Lee Dong-hwan (Korean: 이동환, born c. 1980-1981[1]) is a Methodist pastor who was excommunicated by the Korean Methodist Church for his support of LGBT rights. Lee was an ordained minister at a Korean Methodist Church in Suwon from 2013 until 2020, after he was reported to church authorities for leading a prayer, blessing same-sex couples, and throwing flower petals at the 2019 Incheon Queer Culture Festival. He was suspended in 2020 for two years after the church found that his actions violated their rules preventing church members or pastors from supporting the LGBT rights movement. Lee continued to attend pride events within South Korea and formed an LGBT rights group to advocate for change within South Korean churches. As a result, he was excommunicated by the church in December, 2023. The Suwon District Court granted an injunction suspending the excommunication on July 19, 2024, after Lee filed a lawsuit against the church.
In 2022, Lee was recognized by the Korean branch of Amnesty International for his activism.
Career
editCareer and initial suspension
editLee became an minister at Glory Jeil, a Korean Methodist Church in Suwon, in 2013.[1] Early in his life, he described himself as having negative preconceptions towards LGBT individuals. However, after a member of his church came out to him in 2015, he began to question his views on queer people. He eventually came to the conclusion that "If Jesus were alive today...[he] would be with the LGBTQ community".[1][2] He recognized that his beliefs contradicted official Korean Methodist Church doctrine, which disapproves of same-sex relationships and prohibits LGBT rights advocacy by church members.[3][1]
In 2019, Lee was invited to attend the Incheon Queer Culture Festival.[4] At the event, he blessed a same-sex couple and led a prayer for LGBT people on the main stage.[2][5] He threw flower petals into the audience, and added a rainbow-patterned stole to his minster's robes. According to Lee, he thought his actions might cause "issues" within the church,[6][1] but that he believed that by performing the blessings he was acting in accordance with "God's will". A few days after the festival, he was called to a meeting with local church leaders and reported to the Gyeonggi Annual Conference. Lee was told that he was "humiliating the Methodist Church" and instructed to promise "never carry out such a blessing again".[2] After an internal judicial hearing in October 2020, the church suspended Lee for two years.[7] Lee criticized the hearing's fairness, as one of the judges had also been responsible for investigating him.[8] He filed an appeal on October 15.[2] It was dismissed two years later, on October 20, 2022, after the original suspension was due to expire.[9]
The suspension itself was criticized by religious groups inside and outside Korea and by South Korean LGBT rights groups. A protest was held outside the Korean Methodist Church's headquarters in Seoul.[2] The National Council of Churches in Korea said that in performing the blessing "Rev. Lee Dong-hwan only did his job"[7], and the United Church of Canada termed his suspension "exceedingly unfair".[1] Over 100 pastors from various Korean churches signed a letter supporting him, and individuals donated a total of ₩8,000,000(US$7,200) to cover the costs of his appeal.[2] However, other netizens and pastors felt that the church had not been strict enough, and rather that suspend Lee, he ought to have been removed from his position or the church entirely. Some accused him of being gay, and, according to Lee, some senior pastors attempted to pressure him into dropping his appeal or recant his earlier statements in order to keep his job.[8][2]
Excommunication and lawsuits
editAfter his appeal was dismissed by the church, Lee filed a lawsuit in the Seoul Central District Court to have his suspension overturned.[10] Throughout his suspension, Lee performed several additional blessings for LGBT individual and couples and criticized the church's stance on LGBT issues.[11][3] In response, the church excommunicated Lee in December 2023.[5][10] The excommunication was criticized by several organizations. The National Council of Churches in Korea described it as "hate in the name of religion" and defended Lee, calling him "a faithful Christian".[3] A representative of the LGBT rights group Rainbow Action said they hoped that the church would someday "apologize and repent of its wrongdoing" towards Lee,[10] and the South Korean Coalition for Anti-Discrimination Legislation and Rainbow Jesus announced they would fundraise to help cover Lee's legal fees should he appeal.[12]
