Talk:Fish in a Drawer/GA1

Latest comment: 16 years ago by Gary King in topic GA Review

GA Review

edit

This article fails to meet the Good Article criteria and has therefore failed. Issues include:

  • Lead is too short. Insufficient information in the lead on Plot and Reception.
  • Please break up Plot into more than one, big paragraph.
  • Production looks good, but again, perhaps break it up into more than one paragraph.
  • References go after punctuation per WP:FN.
  • Reception section needs to be significantly expanded to include reception information, Nielson Ratings, etc. Please look at other episode articles at WP:GAN for a better idea.
  • "Cultural References" section needs to be referenced; also, these types of references are strongly discouraged, unless the references are significant. Prose is preferable to bulleted points.

Gary King (talk) 18:50, 13 July 2008 (UTC)Reply