Armagh has 24 All Stars, as of 2008. 15 different players have won, as of 2008. No player has won more than three All Stars. denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1972: Paddy Moriarty
1977: Joe Kernan, Jimmy Smyth, Paddy Moriarty2nd
1980: Colum McKinstry
1982: Joe Kernan2nd
1993: Ger Houlahan
1999: Kieran McGeeney, Diarmaid Marsden
2000: Kieran McGeeney2nd, Oisín McConville
2002: Enda McNulty, Aidan O'Rourke, Kieran McGeeney 3rd, Paul McGrane, Stevie McDonnell, Oisín McConville2nd
2003: Francie Bellew, Stevie McDonnell 2nd
2005: Andy Mallon, Paul McGrane2nd, Stevie McDonnell3rd
2006: Rónán Clarke
2008: Rónán Clarke2nd