| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Extremely messy |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Extremely messy
|
| Article Series |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Article Series
|
| i don't get that 'witchcraft series' thing |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#i don't get that 'witchcraft series' thing
|
| Laws and regulations on witchcraft |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Laws and regulations on witchcraft
|
| Disputed tag |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Disputed tag
|
| Witchcraft and belief |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Witchcraft and belief
|
| Allegedly bigoted material |
48 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Allegedly bigoted material
|
| Witchcraft and the paranormal |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Witchcraft and the paranormal
|
| Possible copyright problem with this page |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Possible copyright problem with this page
|
| Witchcraft in film, fiction, news, etc. |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Witchcraft in film, fiction, news, etc.
|
| Needs research and clearer definitions |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Needs research and clearer definitions
|
| Merged from The Craft |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Merged from The Craft
|
| Lots of cleanup |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Lots of cleanup
|
| Messy article |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Messy article
|
| Let's clean up! |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Let's clean up!
|
| Removed "Who's Who" listing |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Removed "Who's Who" listing
|
| References for this statement |
21 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#References for this statement
|
| POV |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#POV
|
| Added witchcraft template |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Added witchcraft template
|
| Request for references |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Request for references
|
| DreamGuy, about that edit... |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#DreamGuy, about that edit...
|
| RfC |
18 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#RfC
|
| Split section |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Split section
|
| Removed Third Opinion and Wikiquette alert |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Removed Third Opinion and Wikiquette alert
|
| Reverted unsourced claim in intro |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Reverted unsourced claim in intro
|
| Witches - derived from belief in quasi-bacteria? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Witches - derived from belief in quasi-bacteria?
|
| The Craft != Witchcraft |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#The Craft != Witchcraft
|
| Science verdict: witchcraft does not exist. |
8 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Science verdict: witchcraft does not exist.
|
| The Term 'Supernatural' in Reference to Witchcraft |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#The Term 'Supernatural' in Reference to Witchcraft
|
| Separate into sections |
12 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Separate into sections
|
| Personal Vendetta edit and re-edit |
10 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Personal Vendetta edit and re-edit
|
| Jewish witchcraft: Magery? Jewitchery??! |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Jewish witchcraft: Magery? Jewitchery??!
|
| Reverted 23 January 2006 edits |
11 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Reverted 23 January 2006 edits
|
| Relevance? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Relevance?
|
| Code of Hammurabi!? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 1#Code of Hammurabi!?
|
| Warlock |
19 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Warlock
|
| Split? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Split?
|
| Famous Witches in History |
9 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Famous Witches in History
|
| Intro paragraph |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Intro paragraph
|
| Etymology |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Etymology
|
| Spell casting edits |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Spell casting edits
|
| New here |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#New here
|
| GA Re-Review and In-line citations |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#GA Re-Review and In-line citations
|
| External links |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#External links
|
| Recent inaccuracies in article |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Recent inaccuracies in article
|
| Overview |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Overview
|
| Presumption that witches actually exist |
22 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Presumption that witches actually exist
|
| spanish article differences |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#spanish article differences
|
| Reversion |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Reversion
|
| witches in popular culture |
9 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#witches in popular culture
|
| New photo |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#New photo
|
| Luck of the Irish |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Luck of the Irish
|
| "blah sense?" |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#"blah sense?"
|
| 'Modern practitioners' |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#'Modern practitioners'
|
| Taking exception: modern practitioners of "actual" witchcraft |
9 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Taking exception: modern practitioners of "actual" witchcraft
|
| Non-European witchcraft |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Non-European witchcraft
|
| Proposed external link |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Proposed external link
|
| Wicca = Cult irrelevant (& biased) in this article |
10 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Wicca = Cult irrelevant (& biased) in this article
|
| Proposed external link |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Proposed external link 2
|
| Merging info from Witch |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Merging info from Witch
|
| Witchcraft in Europe |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Witchcraft in Europe
|
| Etymology section |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Etymology section
|
| Merge Russian Witchcraft into Witchcraft |
6 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Merge Russian Witchcraft into Witchcraft
|
| Query re: Witchcraft and satanism |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Query re: Witchcraft and satanism
|
| "Historically anachronistic" |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#"Historically anachronistic"
|
| "Russian Witchcraft" |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#"Russian Witchcraft"
|
| Bloodsource |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Bloodsource
|
| Majority of accused witches were women |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Majority of accused witches were women
|
| My recent reversion of "essay" |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#My recent reversion of "essay"
|
| Lyblác |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Lyblác
|
| Witchcraft in popular culture |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 2#Witchcraft in popular culture
|
| additional material |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#additional material
|
| Suggestion |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Suggestion
|
| Add "Critical resources" section |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Add "Critical resources" section
|
| Majority of accused were women |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Majority of accused were women
|
| witches |
7 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#witches
|
| New bunch of witchcraft-related articles |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#New bunch of witchcraft-related articles
|
| Versnel qoute |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Versnel qoute
|
| Something needs to be added |
8 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Something needs to be added
|
| Has Anyone Heard of a Book Of Shadows,If so please reply!! |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Has Anyone Heard of a Book Of Shadows,If so please reply!!
