Librarian's Guide (3 ed.). ABC-CLIO. ISBN 9781440867798.
- Thomas James (1852). "Fable 21 - The Mouse and the Frog (p. 14)". Aesop's Fables. A New Version, Chiefly From Original Sources. Illustrated by Sir John Tenniel. London: John Murray.