The brown-tail moth (Euproctis chrysorrhoea) is a moth of the family Erebidae. It is native to Europe, neighboring countries in Asia, and the north coast of Africa. Descriptions of outbreaks, i.e., large population increases of several years duration, have been reported as far back as the 1500s. The life cycle of the moth is atypical, in that it spends approximately nine months (August to April) as larvae (caterpillars), leaving about one month each for pupae, imagos and eggs. Larvae (caterpillars) are covered in hairs. Two red spots on the back, toward the tail, distinguish these species from other similarly hairy moth larvae. The winged adults have white wings and a hairy white body with a tuft of brown hair at the tip of the abdomen. Females lay one egg cluster, usually on the underside of a leaf of a host plant. The species is polyphagous, meaning that it feeds on many different species of trees, including pear, apple, maple and oak.
|Euproctis chrysorrhoea, upperside|
|Female with tail tuft of red/brown hairs|
This species was accidentally introduced to the United States in the 1890s. During the early 20th century it was present from eastern Connecticut northward into New Brunswick, Canada, but a subsequent severe population collapse reduced the territory to parts of coastal Maine, and Cape Cod, Massachusetts, by the late 20th century. One theory for the decline appeared to be parasitism by a fly introduced to combat gypsy moths. Starting in 2015 there has been a population spike and territory expansion in coastal Maine. In Europe, there are multiple parasitic and predator species, yet there is still a history of population outbreaks.
Hairs from the caterpillars are toxic for humans, causing a poison ivy-like itchy rash of up to weeks' duration due to mechanical and chemical irritation. Direct contact with larvae is not necessary, as the hairs are shed and can become windblown. Toxins in the hairs remain potent for up to three years. Outdoor activities such as mowing a lawn or raking leaves in the fall can cause exposure.
The upper surface of the wings of this species is pure white. Males may have some brown color on the underside of the forewing. Wingspan is 36–42 millimetres (1.4–1.7 in). The body is very hairy, and white except for the tail which is covered in reddish-brown hairs, much more prominent in the females. Males have larger antennae, used to detect pheromones released by unmated females. Females have a larger body. As winged adults, this species is superficially similar in appearance to Euproctis similis (native to Europe) and Hyphantria cunea (native to North America), but female E. similis have a yellow tail tuft and H. cunea lacks tail tuft coloration.
The female lays one cluster of 200 to 400 eggs, typically on the underside of a leaf. The egg cluster is covered with hairs from her anal tuft. The larva is very hairy, brown with white markings, and two prominent red spots toward the tail end. The hairs provide protection from predators; the larva incorporates some into the cocoon within which it pupates. The species overwinters communally as larvae within a tough, silken tent constructed around branch-tip leaves and anchored to twigs. In areas where the species is abundant, these tents are a familiar sight, and can be seen on a huge range of plants, especially in late fall and winter when unaffected leaves have fallen.
This species can be found throughout Europe, except in the most northern countries, also in the westernmost countries of Asia, such as Turkey, Syria and Israel, and the countries across the northern parts of Africa. Fernand and Kirkland recount historic mentions of brown-tail moths dating back to 1500s, describing outbreaks in Paris, London and Berlin so severe as to completely strip all trees of leaves. Carl Linnaeus described the species in the tenth edition (1758) of Systema Naturae.
The brown-tail moth is an invasive species in the United States and Canada, having arrived in Somerville, MA circa 1890 and becoming widespread there and in neighboring Cambridge by 1897. Initial outbreaks were most evident in pear and apple trees. Doctors reported "poisonings" (skin rash) far worse than poison ivy rash. Within a few years it was seen as a serious, fast-spreading, horticultural and health problem. Through the early parts of the 20th century it was present in much of New England from eastern Connecticut to Maine, and northward into New Brunswick, Canada, but the 1906 introduction of a parasitic fly to counter Gypsy moths collaterally impacted brown-tail moths. By the late 20th century the habitat was reduced to the coast and islands of Maine, and also parts of Cape Cod, Massachusetts. Cold and wet weather hinders re-expansion of the population outside its current territories, although starting in 2015 there has been a population spike and territory expansion in coastal Maine. In addition to North America, there have been reports of this species appearing in China, Japan and New Guinea.
Photographs taken from aerial fly-overs are used to identify areas where the trees have been denuded of leaves and where the branch-tip tents are present. The female sex hormone has been synthesized and field-tested in moth traps as a means of monitoring moth populations during the June/July flight season. The white-winged adults are nocturnal and strongly attracted to light; a report from 1903 likened their appearance around streetlights as being akin to heavy snowfall.
The brown-tail moth produces one generation a year. It has four life stages; egg, larval, pupal, and adult. Eggs are laid in July, hatch in August.The annual cycle is approximately one month as eggs, nine months as larvae, one month pupae, and one month Imagoes (winged, sexually mature adults).
