The Trans-Fly–Bulaka River aka South-Central Papuan languages form a hypothetical family of Papuan languages. They include many of the languages west of the Fly River in southern Papua New Guinea into southern Indonesian West Papua, plus a pair of languages on the Bulaka River a hundred km further west.
| Trans-Fly–Bulaka River | |
|---|---|
| South-Central Papuan | |
| (obsolete) | |
| Geographic distribution | New Guinea |
| Linguistic classification | Proposed language family |
| Subdivisions | |
| Glottolog | None |
 Map: The Trans-Fly–Bulaka River languages of New Guinea
The Trans-Fly–Bulaka River languages
Trans–New Guinea languages
Other Papuan languages
Austronesian languages
Australian languages
Uninhabited | |
The family was posited by Stephen Wurm as a branch of his 1975 Trans–New Guinea proposal. Wurm thought it likely that many of these languages would prove to not actually belong to Trans–New Guinea, but rather to have been heavily influenced by Trans–New Guinea languages. Malcolm Ross (2005) concurred, and removed most of them.
Classification edit
None of the families are closely related; indeed, it is difficult to demonstrate a link between any of them. Wurm's 1975 TNG branch included the following eight demonstrated families:
- Kiwaian, on the banks and east of the Fly River
- Waia, north of the Fly delta
- Tirio, on the western bank of the Fly River
- Eastern Trans-Fly languages, south of the Fly delta
- Pahoturi, west of the Eastern languages
- Yam, up to and just across the Indonesian border
- Moraori, between Upper Maro and the Marind language
- Bulaka River, west of Marind
Ross (2005) accepted the TNG identity of Tirio, Moraori, and, tentatively, Kiwaian. He split off the four Eastern Trans-Fly languages as an independent family. The remainder of the family, which he calls South-Central Papuan, is only tentatively retained: their pronouns are suggestive of a relationship, but this has not been demonstrated.
Trans-Fly–Bulaka River
(South-Central Papuan) |
| |||||||||
A more conservative approach would break up Wurm's Trans-Fly–Bulaka River entirely, with two or three of the families remaining within Trans–New Guinea, and five or six being independent. Evans (2012), for example, argues that the inclusion of the Yam language at least is not justified on present evidence. Timothy Usher treats the Bulaka River and Yam languages as separate families, and links the Pahoturi– clade to the Eastern Trans-Fly languages.
Southern New Guinea linguistic area edit
A Southern New Guinea linguistic area, which spans both Indonesia and Papua New Guinea, consisting of the following families is mentioned in Evans (2018).[1]
- Yelmek-Maklew - 500 speakers
- Yam (Morehead-Upper Maro) - 3,000 speakers
- Pahoturi River - just over 4,000 speakers
- Oriomo (Eastern Trans-Fly) - 6,500 speakers
- Trans-New Guinea (TNG)
Languages within the Southern New Guinea linguistic area generally share these typological features.[1]
- lack of tone (except Kuni-Boazi, possibly Marind, and some Kiwai dialects)
- complex verb morphology
- limited or no gender (except for the four-way gender system in Anim languages, and the masculine vs. feminine contrast on undergoer-prefixes in the Tonda languages and some Oriomo languages)
- lack of verb chaining or switch-reference
- single-word verbs form an open class
Pronouns edit
The pronouns Ross reconstructs for the three families he keeps together are suggestively similar, but it has not been possible to reconstruct common forms:
- Proto-Yam (Proto–Morehead – Upper Maro)
I/we *ni you *bu s/he/they *be
- Proto-Pahoturi
I *ŋa-na we ? thou *ba or *be you *-bi s/he *bo they ?
- Proto-Bulaka River
I *ŋöl we *ŋag thou *ob you *el s/he *ib they *im
Lexical comparison edit
The lexical data below is from the Trans-New Guinea database[2] and Usher (2020) (for Proto-Kiwai),[3] unless noted otherwise. Neighboring languages not traditionally classified within Trans-Fly – Bulaka River are also included for comparison.
