Rendlesham Forest incident
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages)(Learn how and when to remove this template message)
In late December 1980, there were a series of reported sightings of unexplained lights near Rendlesham Forest, Suffolk, England, which have become linked with claims of UFO landings. The events occurred just outside RAF Woodbridge, which was used at the time by the U.S. Air Force. USAF personnel, including deputy base commander Lieutenant Colonel Charles I. Halt, claimed to see things they described as a UFO sighting.
The east gate at RAF Woodbridge, where the incident began in December 1980
|Date||26 December and 28 December 1980|
|Time||03:00 GMT (23:00 EDT)|
|Location||Suffolk, England, United Kingdom|
|Also known as||Britain's Roswell|
The occurrence is the most famous of claimed UFO events to have happened in the United Kingdom, ranking among the best-known reported UFO events worldwide. It has been compared to the Roswell UFO incident in the United States and is sometimes referred to as "Britain's Roswell". The Ministry of Defence (MoD) stated the event posed no threat to national security, and it therefore never was investigated as a security matter. The sightings have been explained as a misinterpretation of a series of nocturnal lights – a fireball, the Orford Ness lighthouse and bright stars.
Around 3:00 a.m. on 26 December 1980 (reported as the 27th by Halt in his memo to the UK Ministry of Defence – see below) a security patrol near the east gate of RAF Woodbridge saw lights apparently descending into nearby Rendlesham Forest. These lights have been attributed by astronomers to a piece of natural debris seen burning up as a fireball over southern England at that time. Servicemen initially thought it was a downed aircraft but, upon entering the forest to investigate they saw, according to Halt's memo, what they described as a glowing object, metallic in appearance, with coloured lights. As they attempted to approach the object, it appeared to move through the trees, and "the animals on a nearby farm went into a frenzy". One of the servicemen, Sergeant Jim Penniston, later claimed to have encountered a "craft of unknown origin" while in the forest although there was no mention of this at the time and there is no corroboration from other witnesses.
After daybreak on the morning of 26 December, servicemen returned to a small clearing near the eastern edge of the forest and found three small impressions in a triangular pattern, as well as burn marks and broken branches on nearby trees. At 10:30 a.m. the local police were called out again, this time to see the impressions on the ground, which they thought could have been made by an animal. Georgina Bruni, in her book You Can't Tell the People, published a photograph of the supposed landing site taken on the morning after the first sighting.
The deputy base commander Lt. Col. Charles Halt visited the site with several servicemen in the early hours of 28 December 1980 (reported as the 29th by Halt). They took radiation readings in the triangle of depressions and in the surrounding area using an AN/PDR-27, a standard U.S. military radiation survey meter. The significance of the readings they obtained is disputed. Halt recorded the events on a micro-cassette recorder (see § The Halt Tape, below).
It was during this investigation that a flashing light was seen across the field to the east, almost in line with a farmhouse, as the witnesses had seen on the first night. The Orford Ness lighthouse is visible further to the east in the same line of sight (see below).
Later, according to Halt's memo, three starlike lights were seen in the sky, two to the north and one to the south, about 10 degrees above the horizon. Halt said that the brightest of these hovered for two to three hours and seemed to beam down a stream of light from time to time. Astronomers have explained these starlike lights as bright stars.
Rendlesham Forest is owned by the Forestry Commission and consists of about 5.8 square miles (15 km2) of coniferous plantations, interspersed with broadleaved belts, heathland and wetland areas. It is located in the county of Suffolk, about 8 miles (13 km) east of the town of Ipswich.
The incident occurred in the vicinity of two former military bases: RAF Bentwaters, which is just to the north of the forest, and RAF Woodbridge which extends into the forest from the west and is bounded by the forest on its northern and eastern edges. At the time, both were being used by the United States Air Force and were under the command of wing commander Colonel Gordon E. Williams. The base commander was Colonel Ted Conrad, and his deputy was Lieutenant Colonel Charles I. Halt.
The main events of the incident, including the supposed landing or landings, took place in the forest, which starts at the east end of the base runway or about 0.3 miles (0.5 km) to the east of the East Gate of RAF Woodbridge, from where security guards first noticed mysterious lights appearing to descend into the forest. The forest extends east about 1 mile (1.6 km) beyond East Gate, ending at a farmer's field at Capel Green, where additional events allegedly took place.
