Talk:2009 Giro d'Italia, Stage 1 to Stage 11/GA1

GA Review edit

Latest comment: 14 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
1. Well-written?

In last paragraph of lead section, please define queen stage to the average reader.
For all prose in article, please list nationalities of all riders the first time they are mentioned.
On all length, please include conversion of kilometer to mile, meter to foot, and kph to mph to non-metric users in the English Wikipedia.
For Stage 1 - please spell out TTT.
On all team results, please list team nationalities. I realize these teams have multiple riders from different nations, but the teams has a home base. In Formula 1 motorsports as an example, people know Ferrari is from Italy even though the drivers that have worked for them have in some cases not been from Italy (Michael Schumacher from Germany and Kimi Räikkönen are recent examples of this.).
For Stage 4, please create articles for San Martino di Castrozza and Serafin Martinez.
For Stage 10, the last sentence of the first paragraph seems confusing. Did Fausto Coppi win the stage in 1949 and if so, when? Was this course exact. For the first sentence of the third paragraph, what does "going clear" mean? On the second sentence of the third paragraph, what does "came clear" mean? On the first sentence of the fourth paragraph, please spell out GC.
For Stage 11, please create articles for Alessandro Donati and Vladimir Isaichev
For See also section, what else is in there printed out. I see the template on screen, but not printed out. Shouldn't this template be moved after the references?

2. Factually accurate and verifiable?

3. Broad in coverage?

4. Neutral?

5. Stable?

6. Images?

On the Infobox for the tour map, the image looks fuzzy. Also, what do the red and green lines siginify on the map?

7. Overall.

Good article. Needs work, but the article is there once it is fixed. Chris (talk) 18:31, 7 September 2009 (UTC)Reply