Psychological resistance

Psychological resistance, also known as psychological resistance to change, is the phenomenon often encountered in clinical practice in which patients either directly or indirectly exhibit paradoxical opposing behaviors in presumably a clinically initiated push and pull of a change process. In other words, the concept of psychological resistance is that patients are likely to resist physician suggestions to change behavior or accept certain treatments regardless of whether that change will improve their condition.[1] It impedes the development of authentic, reciprocally nurturing experiences in a clinical setting. Psychological resistance can manifest in various ways, such as denying the existence or severity of a problem, rationalizing or minimizing one's responsibility for it, rejecting or distrusting the therapist's or consultant's suggestions, withholding or distorting information, or sabotaging the treatment process.[2] It is established that the common source of resistances and defenses is shame.[3] This and similar negative attitudes may be the result of social stigmatization of a particular condition, such as psychological resistance towards insulin treatment of diabetes.[4]

Examples of psychological resistance may include perfectionism, criticizing, disrespectful attitude, being self-critical, preoccupation with appearance, social withdrawal, need to be seen as independent and invulnerable, or an inability to accept compliments or constructive criticism.[3] Resistance can be very high, such as inducing conflict, or low such as conceding to everything. In order to fully understand psychological resistance one must understand its roots.

Psychoanalytic origins edit

The discovery of resistance (German: Widerstand) was central to Sigmund Freud's theory of psychoanalysis: for Freud, the theory of repression is the cornerstone on which the whole structure of psychoanalysis rests, and all his accounts of its discovery "are alike in emphasizing the fact that the concept of repression was inevitably suggested by the clinical phenomenon of resistance".[5] Freud's theory established psychological resistance as a passive, unconscious process. It inherently places blame on patients for the inability to accept proper treatment as an avoidance measure. [6] It failed to consider patients having deliberate, conscious concerns relating to treatment that is driving their psychological resistance. This is known as realistic resistance. [6]

Contemporary understandings edit

Realistic resistance edit

Realistic resistance is the understanding of the conscious and deliberate aspect of psychological resistance in therapeutic treatment. "Realistic resistance refers to clients' conscious, deliberate opposition to therapeutic initiatives that they fail to understand or accept".[6] There are several things an individual may disagree with in the therapy setting that can lead to realistic psychological resistance, such as general therapeutic technique or words and phrases utilized by a physician or therapist.[6]

Realistic resistance can be identified by behavioral markers. Some examples include avoidance of certain lines of questioning, outright refusal to cooperate, and sudden loss of effort and interest during sessions.[6] Realistic resistance can have negative consequences for the therapeutic process and outcome, such as reducing client engagement, motivation, and adherence to treatment[7] because of avoidance of certain lines of questioning, outright refusal to cooperate, and sudden loss of effort and interest during sessions. Therefore, it is important for therapists to identify the above mentioned behavioral markers to address realistic resistance in a collaborative and empathic manner.[7]

Strategies to address realistic resistance edit

To manage realistic resistance, it is important to ensure that the client is kept in the loop which can be done by explaining the rationale and evidence for the therapeutic approach and techniques. This could be achieved by inviting feedback and questions from the client.[7] Additionally, therapists often use motivational interviewing techniques to elicit the client's reasons for change, explore ambivalence, and enhance self-efficacy.[7] Adapting the language and style of communication to match the client's preferences, needs, and level of understanding as well as involving the client in setting goals and choosing interventions, and offering choices and alternatives when possible also helps validate the client's feelings, thereby lowering the resistance. These strategies help in reframing resistance as a sign of strength, and highlighting the client's autonomy and responsibility for change.[7]

Interpersonal resistance edit

Resistance is based on instinctively autonomous ways of reacting in which clients both reveal and keep hidden aspects of themselves from the therapist or another person. These behaviors occur mostly during therapy, in interaction with the therapist. It is a way of avoiding and yet expressing unacceptable drives, feelings, fantasies, and behavior patterns.

Examples of causes of resistance include: resistance to the recognition of feelings, fantasies, and motives; resistance to revealing feelings toward the therapist; resistance as a way of demonstrating self-sufficiency; resistance as clients' reluctance to change their behavior outside the therapy room; resistance as a consequence of failure of empathy on the part of the therapist.[8]

Examples of the expression of resistance are canceling or rescheduling appointments, avoiding consideration of identified themes, forgetting to complete homework assignments, and the like. This will make it more difficult for the therapist to work with the client, but it will also provide him with information about the client.

Strategies to manage Interpersonal Resistance edit

Some strategies that can help therapists deal with interpersonal resistance include exploring the meaning and function of the resistance for the client, and how it relates to their interpersonal patterns and goals. Providing feedback and interpretation about the resistance and its impact on the therapy relationship, and inviting the client's response and perspective. Using empathy and validation to acknowledge the client's feelings and concerns, and to convey understanding and acceptance. Using humor and paradox to diffuse tension and challenge the client's assumptions or behaviors in a non-threatening way. Negotiating and compromising with the client about the pace, direction, and focus of therapy, and respecting their autonomy and preferences.[9] By using these strategies, therapists can reduce interpersonal resistance and enhance the therapeutic relationship with their clients, which can facilitate change and improve outcomes.

