Talk:Halloween (The Office)/GA1

GA Review

Unfortunately, I think this article does not meet the GA criteria. Although it is reasonably well-written, it's simply not broad enough in its coverage to meet 3a, which states that the article must addresses the main aspects of the topic. The article contains only three sections: plot synopsis, production, and reception. The production section is skimpy at best, containing only minor information about the writer and trivia about the closing credits and Devon. Similarly, the reception section is relatively lacking, with only statistics about Nielsen ratings and a few comments from TV reviewers.

I'm certainly not blaming the article writer(s)—this is a decent B-class article—but I simply don't believe there are enough raw sources to flesh out this article enough to be a GA. This is also why I am failing it now, rather than simply putting it on hold, because the issues are with content and a lack of sources, rather than style. Mr. Absurd (talk) 02:25, 20 August 2008 (UTC)