Blue City (film)
This article needs additional citations for verification. (August 2012) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
Blue City is a 1986 American drama film based on Ross Macdonald's 1947 novel of the same name about a young man who returns to a corrupt small town in Florida to avenge the death of his father. The film was directed by Michelle Manning and stars Judd Nelson, Ally Sheedy, and David Caruso.
Theatrical release poster
|Directed by||Michelle Manning|
|Based on||Blue City|
by Ross Macdonald
|Music by||Ry Cooder|
|Edited by||Ross Albert|
|Distributed by||Paramount Pictures|
|Box office||$6.9 million|
Returning to the small Florida town where he grew up, Billy Turner learns that his father has been killed. With little help from the police, Billy will take matters into his own hands and go up against a ruthless local mob in a desperate search to find the killer.
This section needs expansion. You can help by adding to it. (September 2013)
- Judd Nelson as Billy Turner
- Ally Sheedy as Annie Rayford
- David Caruso as Joey Rayford
- Paul Winfield as Chief Luther Reynolds
- Scott Wilson as Perry Kerch
- Anita Morris as Malvina Kerch-Turner
- Luis Contreras as Lt. Ortiz
- Julie Carmen as Debbie Torres
- Allan Graf as Graf
- Hank Stone as Hank
- Tommy Lister, Jr. as Tiny
- Rex Ryon as Rex
- Willard E. Pugh as Leroy
- Sam Whipple as Jailer
- Paddi Edwards as Kate
- Rick Hurst as Redneck
The Textones (Carla Olson, Joe Read, George Callins, Phil Seymour and Tom Jr Morgan) appear in the film performing their song You Can Run as produced by Ry Cooder.
Walter Hill wrote the script with Lukas Heller and was originally intended to star a leading man in his mid-30s but by the mid 1980s a number of popular young male actors had emerged, so the script was rewritten to accommodate one of them. (The lead in the original novel was a man in his early 20s, although a war veteran.)
Hill handed over directing duties to first-timer Michelle Manning. She previously worked with Sheedy and Nelson on The Breakfast Club as a producer. Her Breakfast Club co-producer was Ned Tanen and when he took over as head of production at Paramount, the studio agreed to finance Blue City with Manning's direction.
"I don't think I'll become Samantha Peckinpah," said Manning, "but I don't think as a woman that I should have to make a movie with girls in locker rooms putting on make up." Manning did admit being a woman director meant "You're under a microscope. You suddenly become a media event for no good reason."
It was the first film Nelson made since St Elmo's Fire. He had taken a year off to appear in several plays. "It's the first part ever that I didn't have to audition for," he said. "Instead of having to make the rounds and go to casting calls and auditioning with hundreds of other guys, suddenly my agent has more offers coming in than I can possibly handle. I'm in a position where I can actually turn a job down. It's a strange experience."
Nelson reflected on his role:
Cowboys and Indians, cops and robbers. That`s the way Billy Turner sees it--it`s good guys and bad guys. He`s the misunderstood hero now. What, is he out of his mind? He doesn't even know what`s going on. Billy Turner is supposedly on a quest to find out who killed his father, but as soon as he gets a gun in his hand, it`s like: `Hey--I`ve got a gun in my hand!`It`s a little like real life--sometimes you don`t know what you`re supposed to be doing, even when you`re doing it.
"I think it's very exciting that a woman would direct a film of the Peckinpah mode rather the sweet, postman- falls-in-love-with-the-divorcee mode," said Nelson. "I think it could have been filmed in black and white with a blue tint. I think that would have been the coolest."
These actors function on three levels. As professionals, they're totally devoted, totally relentless, totally driven. In the public social scene, like at the Hard Rock Cafe, they have to deal with people coming up to them, asking for autographs, pulling on their clothes. And in the privacy of their homes, they're completely relaxed, and they're just kids. But they all want so much to grow as actors. They all so much want their careers to grow. And it scares them all, the idea that tomorrow this could all end. I mean, it could all just be over. They want so much to be doing the same thing when they're forty, and who's to say? Will the trend then be to make movies with forty-year-olds?
Preview audiences disliked the movie's ending so it was reshot.
Blue City earned $2.7 million in its first weekend and was a box office disappoinment.