State and trait resistance (situational and characteristic) edit

Resistance is an automatic and unconscious process. According to Van Denburg and Kiesler,[10] it can be either for a certain period of time (state resistance) but it can also be a manifestation of more longstanding traits or character (trait resistance).

Trait resistance refers to the stable tendency to resist change or challenge, regardless of the situation or the content of therapy.[11] Both state and trait resistance can interfere with the therapeutic alliance, the client's engagement, and the client's progress.[12]

In psychotherapy, state resistance can occur at a certain moment, when an anxiety-provoking experience is triggered. Trait resistance, on the other hand, repeatedly occurs during sessions and interferes with the task of therapy. The client shows a pattern of off-task behaviors that makes the therapist experience some level of negative emotion and cognition against the client. Therefore the maladaptive pattern of interpersonal behavior and the therapist's response interfere with the task or process of therapy. This 'state resistance' is cumulative during sessions and its development can best be prevented by empathic interventions on the therapist's part.[10]

Outside therapy, trait resistance in a client is demonstrated by distinctive patterns of interpersonal behavior, which are often caused by typical patterns of communication with significant others, like family, friends, and partners.

Strategies to manage State and Trait Resistance edit

Some strategies that can help therapists cope with state and trait resistance include matching the therapeutic approach and techniques to the client's level of resistance, readiness for change, and preferred mode of coping; using cognitive restructuring techniques to challenge the client's irrational beliefs, cognitive distortions, or self-defeating thoughts that contribute to resistance; using exposure techniques to help the client face their fears, anxieties, or discomforts that underlie resistance, and using paradoxical techniques to use the client's resistance as a therapeutic tool, such as prescribing the symptom, reframing the problem, or exaggerating the consequences.

Handling resistance in psychotherapy edit

Nowadays many therapists work with resistance as a way to understand the client better. They emphasize the importance to work with the resistance and not against it.[8][10][13] This is because working against the resistance of a client can result in a counterproductive relationship with the therapist; the more attention is drawn to the resistance, the less productive the therapy. Working with the resistance provides a positive working relationship and gives the therapist information about the unconscious of the client.[13]

A therapist can use countertransference as a tool to understand the client's resistance. The feelings the client evokes in the therapist with his/her resistance will give you a hint what the resistance is about.[8] For example, a very directive client can make the therapist feel very passive. When the therapist pays attention to their passive feelings, it can make him/her understand this behavior of the client as resistance coming from fear of losing control.

It can also be useful to identify resistance with the client. This can not only work towards addressing the issue but can also allow the client to think about and discuss their resistance and the cognitive processes that underlie it. In this way, the client takes an active involvement in their therapy, which may reduce resistance in the future. It also helps the client's ability to identify their resistance in the future and respond to it.

Relevant to the question of treatment planning are research studies that have looked at resistance traits as indicators and contra-indicators for different types of interventions. Beutler, Moleiro, and Talebi reviewed 20 studies that inspected the differential effects of therapist directiveness as moderated by client resistance and found that 80% (n=16) of the studies demonstrated that directive interventions were most productive among clients who had relatively low levels of state or trait-like resistance. In contrast, nondirective interventions worked best among clients who had relatively high levels of resistance. These findings provide strong support for the value of resistance level as a predictor of treatment outcome, as well as treatment-planning.[13] In these studies cognitive behavioral therapy has been used as a prototype for directive therapy and psychodynamic, self-directed, or other relation oriented therapy have been used as a prototype for non-directive treatment.

Behavioral models of resistance edit

Behavior analytic and social learning models of resistance focus on the setting events, antecedents, and consequences for resistant behavior to understand the function of the behavior.[14] At least five behavioral models of resistance exist.[15] These models share many common features.[16] The most explored research model, with more than ten years of support, is the model created by Gerald Patterson for resistance in parent training.[17][18] With supporting research, this model has even been extended to consultation.[19][20]

Patterson's suggested intervention of 'struggle with and work through' is often contrasted as an intervention with motivational interviewing. In motivational interviewing, the therapist does not attempt to prompt the client back to the problem area but reinforces the occurrence when it comes up as opposed to 'struggling with and working through' where the therapist directly guides the client back to the problem. Behavior analytic models can accommodate both interventions, as pointed out by Cautilli and colleagues[21] depending on the function and what needs to be accomplished in the treatment.