| family | language | head | hair | ear | eye | nose | tooth | tongue | leg | blood | bone | skin | breast |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trans-New Guinea | Proto-Trans-New Guinea | *kobutu; *kV(mb,p)utu; *mUtUna; *mVtVna | *iti; *(nd,s)umu(n,t)[V]; *zumun | *ka(nd,t)(i,e)C; *kat(i,e)C; *tVmV(d) | *g(a,u)mu; *ŋg(a,u)mu; *(ŋg,k)iti [maŋgV]; *nVpV | *mundu; *mutu | *magata; *maŋgat[a]; *titi | *balaŋ; *mbilaŋ; *me(l,n)e; *me(n,l)e | *kani(n); *k(a,o)ond(a,o)C; *kitu | *ke(ñj,s)a; *kesa | *kondaC; *kwata(l,n) | *gatapu; *(ŋg,k)a(nd,t)apu | *amu |
| Komolom | Koneraw | wonderam | cin | dyan | cire | kan | iri | iŋar | par | ||||
| Komolom | Mombum | wondrum | xu-sin | musax-nam | zix | kaŋk | iri | itöx | par | ||||
| Yelmek-Maklew | Maklew | ala | aweni | opo | köl | wodo | ehlel | pu | ase | ||||
| Yelmek-Maklew | Yelmek | bemo | yeyu | opo | köl | wodo | elweke | pu | ge | momo | |||
| Yam | Kanum | mel | mel-kata | si | tor | tegu | mbel | mba:r | keikei | ||||
| Yam | Yei | kilpel | peab | cur | ter | cere | gul | gor | pa:r | ||||
| Karami | Karami[4] | epurupa | kuse | epegu | wodi | saku | muta | auni | toki | goni | kebora | bodoro | |
| Gogodala-Suki | Gogodala | ganabi | tita | igibi | tao | mina | poso | mɛlɛpila | gosa | kaka | omo | ||
| Kiwaian | Proto-Kiwai[3] | *kepuɾu | *mus[ua] | *gaɾe | *idomaɾi | *wodi | *ibo(-nVɾV) | *uototoɾo[p/b]e | *sakiɾo | *kaɾima; *sa[w]i | *soɾo | *tama | *amo |
| family | language | louse | dog | pig | bird | egg | tree | sun | moon | water | fire | stone | path |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trans-New Guinea | Proto-Trans-New Guinea | *niman | *n(e,i); *n(e)i; *n[e]i; *yak; *yaka[i]; *yanem | *maŋgV; *munaka; *mun(a,u)ka | *ida; *inda ~ *iñja | *kamali; *kamuli; *ketana | *kal(a,i)m; *kamali; *takVn; *takVn[V] | *nok; *(n)ok; *ok(u); *ok[V] | *inda; *k(a,e)dap; *k(a,e)(n,d)ap; *kambu; *k(a,o)nd(a,u)p | *kamb(a,u)na; *(na)muna; *[na]muna | |||
| Komolom | Koneraw | am | ubui | u | baŋa | to | dzuwo | mui | war | mate | |||
| Komolom | Mombum | am | ipwi | u | konji | yausil | tu | zawa | mwe | wad | mete | ||
| Yelmek-Maklew | Maklew | dobuna | ŋgat | milom | aebola | aloŋ | doyo | olimu | jü | ake | mate | ||
| Yelmek-Maklew | Yelmek | dobna | num | milom | tötöli | alo | doyo | alemu | ju | ete | mata | ||
| Yam | Kanum | ne:mpin | krar | kwer | sento | bel | per | koŋko | ataka | mens | melle | ||
| Yam | Yei | nim | jeu | becek | yarmaker | mekur | per | mir | kao | benj | mejer | ||
| Karami | Karami | sugani | kso | giromoi | kaimo | sumari | aimea | kuwiri | auwo | mavio | agabu | ige | |
| Gogodala-Suki | Gogodala | ami | soke | uai | kadɛpa | wi | ila | nabidi | |||||
| Kiwaian | Proto-Kiwai | *nimo | *[k]umu | *wowogo | *kikopu | *nuk₂a; *kota | *saɾik₂i; *si[w]io | *sagomi; *owe | *kobo | *keɾa | *(nok₂oɾa-)kopi | *gabo |
| family | language | man | woman | name | eat | one | two |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trans-New Guinea | Proto-Trans-New Guinea | *abV; *ambi | *panV; *pan(V) | *ibi; *imbi; *wani | *na; *na- | *ta(l,t)(a,e) | |
| Komolom | Koneraw | nam | ur | gim-nugu | tenamotere | kuinam | |
| Komolom | Mombum | nam | ur | nuku- | te | kumb | |
| Yelmek-Maklew | Maklew | modin | ŋeŋele | oŋa -eio- | mepola | inage | |
| Yelmek-Maklew | Yelmek | gomnek | ŋadöl | ŋa- | ŋklala | ina | |
| Yam | Kanum | ire | iu | anaŋ | namper | yempoka | |
| Yam | Yei | el-lu | ore | cenye | nampei | yetapae | |
| Karami | Karami | sor | kipa | botie | kipainoe | ||
| Gogodala-Suki | Gogodala | dala; dalagi | ato; susɛgi | gagi | na | ||
| Kiwaian | Proto-Kiwai | *dubu | *oɾobo; *upi | *paini, *paina | *oɾuso (sg.), *iɾiso (pl.) | *nak[o/u] | *netoa |
See also edit
References edit
- ^ a b Evans, Nicholas (2018). "The languages of Southern New Guinea". In Palmer, Bill (ed.). The Languages and Linguistics of the New Guinea Area: A Comprehensive Guide. The World of Linguistics. Vol. 4. Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton. pp. 641–774. ISBN 978-3-11-028642-7.
- ^ Greenhill, Simon (2016). "TransNewGuinea.org - database of the languages of New Guinea". Retrieved 2020-11-05.
- ^ a b Usher, Timothy (2020). "New Guinea World". Archived from the original on 2022-12-16. Retrieved 2020-12-31.
- ^ Flint, L. A. 1919. Vocabularies: Daru station, Western Division. Papua. Annual Report for the Year 1917‒18, 96. The Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia.
- Ross, Malcolm (2005). "Pronouns as a preliminary diagnostic for grouping Papuan languages". In Andrew Pawley; Robert Attenborough; Robin Hide; Jack Golson (eds.). Papuan pasts: cultural, linguistic and biological histories of Papuan-speaking peoples. Canberra: Pacific Linguistics. pp. 15–66. ISBN 0858835622. OCLC 67292782.