- Pre-diapausing larvae: Emerge and feed gregariously starting in August after about three weeks of egg incubation.
- Diapausing larvae: As a response to shortened periods of daylight, larvae build communal winter nests in the fall, inside of which they overwinter. These involve webbing binding leaves together at branch tips. Distinct from other communal moth larvae such as eastern tent caterpillar that create webbed nests in branch crotches during spring and summer.
- Post-diapausing gregarious larvae: Resumes feeding in early April synchronized with bud break, and still inhabit the winter nests as their resting places.
- Post-diapausing dispersive larvae: Once larvae reach late instars, colonies break up and larvae start feeding independently.
- Pupation: Larvae pupate in June after six to eight instars.
- Emergence: Imagoes (winged, sexually mature adults) appear about one month later; mate, lay eggs, and die.
Predators, parasites and diseasesEdit
In the United States, many species of birds prey on the winged adults, including English house sparrow and blue jay. A review of mortality causes in England and mainland Europe described the brown-tail moth as undergoing periodic population outbreaks, each developing rapidly and lasting for several years, followed by a decline to relative obscurity. In a study conducted in England, egg, larvae and pupae deaths were attributed to several parasites, including microsporidia, cytoplasmic and nuclear viruses, and larvae predation by birds, specifically identifying the common cuckoo (Cuculus canorus) and titmice. A more recent review, conducted in Spain, identified 17 species of parasites, viral diseases, unspecified predation and other, unknown, causes of death spanning from eggs not hatching, during summer, winter and spring as larvae, finishing with pupae failing to produce winged adults. Generally, mortality increased with population density, although in outbreak regions there was some compensation by females laying 21.6% more eggs (cause not discussed).
Compsilura concinnata, a parasitic fly, pierces the brown-tail moth larva and deposits its own larva inside. This fly was introduced to North America in 1906 in an attempt to counter gypsy moth, an invasive species. While not entirely successful for that purpose, one research group concluded that introduction of this fly had a great impact on brown-tail moths while not being as effective on gypsy moths, the reason being that the fly larvae need to over-winter inside a host larvae. Brown-tail moths over-winter as larvae, whereas gypsy moths over-winter as eggs. An older review describes other fly species that were confirmed as brown-tail moth larvae parasites, then released in U.S.: Apanteles lacteicolor, Metrous versicolor, Sturmia nidicola.
Branch-tip webs can be clipped in winter and very early spring, and either dropped into a bucket of soapy water or burned. Gloves should be worn. Appropriate pesticides should be applied before early May because that is when the larvae start to develop harmful hairs. For organic garden and farm situations there are sprays that use a strain of Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt).
Cicely Blair wrote a paper about the rash caused by the brown-tail moth caterpillar in the British isles. It, and other descriptions, confirmed that loose hairs break off and, on contact with skin can cause very itchy rashes, and breathing difficulties similar to asthma if inhaled. Rashes can persist for weeks. The same symptoms have been reported as far back as 1903. The reactions are due to a combination of mechanical and chemical stimuli, the barbed hairs in effect becoming lodged in and physically irritating the skin, and also functioning as microtubules to introduce irritating chemical compounds that have hydrolase, esterase and hemolytic activity. This rash reaction may be referred to as lepidopterism. The species should be handled using protective gloves at all stages of its life cycle. Shed hairs blow about, and can be brought indoors on clothing and shoes, so rashes can occur without the victim coming in direct contact with the caterpillars. The toxins in the hairs remain potent for up to three years after being shed. Outdoor activities such as mowing a lawn or raking leaves in the fall can cause exposure.
A related species, mistletoe browntail moth (Euproctis edwardsi), has been reported as causing a similar rash in Australia, in people working at or visiting a community center, attributed to caterpillars feeding on a tree outside the building. In addition to brown-tail and mistletoe browntail, several other Euproctis species are identified as causing rashes in humans, including Euproctis baliolalis, Euproctis limbalis and Euproctis lutea (all three native to Australia). Urticating hairs, i.e., itch and rash-producing, are also reported for caterpillars of other moth and butterfly species.
Brown-tail larvae have been reported as feeding on 26 genera of non-resinous trees and shrubs belonging to 13 different families. This polyphagy is considered unusual. Non-specific host plant feeding combined with its tendency to reach extreme outbreak densities, makes this species a major pest of fruit orchards, ornamental trees and hardwood forests. Partial list of plant species: apple, cherry, beach plum (Cape Cod, MA, USA), beech, elm, grape, hops, maple, oak, pear, raspberry, rose and willow. An early description of the introduction to the United States in the 1890s identified pear and apple trees as most greatly afflicted, but mentioned that once trees were entirely bare of leaves, the larvae would descend to the ground in great numbers and move toward any leafy plant, including vegetable plants.