|
| Witchcraft the religion |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Witchcraft the religion
|
| Is this article saying that Witchcraft is "real"? |
6 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Is this article saying that Witchcraft is "real"?
|
| Gray magic article |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Gray magic article
|
| Witchcraft not synonymous with sorcery |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Witchcraft not synonymous with sorcery
|
| Ælfric |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Ælfric
|
| New material |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#New material
|
| "Wizards" |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#"Wizards"
|
| "Good witches" |
9 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#"Good witches"
|
| "witchcraft, more broadly" |
6 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#"witchcraft, more broadly"
|
| An Intolerant Look at Witchcraft on Wikipedia |
10 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#An Intolerant Look at Witchcraft on Wikipedia
|
| Sources |
6 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Sources
|
| New First Sentence |
8 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#New First Sentence
|
| The Wide World of Daoism |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#The Wide World of Daoism
|
| European witchcraft |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#European witchcraft
|
| Pointy hats |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 3#Pointy hats
|
| Last trial in England |
9 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Last trial in England
|
| New article Witch (magic), overlap? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#New article Witch (magic), overlap?
|
| Just Wondering But |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Just Wondering But
|
| Warlocks |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Warlocks
|
| Saudi Arabia witch-hunt |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Saudi Arabia witch-hunt
|
| Removal of links to See also, Sex magic and the Great Rite |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Removal of links to See also, Sex magic and the Great Rite
|
| guys, plz |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#guys, plz
|
| This article is not accurate in the least |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#This article is not accurate in the least
|
| Grammar |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Grammar
|
| Citation? |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Citation?
|
| History vs. historiography |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#History vs. historiography
|
| No source? |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#No source?
|
| In Our Time |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#In Our Time
|
| Sources |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Sources
|
| Racist comment? |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Racist comment?
|
| Knights Templar trial connection to witch-trials? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Knights Templar trial connection to witch-trials?
|
| Relevance of polytheistic reconstructionism? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Relevance of polytheistic reconstructionism?
|
| Removed an essay about cunning folk vs witches |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Removed an essay about cunning folk vs witches
|
| Anyone can practice witchcraft |
12 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Anyone can practice witchcraft
|
| Were there any witches between 600 AD and 1870? |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Were there any witches between 600 AD and 1870?
|
| Djambe redirect |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Djambe redirect
|
| Japanese witchcraft |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Japanese witchcraft
|
| Removal of inappropriate categories |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Removal of inappropriate categories
|
| Can this be worked into the Africa section? |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Can this be worked into the Africa section?
|
| Witchcraft |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Witchcraft
|
| Irreligion section sketchy, Removed it until someone can have a look at it. |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Irreligion section sketchy, Removed it until someone can have a look at it.
|
| Pharmakeia article needs help..... |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Pharmakeia article needs help.....
|
| How about splitting this article? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#How about splitting this article?
|
| Spiritual healing |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Spiritual healing
|
| differences of all magic titles!!! |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#differences of all magic titles!!!
|
| Copyright problem removed |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Copyright problem removed
|
| Russia section |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Russia section
|
| Non-global representation in intro |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Non-global representation in intro
|
| German .. |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#German ..
|
| Review of the Witchcraft in Italy |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Review of the Witchcraft in Italy
|
| Adding in the relation of witchcraft, feminism, and the media |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Adding in the relation of witchcraft, feminism, and the media
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#External links modified
|
| Canon Episcopi |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#Canon Episcopi
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#External links modified 2
|
| In-universe language |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#In-universe language
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 4#External links modified 3
|
| Witch and witchcraft: two Wikidata items, and a problem |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Witch and witchcraft: two Wikidata items, and a problem
|
| About Withcraft |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#About Withcraft
|
| Canada witchcraft AD 2018 |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Canada witchcraft AD 2018
|
| The use of "white peoples" term |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#The use of "white peoples" term
|
| Intro should more clearly state that witchcraft is a belief |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Intro should more clearly state that witchcraft is a belief
|
| Requesting help in article expansion |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Requesting help in article expansion
|
| “Witch” refers to a woman. Say so. |
12 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#“Witch” refers to a woman. Say so.
|
| Pop culture claim |
11 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Pop culture claim
|
| Missing perspectives: Unjust persecution of witches through the centuries; and fiction versus nonfiction |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Missing perspectives: Unjust persecution of witches through the centuries; and fiction versus nonfiction
|
| Support for Witches and Literary Stereotypes of Women |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Support for Witches and Literary Stereotypes of Women
|
| rules of witchcraft |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#rules of witchcraft
|
| Edits to introduction |
7 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Edits to introduction
|
| Section on contemporary depictions |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Section on contemporary depictions
|
| Harm |
6 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Harm
|
| Fairies are real and only the identification of them as demons is wrong? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Fairies are real and only the identification of them as demons is wrong?