Orford Ness lighthouse, which sceptics identify as the flashing light seen off to the coast by the airmen, is along the same line of sight about 5 miles (8.0 km) further east of the forest's edge. At that time it was one of the brightest lighthouses in the UK.
Primary and secondary sourcesEdit
The Halt memoEdit
The first piece of primary evidence to be made available to the public was a memorandum written by the deputy base commander, Lt. Col. Charles I. Halt, to the Ministry of Defence (MoD). Known as the "Halt memo", this was made available publicly in the United States under the U.S. Freedom of Information Act in 1983. The memorandum (left), was dated "13 Jan 1981" and headed "Unexplained Lights". The two-week delay between the incident and the report might account for errors in the dates and times given. The memo was not classified in any way. Dr. David Clarke, a consultant to the National Archives, has investigated the background to this memo and the reaction to it at the Ministry of Defence. His interviews with the personnel involved confirmed the cursory nature of the investigation made by the MoD, and failed to find any evidence for any other reports on the incident made by the USAF or UK apart from the Halt memo. Halt has since gone on record as saying he believes that he witnessed an extraterrestrial event that was then covered up.
The Halt TapeEdit
In 1984, a copy of what became known as the "Halt Tape" was released to UFO researchers by Col. Sam Morgan, who had by then succeeded Ted Conrad as Halt's superior. This tape chronicles Halt's investigations in the forest in real time, including taking radiation readings, the sighting of the flashing light between trees and the starlike objects that hovered and twinkled. The tape has been transcribed by researcher Ian Ridpath, who includes a link to an audio download and also a step-by-step analysis of the entire contents of the tape.
Statements from eyewitnesses on 26 DecemberEdit
In 1997 Scottish researcher James Easton obtained the original witness statements made by those involved in the first night’s sightings. One of the witnesses, Ed Cabansag, said in his statement: "We figured the lights were coming from past the forest since nothing was visible when we passed through the woody forest. We would see a glowing near the beacon light, but as we got closer we found it to be a lit-up farmhouse. We got to a vantage point where we could determine that what we were chasing was only a beacon light off in the distance." Another participant, John Burroughs, also stated: "We could see a beacon going around so we went towards it. We followed it for about two miles [3 km] before we could [see] it was coming from a lighthouse."
Burroughs reported a noise "like a woman was screaming" and also that "you could hear the farm animals making a lot of noises". Halt heard the same noises two nights later. Such noise could have been made by Muntjac deer in the forest, which are known for their loud, shrill bark when alarmed.
The Halt affidavitEdit
In June 2010, retired colonel Charles Halt signed a notarised affidavit, in which he again summarised what had happened, then stated he believed the event to be extraterrestrial and it had been covered up by both the UK and U.S. Contradictions between this affidavit and the facts as recorded at the time in Halt's memo and tape recording have been pointed out.
In 2010, base commander Colonel Ted Conrad provided a statement about the incident to Clarke. Conrad stated that "We saw nothing that resembled Lieutenant Colonel Halt's descriptions either in the sky or on the ground" and that "We had people in position to validate Halt's narrative, but none of them could." In an interview, Conrad criticised Halt for the claims in his affidavit, saying "he should be ashamed and embarrassed by his allegation that his country and Britain both conspired to deceive their citizens over this issue. He knows better." Conrad also disputed the testimony of Sergeant Jim Penniston, who claimed to have touched an alien spacecraft; he said that he interviewed Penniston at the time and he had not mentioned any such occurrence. Conrad also suggested that the entire incident might have been a hoax.
A 1983 Omni article says "Colonel Ted Conrad the base commander... recalls five Air Force policemen spotted lights from what they thought was a small plane descending into the forest. Two of the men tracked the object on foot and came upon a large tripod-mounted craft. It had no windows but was studded with brilliant red and blue lights. Each time the men came within 50 yards of the ship, Conrad relates, it levitated six feet in the air and backed away. They followed it for almost an hour through the woods and across a field until it took off at 'phenomenal speed.' Acting on the reports made by his men, Colonel Conrad began a brief investigation of the incident in the morning. He went into the forest and located a triangular pattern ostensibly made by the tripod legs. ...he did interview two of the eyewitnesses and concludes, 'Those lads saw something, but I don't know what it was'."
