Franz Tieze (1842–1932) was a late 19th-century Dublin-based forger. An exiled Bohemian glass engraver, he worked in Dublin in the studios of the Pugh Brothers (Thomas and Richard Pugh) at The Potters Alley Glass Works, the only manufacturers of flint-glass in Ireland.[1] Tieze had been recruited, with other Bohemian glass engravers, by the Pugh Brothers and he arrived in Dublin in 1865 to engrave glass in the 'antique style'.
Cork historian Robert Day and Franz Tieze collaborated in supplying goblets to a ready market of glass collectors. Day researched Irish Volunteer glass designs and Jacobite toasting glasses. Tieze's engraving skills allowed the work to be categorised as "historicist". Thomas Rohan, in his Confessions of a Dealer (London, 1924), noted the flood of Volunteer and Williamite glasses in Dublin.[2] An example of Tieze's work is the Charlemont Jug, regarded as genuine until scrutinised firstly by Mary Boydell and then by Peter Francis, a modern Irish researcher who found compelling evidence in Tieze's own notebooks, showing that the age and style of the engraving had been faked, circa 1900. It was subsequently acquired by the National Museum of Ireland.[3][4]
Francis' revelations appeared in the Burlington Magazine in 1994. It was disclosed that almost without exception every single glass piece supposedly engraved in support of the Irish Volunteer regiments of the late 18th century was the work of Franz Tieze. The glass was from the period it purported to be, while the engraving was carried out much later.
While Tieze's ability to have produced 'period' glassware is undeniable, he did not profit substantially from his activities. Tieze was admitted to Simpson's Hospital in Dublin in 1910. Hospital records indicate that he spent his final 22 years there and that he had been blind when admitted. This conflicts with evidence unearthed by Boydell and Francis, which shows that Tieze had been engraving pieces "after 1913 and possibly as late as 1918".
Initially the researchers investigated only Williamite glass, which supposedly was made to celebrate the victory of William of Orange (1689–1702) over the Stuarts. It was found that much of this glass was 19th-century, and some the work of Tieze who had supplied the pieces to Orange Order lodges. It was noticed that some of the individuals who had promoted Volunteer and Williamite glass had also featured in the promotion of Jacobite glass. Major museums in Ireland and England, including the Victoria & Albert and the Museum of London, took a closer look at their collections and re-attributed the offending items. It soon became evident that dealers, collectors, and museums had not been as scrupulous as they might have in checking the provenance of the 18th-century commemorative glass in their collections.[5]
Bibliography
edit- Franz Tieze 1842-1932 : a Bohemian glass-engraver in Dublin - Mary Boydell, 1992
- Franz Tieze (1842-1932) and the re-invention of history on glass - Peter Francis, 1994
- The engraved glass of Franz Tieze - Mary Boydell, 1995 [6]
References
edit- ^ "A Tapering Jug, 19th Century, engraved by Franz Tieze, attributed to The Pugh Brothers at The Potters Alley Glass Works, with a pair of swans by". invaluable.com.
- ^ James Adam[permanent dead link]
- ^ Adam's Salerooms Archived 2011-07-21 at the Wayback Machine
- ^ "A Waterford Full Size Jug, 18th Century, with crimped handle and moulded fluted base, later engraved by Franz Tieze, with the Caulfield". invaluable.com.
- ^ Francis, Peter (23 October 1994). "Franz Tieze (1842-1932) and the Re-Invention of History on Glass". The Burlington Magazine. 136 (1094): 291–302. JSTOR 885911.
- ^ "RHS bibliography".[permanent dead link]