In 1907, Jersey A.C., which had long fielded a successful cricket team entered a soccer team in the National Association Football League (NAFBL). They finished mid-table and withdrew at the end of the season. In 1908, Jersey A.C. returned to the NAFBL. In 1911, they won their second title. The team finished mid-table most seasons. With the entry of the United States into World War I, Jersey A.C. lost so many players to military service that it left the NAFBL in 1918 and ceased operations a year later.
|Year||League||Reg. Season||American Cup||National Challenge Cup|
|1914/15||NAFBL||2nd||Third round||First round|
|1916/17||NAFBL||1st||Second round||Second round|
- Winner (2): 1911, 1917
- Runner Up (2): 1910, 1915
New Jersey State Challenge Cup
- Runner Up (1): 1917