Sacramento River massacre
The Sacramento River massacre refers to the killing of several hundred Wintu people on the banks of the Sacramento River on 5 April 1846 by an expedition band led by Captain John C. Frémont of Virginia.
The expansionist movement of the 1840s motivated many Americans to work to push America's borders out into land claimed by Spain, Mexico, Britain, and Native American tribes. "Manifest Destiny", a term coined by journalist John O'Sullivan, captured the idea that the young American nation was destined to rule all of the North American continent.
Democratic Senator Thomas Hart Benton of Missouri was a prominent leader of this movement, into which he enlisted his son-in-law, John C. Frémont. Benton obtained government funding for several expeditions led by Frémont to map and explore the western territory.
In 1845, Captain Frémont was sent by the War Department on an expedition to survey the central Rockies. Frémont disobeyed orders and headed straight to California, a possession of Mexico, motivated by the desire to obtain "fame and power" in the American seizure of California that President James Polk had personally told him was imminent. Upon arriving in California, Frémont and his men moved about the northern half of the state for several months, provoking the Mexican authorities and building up patriotic sentiment among Americans who had settled there.
On 30 March 1846, the band arrived at the Lassen Ranch in the upper Sacramento Valley. There they met Americans who claimed that an encampment of Indians was preparing to attack White settlers. Frémont moved his men up the Sacramento River in search of such Indians. The party reached Reading's Ranch (near present-day Redding, California) on 5 April 1846 and spotted a large Indian camp, likely of the Wintu tribe.
Captain Frémont ordered an advance on the Indians, with every one of his men carrying a rifle, two pistols, and a knife. The Wintu were unable to flee the camp as the majority of their ranks were women and children and they were pinned against the river. The men of the Wintu camp formed a defensive line with the women and children behind them.
Expedition member Thomas E. Breckenridge states that "the order was given to ask no quarter and to give none." Frémont's men lined up and began firing several rifle volleys, slaughtering the Indians in front of them. The long range of the rifles rendered it impossible for the Indians' arrows to reach them. The men then approached towards the camp, fired another volley at closer range, and rushed in with their sabers and pistols. Breckenridge writes:
The settlers charged into the village taking the warriors by surprise and then commenced a scene of slaughter which is unequalled in the West. The bucks, squaws and paposes were shot down like sheep and those men never stopped as long as they could find one alive.
The remaining Indians were forced to flee, with some running for the hills and others braving the river. Eyewitness William Isaac Tustin reports that men of Frémont's band mounted on horses chased down the running Indians and tomahawked them to death, while riflemen stood on the shores of the river and took potshots at the Indians trying to swim to safety. He described the scene as "a slaughter."
Estimates of the casualties vary. Expedition members Thomas E. Breckenridge and Thomas S. Martin claim the number of Indians killed as "120-150" and "over 175" respectively, but the eyewitness Tustin claimed that at least 600-700 Indians were killed on land, with another 200 or more dying in the water. There are no records of any expedition members being killed or even wounded in the massacre. Kit Carson, one of the mounted attackers, later stated, "It was a perfect butchery." Breckenridge, who claims not to have participated, laments:
I think that I hate an Indian as badly as anybody and have as good reason to hate them, but I don't think that I could have assisted in that slaughter. It takes two to fight or quarrel but in that case there was but one side fighting and the other side trying to escape.
Neither Frémont nor any of his expedition members were charged or punished in any way for the killings. Several expedition members suggested that the massacre led local Indians to fear the White men and avoid raiding the settlements and ranches that American settlers had begun erecting on Indian land.
Frémont and his band continued up the Sacramento River, killing Indians on sight as they went. The Klamath people they met further north in Oregon Territory eventually retaliated and killed 2-3 members of Frémont's party on the night of 9 May 1846, leading to the Klamath Lake massacre three days later.
On 9 May 1846 Frémont received word that war with Mexico was imminent. He quickly returned from Oregon to participate, killing several more Sacramento Valley Indians in the journey south in the Sutter Buttes massacre. By August 1846 American military officers had fully occupied the northern half of the state, and by December all of modern California was under American control. John C. Frémont became Military Governor of California in January 1847, but was forced to give up the position less than two months later under disputed circumstances. In 1850 Frémont became California's first U.S. Senator. Frémont, who in the meantime had become wealthy off of gold mining claims, wrote a bill limiting gold mining claims to White citizens of the United States. In 1856 Frémont was nominated as the Republican candidate for President, losing the race to James Buchanan. He later fought as a Union general during the Civil War.
While some locals had admired the massacre, the wealthy landed settlers were beginning to depend on Indian labor in a sort of feudal system, with the Indians working both as free and as bonded labor. To some degree this saved the local Wintu from immediate annihilation, though smaller scale massacres occurred as early as the next year. By the 1850s, White American animosity at Indian possession of the land had built, and large-scale massacres involving hundreds of Wintu deaths recommenced, including the Kabyai Creek massacre, the Old Shasta Town massacre and the Bridge Gulch massacre.
- Richards 2007, p. 44
- Paddison 1999, p. 260
- Frémont 1887, pp. 418–420
- Sides 2006, pp. 123–124
- Frémont 1887, p. 473
- Madley 2016, p. chapter 2
- Breckenridge 1894, p. 56
- Breckenridge 1894, p. 56
- Tustin 1880, p. 4
- Breckenridge 1894, p. 56
- Martin 1975, p. 14
- Tustin 1880, p. 7
- Madley 2016, p. chapter 2
- Carson 1924, pp. 69–70
- Breckenridge 1894, pp. 56–57
- Martin 1975, p. 8
- Breckenridge 1894, p. 55
- Smith 2013, p. 92
- Heizer 1978, pp. 324–325
- Norton 1979, pp. 51–54
- Breckenridge, Thomas E. (1894). Thomas E. Breckenridge Memoirs. University of Missouri at Columbia: Western Historical Manuscripts Collection.
- Carson, Kit (1924). Kit Carson's Own Story of His Life, As dictated to Col. And Mrs. D.C. Peters about 1856-1857, and never before published. Taos, NM: Santa Fe New Mexican Publishing.
- Frémont, John Charles (1887). Memoirs of My Life, By John Charles Frémont. Chicago: Belford, Clark.
- Heizer, William (1978). Handbook of North American Indians: California, Volume 8. Smithsonian Institution.
- Madley, Benjamin (2016). An American Genocide. Yale University Press.
- Martin, Thomas S. (1975). With Frémont to California and the Southwest 1845-1849. Ashland, OR: Lewis Osborne.
- Norton, Jack (1979). Genocide in Northwestern California: when our worlds cried. San Francisco: Indian Historian Press.
- Paddison, Joshua (1999). A World Transformed: Firsthand Accounts of California before the Gold Rush. Berkeley, CA: Heyday Books.
- Richards, Leonard L. (2007). The California Gold Rush and the Coming of the Civil War. New York, New York: Vintage Books.
- Sides, Hampton (2006). Blood and Thunder: An Epic of the American West. Random House Inc.
- Smith, Stacey L. (2013). Freedom's Frontier, California and the Struggle Over Unpaid Labor, Emancipation, and Reconstruction. UNC Press Books.
- Tustin, William Issac (1880). Recollections of Early Days in California. Bancroft Library.