Suffolk police logEdit
Suffolk police were called to the scene on the night of the initial sighting and again the following morning but found nothing unusual. On the night of the initial incident they reported that the only lights visible were from the Orford lighthouse. They attributed the indentations in the ground to animals. The Suffolk constabulary file on the case was released in 2005 under the UK’s Freedom of Information Act and can be accessed on their website. It includes a letter dated 28 July 1999 written by Inspector Mike Topliss who notes that one of the police constables who attended the scene on the first night returned to the site in daylight in case he had missed something. "There was nothing to be seen and he remains unconvinced that the occurrence was genuine," wrote Topliss. "The immediate area was swept by powerful light beams from a landing beacon at RAF Bentwaters and the Orfordness lighthouse. I know from personal experience that at night, in certain weather and cloud conditions, these beams were very pronounced and certainly caused strange visual effects."
Ministry of Defence fileEdit
Evidence of a substantial MoD file on the subject led to claims of a cover-up; some interpreted this as part of a larger pattern of information suppression concerning the true nature of unidentified flying objects, by both the United States and British governments. However, when the file was released in 2001 it turned out to consist mostly of internal correspondence and responses to inquiries from the public. The lack of any in-depth investigation in the publicly released documents is consistent with the MoD's earlier statement that they never took the case seriously. Included in the released files is an explanation given by defence minister Lord Trefgarne as to why the MoD did not investigate further.
One proposed theory is that the incident was a hoax. The BBC reported that a former U.S. security policeman, Kevin Conde, claimed responsibility for creating strange lights in the forest by driving around in a police vehicle whose lights he had modified. However, there is no evidence that this prank took place on the nights in question.
In his 6 January 2009 Skeptoid podcast episode titled "The Rendlesham Forest UFO," scientific sceptic author Brian Dunning evaluated the original eye-witness reports and audio recordings, as well as the resulting media reporting of this incident. After a lengthy analysis Dunning concluded:
Col. Halt's thoroughness was commendable, but even he can be mistaken. Without exception, everything he reported on his audiotape and in his written memo has a perfectly rational and unremarkable explanation... All that remains is the tale that the men were debriefed and ordered never to mention the event, and warned that "bullets are cheap". Well, as we've seen on television, the men all talk quite freely about it, and even Col. Halt says that to this day nobody has ever debriefed him. So this appears to be just another dramatic invention for television, perhaps from one of the men who have expanded their stories over the years.
When you examine each piece of evidence separately on its own merit, you avoid the trap of pattern matching and finding correlations where none exist. The meteors had nothing to do with the lighthouse or the rabbit diggings, but when you hear all three stories told together, it's easy to conclude (as did the airmen) that the light overhead became an alien spacecraft in the forest. Always remember: Separate pieces of poor evidence don't aggregate together into a single piece of good evidence. You can stack cowpies as high as you want, but they won't turn into a bar of gold.
In 2005, the Forestry Commission used Lottery proceeds to create a trail in Rendlesham Forest because of public interest and nicknamed it the UFO Trail. In 2014, the Forestry Service commissioned an artist to create a work which has been installed at the end of the trail. The artist states the piece is modeled after sketches that purportedly represent some versions of the UFO claimed to have been seen at Rendlesham.
Change of heartEdit
In 2010, Jenny Randles, one of the co-authors of the 1984 book Sky Crash: A Cosmic Conspiracy, eventually voiced her doubts that the incident had ever had anything to do with extraterrestrial visitors: "Whilst some puzzles remain, we can probably say that no unearthly craft were seen in Rendlesham Forest. We can also argue with confidence that the main focus of the events was a series of misperceptions of everyday things encountered in less than everyday circumstances."
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Rendlesham Forest incident.|
- "UFO files: Rendlesham Forest incident remains Britain’s most tantalising sighting". The Telegraph. 21 June 2013. Retrieved 13 July 2013.
- "Minister warned over 'UK Roswell'". BBC News. 17 August 2009. Retrieved 17 July 2009.
- Ridpath, Ian. "The Rendlesham Forest UFO case". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 17 April 2007.
- Dunning, Brian (6 January 2009). "Skeptoid #135: The Rendlesham Forest UFO". Skeptoid. Retrieved 22 June 2017.
- Ridpath, Ian. "The 3am fireball". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 2015-04-03.
- Ridpath, Ian. "Penniston's notebook". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 2007-09-27.
