Salary history bans refer to policies, adopted mostly in the United States, that ban employers from asking job candidates about their previous salaries. The purpose of these laws is the reduce the impact of historical discrimination.[1] As of January 2021, nineteen American states and twenty-one American municipalities have adopted some form of a salary history ban.[2] The first salary history ban was passed in Massachusetts in August 2016.[3]
Salary history bans forbid employers from asking candidates their salary histories. However, the bans do not forbid workers from volunteering their salaries. This raises the possibility of adverse selection, in which only workers with good salaries volunteer (and workers with bad salaries decline to answer). Voluntary disclosure also raises the possibility of unravelling,[4] in which one person volunteering creates incentives for others to volunteer. In principle, this could lead to a full unravelling of salary history bans in which all workers disclose (despite the ban on employers asking).
Salary history bans have been found to be effective in reducing pay gap between men and women. Research suggests that these bans reduced the gender pay gap by 2 percentage points in states which have these bans in place.[5]
The behavioral research in 2020 about salary disclosure behavior suggests that about 25% of job-seekers would volunteer their prior salaries, even if not asked, and that bans would partially (if not fully) unravel.[6]
References
edit- ^ Wong, Kristin (22 October 2019). "Don't Ask Me About My Salary History". The New York Times.
- ^ "A running list of states and localities that have outlawed pay history questions".
- ^ "Chapter 177 of the Acts of 2016: An Act to Establish Pay Equity".
- ^ Milgrom, Paul R. (1981). "Good News and Bad News: Representation Theorems and Applications". The Bell Journal of Economics. 12 (2): 380–391. doi:10.2307/3003562. JSTOR 3003562.
- ^ Sinha, Sourav (2019-08-20). "Salary History Ban: Gender Pay Gap and Spillover Effects". Rochester, NY. SSRN 3458194.
{{cite journal}}
: Cite journal requires|journal=
(help) - ^ Agan, Amanda; Cowgill, Bo; Gee, Laura (2020). "Do Workers Comply with Salary History Bans? A Survey on Voluntary Disclosure, Adverse Selection, and Unraveling". AEA Papers and Proceedings. 110: 215–219. doi:10.1257/pandp.20201123. S2CID 216549665.