- Fernand CH, Kirkland AH (1903).The brown-tail moth, Euproctis chrysorrhoea (L.). A report on the life history and habits of the imported brown-tail moth, together with a description of the remedies best suited for destroying it. Wright & Potter Printing Co., Boston.
- Elkinton JS, Parry D, Boettner GH (2006). "Implicating an introduced generalist parasitoid in the invasive browntail moth's enigmatic demise". Ecology. 87 (10): 2664–2672. doi:10.1890/0012-9658(2006)87[2664:iaigpi]2.0.co;2. PMID 17089674.
- "Browntail Moth History, Background, Conditions in ME" (PDF). Department of Agriculture, Conservation & Forestry, Maine Forest Service. February 2018. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
- Frago, E; Pujade-Villar, J; Guara, M; Selfa, J (2011). "Providing insights into browntail moth local outbreaks by combining life table data and semi-parametric statistics". Ecological Entomology. 36 (2): 188–199. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2311.2010.01259.x.
- "Browntail Moth" (PDF). Maine Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry. Retrieved 24 July 2018.
- de Jong MC, Hoedemaeker J, Jongebloed WL, Nater JP (1976). "Investigative studies of the dermatitis caused by the larva of the brown-tail moth (Euproctis chrysorrhoea Linn.) II. Histopathology of skin lesions and scanning electron microscopy of their causative setae". Arch Dermatol Res. 255 (2): 177–191. doi:10.1007/bf00558526. PMID 1275552.
- de Jong MC, Kawamoto F, Bleumink E, Kloosterhuis AJ, Meijer GT (1982). "A comparative study of the spicule venom of Euproctis caterpillars". Toxicon. 20 (2): 477–485. doi:10.1016/0041-0101(82)90011-3. PMID 7043788.
- "Controlling Browntail moths as they lay eggs". Harpswell Heritage Land Trust, Harpswell, Maine. 2016-08-02. Retrieved 10 July 2018.
- Candan, S; Suludere, Z; Bayrakdar, F (2007). "Surface morphology of eggs of Euproctis chrysorrhoea (Linnaeus, 1758)". Acta Zoologica. 89 (2): 133–136. doi:10.1111/j.1463-6395.2007.00300.x.
- "Euproctis chrysorrhoea (brown-tail moth)". CABI Invasive Species Compendium. Wallingford, UK: CAB International. 2018. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
- Elkinton JS, Preisser E, Boettner G, Parry D (2008). "Factors influencing larval survival of the invasive browntail moth (Lepidoptera: Lymantriidae) in relict North American populations". Environ. Entomol. 37 (6): 1429–1437. doi:10.1603/0046-225x-37.6.1429. PMID 19161686.
- Khrimian A, Lance DR, Schwarz M, Leonhardt BA, Mastro VC (2008). "Sex pheromone of browntail moth, Euproctis chrysorrhoea (L.): synthesis and field deployment". J. Agric. Food Chem. 56 (7): 2452–2456. doi:10.1021/jf073161w. PMID 18333615.
- Frago, E; Guara, MJ; Pujade-Villar, J; Selfa, S (2010). "Winter feeding leads to a shifted phenology in the browntail moth Euproctis chrysorrhoea on the evergreen strawberry tree Arbutus unedo". Agricultural and Forest Entomology. 12 (4): 381–388. doi:10.1111/j.1461-9563.2010.00489.x.
- Sterling, PH; Speight, MR (1989). "Comparative mortalities of the brown-tail moth, Euproctis chrysorrhoea (L.) (Lepidoptera: Lymantriidae), in south-east England". Botanical J Linnean Soc. 101: 69–78. doi:10.1111/j.1095-8339.1989.tb00137.x.
- Burgess, AF (1929). "Imported insect enemies of the gypsy moth and the brown-tail moth" (PDF). U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC. Retrieved 23 July 2018.
- Blair, CP (1979). "The browntail moth, its caterpillar and their rash". Clin Experimental Dermatol. 4 (2): 215–222. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2230.1979.tb01621.x.
- Mabey, Richard; Marren, Peter (2010). Bugs Britannica (Illustrated ed.). Random House UK. p. 273. Retrieved 7 January 2016.
- Graham, Gillian (2015-07-23). "Got an itchy rash? Browntail moths out in force in Maine, spreading noxious hairs". Portland Press Herald. Retrieved 26 May 2016.
- Balit CR, Ptolemy HC, Geary MJ, Russell RC, Isbister GK (2001). "Outbreak of caterpillar dermatitis caused by airborne hairs of the mistletoe browntail moth (Euproctis edwardsi)". Med. J. Aust. 175 (11–12): 641–643. PMID 11837874.