Talk:Malkin Tower/GA1
Latest comment: 11 years ago by Mark Arsten in topic GA Review
GA Review edit
GA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Mark Arsten (talk · contribs) 19:31, 26 August 2012 (UTC)
- Will review, comments to follow in the next couple days. Mark Arsten (talk) 19:31, 26 August 2012 (UTC)
- Alright, pretty interesting read--haunted witch towers in the forest and all. The article is in good shape, just a few quibbles about wording and punctuation, then I'll pass this. Mark Arsten (talk) 20:13, 27 August 2012 (UTC)
Lead
- You might want to link Black Moss Reservoir in the lead image caption.
- "Despite several archaeological excavations in the area no remains have yet been discovered." I would suggest adding a comma after "area", and maybe removing "yet". Also, it seems that there were remains of a potential candidate discovered by the water engineers, would it make sense to state that no confirmed remains were found but candidates have been offered?
- Instead of linking Thomas Potts to The Wonderfull Discoverie of Witches in the Countie of Lancaster, I'd like "the official account" or write it out.
- "Malkin Tower was likely to have been a simple cottage rather than a tower." I'd consider ending the sentence after "cottage".
- "sometimes called Malking Tower, or Mocking Tower," do you need the first comma here?
History
- "a word used to describe a lower-class woman or slut" Is "slut" a formal enough term to use here? (Honestly not sure.)
- "it is almost certain that Southerns and Device did not own Malkin Tower, but were tenants of the property." I'd consider removing the comma here.
- "When Nowell learned of the meeting he concluded after examining Alizon Device's "mentally sub-normal" brother, James, that Malkin Tower had been the scene of a witches' coven" Let me see if I have this right. So he learned of the meeting, then asked James Device about it, and then concluded that the meeting was a coven?
- "an old cat, as in "grimalkin" or "grey malkin"," Do you need the middle comma here?
- Probably not, so I've removed it.
Location
- "The building may also have been destroyed in order to eradicate the "melancholy associations" of the place." You might want to remove "in order" here.
- You use "not uncommon" a couple times in the article, I'd suggest switching one to "common".
- "but only describes it as being in the Forest of Pendle, a former royal forest that covered a considerable area south and east of Pendle Hill" Was it a former royal forest at the time of writing, or did it cease to be a royal forest afterwards?
- My understanding is that Pendle Forest, which was part of the Honour of Clitheroe, was disafforested in 1507, more than 100 years before the trials of the Pendle witches. I've added a note to explain. Malleus Fatuorum 02:20, 28 August 2012 (UTC)
- "The primary evidence supporting this location seems to be that a hollow in the hillside east of the farm is known as Mawkin Hole." I'm not sure about the use of "seems to be" here, it sounds like it's clear that that is the primary evidence, or am I mistaken?
- "It is suggested that this is the same place..." I presume it is suggested by local folklore, right?
- "the same place mentioned in the 16th-century halmote court records" Could you clarify what a "halmote court" is?
- It would be nice one day to be able to rely on decent supporting articles, but that day seems a long way off. Anyway, a halmote court is a type of manorial court, also called a court customary. We don't have an article on that, so what I've done is to link halmote court to manor court for now, which I'll expand tomorrow to cover halmote court and the other types of manorial courts. Malleus Fatuorum 01:49, 28 August 2012 (UTC)
- "A potential candidate for the lost Malkin Tower was announced in December 2011, after water engineers unearthed a 17th-century cottage complete with a mummified cat sealed in the walls, close to Lower Black Moss reservoir near Barley." What is the significance of the mummified cat here?
- "Douglas claims there is "persuasive" evidence that an area near Sadler's Farm (now known as Shekinah Christian Centre) was the site of Malkin Tower" Is the area near the farm known as Shekinah Christian Centre, or is it that Shekinah Christian Centre is the new name for the farm?
- "but anywhere inside the manor of Colne would be outside the Forest of Pendle." Would "but every location inside the manor of Colne is outside the Forest of Pendle." be an improvement here?
- "old masonry found in one of the field walls is said to be from the remains of the building." Would "old masonry found in a field wall is said to be from the remains of the building." be an improvement here?
References
- You mention a "smallholding" in note b, you might want to link that.
- A couple books in the Bibliography don't have locations, you might want to standardise that if you can.
- Not a big deal, but you might want to add an OCLC for the Farrer source.
Other
- Dabs, links, source reliablity, image licensing, etc. are all fine.
- Spotchecked the Guardian and BBC sources, no issues there. Mark Arsten (talk) 20:13, 27 August 2012 (UTC)
- Alright, the remaining bullets are fairly trivial, and I'm satisfied with the fixes, so I'm passing this now. Good work! Mark Arsten (talk) 13:47, 28 August 2012 (UTC)