Talk:Emma Kaili Metcalf Beckley Nakuina/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Tbhotch (talk · contribs) 16:54, 23 February 2019 (UTC)

GA review – see WP:WIAGA for criteria

1. Is it reasonably well written?

   A. Prose quality (prose is clear and concise, without exceeding quotations, or spelling and grammar errors):

   B. MoS compliance (included, but not limited to: lead, layout, words to watch, fiction, and lists):

2. Is it factually accurate and verifiable?

   A. References to sources (it also includes an appropriate reference section):

   B. Citation of reliable sources where necessary (including direct quotations):

   C. No original research:

   D. No copyright violations:

3. Is it broad in its coverage?

   A. Major aspects:

   B. Focused:

4. Is it neutral?

   Fair representation without bias:

5. Is it stable?

   edit wars, multiple edits not related to the GAN process, etc. (this excludes blatant vandalism):

6. Does it contain images (or other media) to illustrate (or support) the topic?

   A. Images (and other media) are copyright tagged, and non-free images have fair use rationales:

   B. Images (and other media) are provided where possible and are relevant, with suitable captions:

7. Overall:

   Pass or Fail:

Resolved comments from Tbhotch

;Images File:Emma M Nakuina Signature 1904.svg has a CC-BY-SA-4.0 license, which is valid for the uploader's re-creation. However, it misses the copyright status for the signature itself. Done. Infobox Spouse(s) Frederick William Beckley Sr. -> see {{marriage}} Done. Spouse(s) Moses Kuaea Nakuina -> see {{marriage}} Done. Children "and others" -> Ambiguous Fred Beckley is the only one worth mentioning in the infobox. The other children are not noteworthy. Lead Too short for WP:LEAD Done. If you are not going to create Hawaiian National Museum soon, remove it Sorry, I've been encouraged to red link relevant articles in past GA and FA reviews. Unless used frivolously, it is a perfectly okay according to policy. See Wikipedia:Red link. Early life Kaua'ala -> Kauaʻala Done. Her mother Kaʻilikapuolono was -> Her mother, Kaʻilikapuolono, was Done. "descendant of the aliʻi lineages of Oahu associated with the Kūkaniloko Birthstones" -> It is missing something to be clear Changed. "highest ranking chiefs" -> "highest-ranking chiefs" Done. "where the highest ranking chiefs of the islands were once born ... Kamehameha I during his conquest of the Hawaiian Islands." -> I find this line irrelevant to Nakuina Ancestry is crucial to the identity of a Hawaiian in the 19th-century and Kamehameha I was the defining figure of the age, thus connecting Nakuina to be a descendant of a chief under the service of the conqueror king. If you are not going to create Moses Kuaea, remove the link Same as above. Career "The salary from this governmental post help her support her children" -> tense Done. "Hawaii's first female judge.[13][14][8][15]" -> see also WP:CITEKILL Changed. See also The link List of first women lawyers and judges in Hawaii should be mentioned instead at the lead and at "regarded as Hawaii's first female judge" Changed. Bibliography "Harper, Ida Husted, ed." -> Did you mean "et al."? No ed is for editor. There is no accredited author for the given section about Hawaii. Taylor, Albert Pierce (1926) -> unlink it, as repeated Changed. Yasutake, Rumi (2017) -> You're missing author 2 Yasutake was the only other of the journal article used. Choy and Wu are editors of the entire piece. KAVEBEAR (talk) 23:02, 2 March 2019 (UTC) Categories Order them alphanumerically Is that a policy? I have never heard such a request. WP:CATORDER mentions it is not a rule, but having any particular order is helpful. The categories go: politician, politician, nobility, alumni, origin, alumni, nobility, writer, writer, writer, judge, curator, politician, politician, date, date. If you'd argue the categories are in disorder because of a semantic field-style I wouldn't mind, but the current order isn't helpful. Done. KAVEBEAR (talk) 00:57, 5 March 2019 (UTC)

Name

• For what I've read, "Emma Kaili Metcalf Beckley Nakuina" is not her WP:COMMONAME

• This is the version used in Notable Women of Hawaii and American Women Historians, 1700s-1990s: A Biographical Dictionary. There is no consistent usage. Calling her simply Emma Nakuina would be wrong given the importance of her first marriage and her own maiden name. KAVEBEAR (talk) 23:07, 2 March 2019 (UTC)

• Giving her her full name gives the wrong impression her (almost) full name is her common name, when it's based on 1-2 sources. © Tbhotch^™ (en-2.5). 21:10, 3 March 2019 (UTC)

• What do you suggest? Don’t know what you mean by almost since Kaili is merely the shorten form of Kaʻilikapuolono. KAVEBEAR (talk) 00:57, 5 March 2019 (UTC)

• I'll take it to RM instead, as I'm as divided as the sources are. © Tbhotch^™ (en-2.5). 14:56, 5 March 2019 (UTC)

Article on hold. © Tbhotch^™ (en-2.5). 02:23, 2 March 2019 (UTC)

Not having any other objection, I pass its nomination. Good work. © Tbhotch^™ (en-2.5). 14:56, 5 March 2019 (UTC)