In response to the excommunication, Lee lodged an appeal within the church. His lawyers also argued that, since there had been no complaint made against Lee to base the reindictment on, the ecclesiastical court had not followed proper procedures.[10] The Korean Methodist Church heard the appeal in a tribunal, where they upheld the excommunication. According to the tribunal, when Lee performed the blessing and threw flower petals, he had violated their rules prohibiting "advocating or sympathizing with homosexuality" and thus the excommunication was warranted.[10] They conceded that there had been an "error" in their procedures, but denied that it had negatively impacted Lee.[10] They also found Lee liable for the costs of the appeal, announcing later that month that he owed them ₩28,64,2532(US$21,800). The amount was described by The Hankyoreh as "excessively high compared to the denomination’s normal trial costs" given that church's normal appeals typically cost only around ₩7,000,000. Lee was billed for the cost of the trials themselves, but also the costs of the conciliation process, the examination committee process, and a delay caused by the church when they assigned an ecclesiastical prosecutor with an external connection to a complainant.[13] The church confirmed the excommunication in March 2024.[3] Lee filed a lawsuit within the Suwon District court, which granted an injunction to temporarily suspend the excommunication on July 19, 2024.[5]
Activism
editIn 2021 Lee was recognized by the Korean branch of Amnesty International for his activism,[8][14] and in 2022, he founded an Christian LGBT activist group called Q&A.[12] which stands for "Queer and Allies". The organisation is designed to tell the stories of queer Christian and advocate for their acceptance within churches.[15] He has attended several pride festivals, and ran a stand at the 2021 and 2022 Seoul Queer Culture Festival.[16]
In December 2023, Lee held a prayer at a disability rights protest at Hyehwa station. The protestors were removed from the station due to lack of advanced permission, and so held a prayer outside instead.[17]
Personal life
editLee Dong-hwan was raised in a religious family, although he did not view himself as particularly devout until he chose to attend a theological college as a teenager. He is married.[2] In a 2020 interview, he stated he that suffered from facial nerve paralysis brought on by the stress he experienced as a result of his suspension.[8]
References
edit- ^ a b c d e f Maresca, Thomas (2021-07-21). "Suspended South Korean pastor challenges church's position on LGBTQ issues". United Press International. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ a b c d e f g h Yoon, So-yeon (2020-11-24). "Suspended pastor has one regret from time at queer festival — not smiling more". Korea JoongAng Daily. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ a b c d Min-sik, Yoon (2024-03-15). "Pastor expelled for blessing LGBTQ+ couples continues fight". The Korea Herald. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ Kim, Eung-seon, ed. (2023-12-12). "또다시 이 사람, 이동환 목사를 소개합니다 '결국 사랑이 승리할 것입니다'" [ddadosi i saram, lee dong-hwan moksarur sogaehamnida 'gyeorguk sarangi seungrihar geotimnida']. United Methodist News Service (in Korean). Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ a b c Lee, Hae-rin (2024-07-19). "Court suspends Korean Methodist church's excommunication of pro-LGBTQ pastor". The Korea Times. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ So-hyun, Kim (2023-06-20). "Pastor faces discipline again for blessing LGBTQ people". The Korea Herald. Retrieved 2024-07-22.
- ^ a b Park, Ji-won (2020-10-16). "Pastor suspended for giving blessing at LGBT festival". The Korea Times. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ a b c d Park, Ji-won (2021-04-29). "[Interview] Pastor suspended for blessing LGBTQ questions meaning of love in church". The Korea Times. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ Choi, Seung-hyun (2022-10-20). "기독교대한감리회, '성소수자 축복기도' 이동환 목사 정직 2년 확정". News & Joy (in Korean). Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ a b c d e f Chai, Yoon-tae (2024-03-05). "Korean Methodists excommunicate minister for performing blessings at LGBTQ+ pride events". The Hankyoreh. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ Choi, Si-young (2024-03-28). "[Herald Interview] Seeking redemption -- for church". The Korea Herald. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ a b Yoon, Min-sik (2023-12-10). "LGBTQ+ groups vow support for pastor expelled after blessing gay people". The Korea Herald. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ Chai, Yoon-tae (2023-12-19). "Church slaps Korean pastor dismissed for performing blessings at Pride with major bill for trial". The Hankyoreh. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ "제23회 국제앰네스티 언론상 수상작 발표" [je23hwi gukjeaemneseuti eonronsang susangjak barpyu]. Amnesty International Korea. 2021-03-23. Retrieved 2024-07-20.
- ^ Francis, Johan Eduard (2022-07-01). "Asking a queer question to the church". Korean Quarterly. Retrieved 2024-07-22.
- ^ Jeong, Hee-wan (2023-06-18). "'성소수자 축복식' 이동환 목사 다시 재판에". Kyunghyang Shinmun (in Korean). Retrieved 2024-07-21.
- ^ Kim, Se-hoon (2023-12-25). "출입 금지당한 장애인활동가·출교당한 목사…배제된 사람들의 예배". Kyunghyang Shinmun (in Korean). Retrieved 2024-07-21.