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 2
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 3
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 4
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 5
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 18 January 2022 |
24 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 18 January 2022
|
| A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 7 March 2022 |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 7 March 2022
|
| Allow editing to remove obvious bias |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Allow editing to remove obvious bias
|
| Semi-protection |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Semi-protection
|
| Witchcraft is not intended to “harm others”. It is intended for personal power! |
16 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Witchcraft is not intended to “harm others”. It is intended for personal power!
|
| Short description |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Short description
|
| I'm sure others are offended too... |
6 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#I'm sure others are offended too...
|
| Witch craft is not evil! |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Witch craft is not evil!
|
| Inaccurate |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Inaccurate
|
| Witchcraft |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Witchcraft
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 2 April 2023 |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 2 April 2023
|
| Changes without consensus |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Changes without consensus
|
| Ridiculous! |
103 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 8#Ridiculous!
|
| Underscores |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Underscores
|
| Short description |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Short description
|
| Witchcraft is not meant for harm |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 5#Witchcraft is not meant for harm
|
| Proposal |
76 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 7#Proposal
|
| Islam section |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Islam section
|
| What, no mention of the TV fantasy drama "Charmed"? |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#What, no mention of the TV fantasy drama "Charmed"?
|
| Requested move 19 July 2023 |
45 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Requested move 19 July 2023
|
| Is this a WP:BROADCONCEPT article or not? |
32 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Is this a WP:BROADCONCEPT article or not?
|
| Systemic bias |
64 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 9#Systemic bias
|
| British or American spelling? |
7 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#British or American spelling?
|
| Mystical |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Mystical
|
| Summing Up the Problem |
34 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Summing Up the Problem
|
| More discussion about the lede |
6 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#More discussion about the lede
|
| Statements that all Neopagan Witches are Wiccan are Unsourced |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 10#Statements that all Neopagan Witches are Wiccan are Unsourced
|
| Knowledge, Belief, and Witchcraft |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Knowledge, Belief, and Witchcraft
|
| Case opened on dispute resolution noticeboard |
8 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Case opened on dispute resolution noticeboard
|
| Is magic real? |
10 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 6#Is magic real?
|
| Article length |
22 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 9#Article length
|
| "Stereotyped" |
3 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 7#"Stereotyped"
|
| Please be aware of the DRN rules and moderator advice |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 9#Please be aware of the DRN rules and moderator advice
|
| I know that ChatGPT gets a bad press |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 9#I know that ChatGPT gets a bad press
|
| RFC on Lede Section on Witchcraft |
116 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 10#RFC on Lede Section on Witchcraft
|
| Wikipedia is now COMPLETELY DISCREDITED |
36 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 9#Wikipedia is now COMPLETELY DISCREDITED
|
| Origin of witches |
15 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 9#Origin of witches
|
| Article organization |
9 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 9#Article organization
|
| Witchcraft in Africa |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 9#Witchcraft in Africa
|
| Sourced Material Not Covered |
15 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 11#Sourced Material Not Covered
|
| US survey |
7 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 10#US survey
|
| Movement of sections to after by region |
20 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 10#Movement of sections to after by region
|
| Indigenous traditions suppressed as 'witchcraft' |
13 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 10#Indigenous traditions suppressed as 'witchcraft'
|
| Historical order |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 10#Historical order
|
| Hutton re Africa and Melanesia: "harm", "power" |
19 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 11#Hutton re Africa and Melanesia: "harm", "power"
|
| North America Indigenous is now unsourced |
7 |
Talk:Witchcraft/Archive 11#North America Indigenous is now unsourced
|
| Ancient Roman world |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft#Ancient Roman world
|
| Rewording of first sentence |
5 |
Talk:Witchcraft#Rewording of first sentence
|
| Sources |
2 |
Talk:Witchcraft#Sources
|
| Notice of ANI discussion |
1 |
Talk:Witchcraft#Notice of ANI discussion
|
| The logic of the opening sentence |
4 |
Talk:Witchcraft#The logic of the opening sentence
|