- "Unusual Lights Incident Rendlesham". suffolk.police.uk. Suffolk Constabulary. Archived from the original on 15 July 2013.
- Ridpath, Ian. "The Police evidence". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 3 April 2015.
- "Fax from Parliamentary Branch to DAS(SEC), 4 June 2001 8:50AM" (PDF). Ministry of Defence.
- Ridpath, Ian. "What were the landing marks?". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 3 April 2015.
- Ridpath, Ian. "Were the radiation readings significant?". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 2007-04-17.
- Printy, Tim. "The AN/PDR-27 SUNlite, vol. 2. no. 6 p. 10" (PDF). Tim Printy Comcast user page. Retrieved 2010-11-02.
- Ridpath, Ian. "The flashing light". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 2007-10-01.
- Ridpath, Ian. "The other lights". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 1 October 2007.
- Ridpath, Ian. "The Halt memo". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 2 April 2015.
- Clarke, David. "Rendlesham: Analysis 17". UK-UFO.org. Retrieved 18 July 2008.
- Clarke, David. "The Rendlesham Files". David Clarke blog. Retrieved 2 September 2010.
- "U.S. Nuclear Weapons Have Been Compromised by Unidentified Aerial Objects". PR Newswire. Reuters.com. 15 September 2010; Halt's press conference statement, starting at 3:00, part 1; YouTube, part 2
- Ridpath, Ian. "Transcript of Col. Halt’s tape". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 17 April 2007.
- Ridpath, Ian. "Transcript of Col. Halt’s tape". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 3 April 2015.
- Ridpath, Ian. "Rendlesham Forest UFO – the witness statements". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 2007-04-17.
- "Muntjac deer". bds.org. British Deer Society. Retrieved 2007-12-10.
- "Col Halt's affidavit". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved on 16 August 2011.
- Copping, Jasper (6 August 2011). "Rendlesham Incident: US commander speaks for the first time about the 'Suffolk UFO'". The Daily Telegraph.
- Clarke, David. "The Rendlesham files". David Clarke blog. Retrieved 29 September 2010.
- OMNI Magazine, March 1983, "UFO Update", p. 115
- Clarke, David. "Rendlesham analysis". UK-UFO.org. Retrieved 1 October 2007.
- Clarke, David. "The Rendlesham files". David Clark blog. Retrieved 1 October 2010.
- Ridpath, Ian. "Why did the British government not investigate the Rendlesham Forest UFO case in any depth?". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 1 October 2010.
- BBC (30 June 2003). "UFO lights were 'a prank'". BBC News. Retrieved 17 April 2007.
- "Rendlesham – UFO hoax". BBC. Retrieved 17 April 2007.
- "UFO sighted at Rendlesham". BBC. Retrieved 17 April 2007.
- Ridpath, Ian. "The Russian rocket re-entry". IanRidpath.com. Retrieved 18 October 2007.
- BBC (9 August 2005). "New UFO trail follows sightings". BBC News. Retrieved 17 April 2007.
- "Rendlesham UFO incident: Sculpture to be installed at forest site". BBC News. Retrieved 2016-07-21.
- "Rendlesham UFO Trail (England)". Forestry.gov.uk. Retrieved 2016-07-21.
- Hawksley, Rupert. "Britain's Roswell: the truth behind the Rendlesham Forest UFO incident". Telegraph. Retrieved 2016-07-21.
- Sky Crash: A Cosmic Conspiracy by Brenda Butler, Dot Street, and Jenny Randles, Neville Spearman, 1984, xii, 283 p., 12 p. of plates, ISBN 0-85435-155-8 .
- As quoted by Joe Nickell and James McGaha in The Roswellian Syndrome: How some UFO Myths Develop, Skeptical Inquirer, vol. 36.3, May/June 2012.
- Jenny Randles, Andy Roberts and David Clarke, The UFOs That Never Were, London House, 2000, p. 222.
- 2005 Nick Pope Interview at 28:25 minutes and 32:15 minutes he talks about Rendlesham.
- Dunning, Brian (6 January 2009). "Skeptoid #135: The Rendlesham Forest UFO". Skeptoid. Retrieved 22 June 2017. Explains the Rendlesham incident in rational terms.
- The Rendle-Sham case Robert Sheaffer's skeptical assessment of the case.