See also edit

References edit

  1. ^ Jost, John T. (2015). "Resistance to Change: A Social Psychological Perspective". Social Research. 82 (3): 607–636. ISSN 0037-783X. JSTOR 44282124.
  2. ^ Serpell, Lucy (2006). "Robert L. Leahy (Ed.) (2003). Overcoming resistance in cognitive therapy. Guilford: New York, pp. 309, ISBN 1572309369". European Eating Disorders Review. 15 (1): 78–79. doi:10.1002/erv.756. ISSN 1072-4133.
  3. ^ a b Edward Teyber; Faith Teyber (2010). Interpersonal Process in Therapy: An Integrative Model. Cengage Learning. pp. 136–137. ISBN 978-0-495-60420-4.
  4. ^ Petrak, Frank; Stridde, Elmar; Leverkus, Friedhelm; Crispin, Alexander A.; Forst, Thomas; Pfützner, Andreas (2007-09-01). "Development and Validation of a New Measure to Evaluate Psychological Resistance to Insulin Treatment". Diabetes Care. 30 (9): 2199–2204. doi:10.2337/dc06-2042. ISSN 0149-5992. PMID 17575092.
  5. ^ Angela Richards, "Editor's Note", in Sigmund Freud, On Metapsychology (Middlesex 1987), p. 141-2.
  6. ^ a b c d e "Addressing and Managing Resistance with Internalizing Clients | Society for the Advancement of Psychotherapy". Retrieved 2022-04-16.
  7. ^ a b c d e Portis, Mary (September 1998). "Stop, Drop, & Roll: A Lifesaving Physical Education Lesson". Strategies. 12 (1): 11–12. doi:10.1080/08924562.1998.10591364. ISSN 0892-4562.
  8. ^ a b c Messer, S.B. (2002). "A Psychodynamic Perspective on Resistance in Psychotherapy: Vive la Résistance". Journal of Clinical Psychology. 58 (2): 157–163. doi:10.1002/jclp.1139. PMID 11793328.
  9. ^ "Countertransference and the Therapist's Experiential World", Countertransference and the Therapist's Inner Experience, Routledge, pp. 83–104, 2007-02-15, doi:10.4324/9780203936979-7, ISBN 978-0-429-24127-7, retrieved 2023-07-30
  10. ^ a b c Van Denburg, T.F.; Kiesler, D.J. (2002). "An Interpersonal Communication Perspective on Resistance in Psychotherapy". Journal of Clinical Psychology. 58 (2): 195–205. doi:10.1002/jclp.1143. PMID 11793332.
  11. ^ Beutler, Larry E.; Edwards, Christopher; Someah, Kathleen (2018-10-18). "Adapting psychotherapy to patient reactance level: A meta-analytic review". Journal of Clinical Psychology. 74 (11): 1952–1963. doi:10.1002/jclp.22682. ISSN 0021-9762. PMID 30334254. S2CID 52985820.
  12. ^ Beutler, Larry E.; Harwood, T. Mark (February 2000). Prescriptive Psychotherapy. Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/med:psych/9780195136692.001.0001. ISBN 978-0-19-513669-2.
  13. ^ a b c Beutler, L.E.; Moleiro, C.; Talebi, H. (2002). "Resistance in psychotherapy: What conclusions are supported by research". Journal of Clinical Psychology. 58 (2): 207–217. doi:10.1002/jclp.1144. PMID 11793333.
  14. ^ Cautilli, J. D., & Santilli-Connor, L. (2000) "Assisting the Client/Consultee to Do What is Needed: A Functional Analysis of Resistance and other Forms of Avoidance". The Behavior Analyst Today, 1(3), pp. 37-42.
  15. ^ Cautilli, J.D., Riley-Tillman, T.C., Axelrod, S., & Hineline, P.N. (2005). "Current Behavioral Models of Client and Consultee Resistance: A Critical Review". International Journal of Behavioral Consultation and Therapy, 1 (2), 147 –154.
  16. ^ Cautilli, J.D., Riley-Tillman, T.C., Axelrod, S., & Hineline, P.N. (2005). "Current Behavioral Models of Client and Consultee Resistance: A Critical Review". International Journal of Behavioral Consultation and Therapy Archived 2013-09-27 at the Wayback Machine, 1 (2), pp. 147–154.
  17. ^ Patterson, G. R. & Chamberlain, P. (1994). "A functional analysis of resistance during parent training". Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 1(1), pp. 53-70.
  18. ^ Patterson, G. R. & Forgatch, M.S. (1985). "Therapist behavior as a determinant for client noncompliance: A paradox for the behavior modifier". Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 53(6), pp. 846-851.
  19. ^ Joseph Cautilli, T. Chris Tillman, Saul Axelrod and Phil Hineline (2006). "Brief Report: An Experimental Analogue of Consultee "Resistance" Effects on the Consultant's Therapeutic Behavior". The Behavior Analyst Today, 7 (3), pp. 351-365.
  20. ^ Joseph Cautilli, T. Chris Tillman, Saul Axelrod, Halina Dziewolska, Philip Hineline (2006). "Resistance Is Not Futile: An experimental analogue of the effects of consultee "resistance" on the consultant's therapeutic behavior in the consultation process: A replication and extension". International Journal of Behavioral Consultation and Therapy Archived 2013-09-27 at the Wayback Machine, 2 (3), pp. 362-374.
  21. ^ Cautilli, J. D., & Santilli-Connor, L. (2000). "Assisting the Client/Consultee to Do What is Needed: A Functional Analysis of Resistance and other Forms of Avoidance". The Behavior Analyst Today, 1 (3), pp. 37-42.