Talk:The Naked Brothers Band (TV series)/GA3

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: TBrandley (talk · contribs) 15:56, 26 August 2012 (UTC)

Way to many [citation needed] templates for GAN right now, and way too much clean-up. I also found a handful from just a quick view. Quick fail. Here are somethings you can work on though, and other reasonings for the quick fail:

• Add references to the citation needed templates, much further reference problems, no references at all in some sections
• Expand the article itself
• WP:MOS recommends using straight prose rather than bulleted and numbered lists where feasible. That being said, I see way too many tables and not enough text.
• All uses of "#" in this article, other than inside tables, should be "No.", as per WP:POUND
• Big problem is crew section. Much unneeded trivia, that, as seen above, should use straight prose rather than bulleted. One example is coordinating producer, very unneeded trivia. Unneeded per WP:MOS. Only key crew are the executive producers, regular producers, writers, director. Most others, and all unneeded trivia.
• Special appearances same as above
• A regular - should an en-dash, –, as per WP:MOS
• TV Ratings should be in reception, not episodes
• Remove flags as per MOS:FLAG.
• MOS:BOLD issues.
• "film"? It is a TV show.

I'm sorry to quick fail this. Please try to add a bunch of reference, remove pointless trivia, and use straight prose rather than bulleted. Those issues are most key. Most references that are there, like IMDb, are not "high-quality" enough for Wikipedia, per WP:RS. Sorry. TBrandley 15:56, 26 August 2012 (UTC)