Nelson's performance was particularly criticized, USA Today saying "Is Judd Nelson the smirkiest actor in current movies, or is he simply getting stereotyped playing overbearing creeps? Either way, you spend `Blue City's' 83 interminable minutes begging to deck him." The LA Daily News said "You haven't seen anything quite so ridiculous as a limp-jawed, dewy-eyed Nelson trying to carry off a tough guy part." "Nelson-.008 charisma rating on the Richter scale-is resolutely unconvincing." (L.A. Herald-Examimer). "It's another step in the slow process of revealing, movie by movie, what dull actors some of the celebrated Brat Pack kids are. Judd Nelson would make a great shopping cart, Sheedy a still life of a cornflower gone to wilt." (San Francisco Chronicle) "(The main character has) a passion as rootless as an Everglades air plant. . . . Though his clothes suggest that he and Don Johnson patronize the same boutique, Mr. Nelson has the looks of someone who's come South on a spring break and overshot Fort Lauderdale." (The New York Times) "The worst major studio film we've seen in recent memory." (Santa Monica Outlook) " Blue City is fictionally set in Florida, but was lensed entirely in California, thus managing to shame the citizenry on one coast and the film making industry on the other, all at the same time." (Daily Variety)
The Los Angeles Times wrote:
How many ways can a movie go wrong? You will never really know until you see Blue City. The packaging fools you. How could you guess that a Ross MacDonald novel, scripted by action pros Walter Hill and Lukas Heller, would come out sounding addle-brained? Or that Judd Nelson and Ally Sheedy--of The Breakfast Club--could exhibit subzero chemistry? Or that sun-drenched Florida (re-created in San Pedro) could be so flat and homely? The action so preposterous? The sex so dull? The wisecracks so witless? If this movie were a vaudeville act, you'd be yelling "Give 'em the hook!" after 15 minutes. Maybe that's Blue City's problem: too many hooks. It's a high-concept "Young '80s" reworking of MacDonald's 1947 Hammett-style thriller--with no Lew Archer, no metaphor and no edge.
It was nominated for five Golden Raspberry Awards in the 7th Golden Raspberry Awards, but won none:
- Worst Actor (Nelson) (lost to Prince in Under the Cherry Moon)
- Worst Actress (Sheedy) (lost to Madonna in Shanghai Surprise)
- Worst Supporting Actor (Scott Wilson) (lost to Jerome Benton in Under the Cherry Moon)
- Worst Director (lost to Prince for Under the Cherry Moon)
- Worst Picture (lost in a tie to Howard the Duck and Under the Cherry Moon).
Sheedy later said she "didn't particularly like" the film:
Michelle Manning and I had been close friends. And she was so excited about the chance to direct that my feeling was it would be really great to work with someone I really liked and help contribute to their first big project. I was very naive, I guess, because I kept hoping it would turn out OK, that somehow all the stuff that was missing would miraculously appear when they edited it all together. I guess that's not the way it works, so I was disappointed.
Tanen's associate at Paramount, Dawn Steel, later said, "I suspect Michelle took her shot at directing too early. I think the experience for Michelle was unbelievably difficult. She may not necessarily have had the experience she needed. She didn't have the production support we thought we'd be able to supply her with. She was out there pretty much by herself. That's really tough your first time out. I think Michelle will turn out to have enormous amounts of talent. She kills herself. I never saw anyone work harder, ever. She's very smart. I think she'll be one of the few who gets a second chance. I don't think a first-time male director would have had much more luck than Michelle, given all those things. It had nothing to do with her being a woman."
After hearing Steel's comments, Manning said: "I think that's fair. I was out there pretty much on my own. In retrospect, I do think the critics were more tough on me than they had to be. I'm not a war criminal. I don't think many directors' first films are perfect. Maybe the timing wasn't right. There was a lot of `brat-pack' backlash." 
Manning had a production deal at Paramount as a producer and was developing projects elsewhere as a director. However she never directed another film.
- MILLS, NANCY (1986-11-19). "Women Directors: Door Opens - Page 3 - Los Angeles Times". Articles.latimes.com. Retrieved 2012-08-16.
- Will the Real Ross MacDonald Please Keep Writing? Adler, Dick. Los Angeles Times (1923-Current File) [Los Angeles, Calif] 10 Dec 1967: n79.
- Ross Macdonald, his Lew Archer and other secret selves: Ross Macdonald By JOHN LEONARD. New York Times (1923-Current file) [New York, N.Y] 01 June 1969: BR2.
- FILM CLIPS: YOUTH CALLS THE SHOTS IN 'BLUE CITY' London, Michael. Los Angeles Times (1923-Current File) [Los Angeles, Calif] 15 Feb 1985: l1.
- Mills, Nancy (4 May 1986). "MICHELLE MANNING'S 'BLUE CITY' / She's Textbook On How to Get What You Want/ Young director's obsession". San Francisco Chronicle. p. 40.
- Mills, Nancy (19 Nov 1986). "WOMEN DIRECTORS: DOOR OPENS Series: Third in a series charting the progress of women directors". Los Angeles Times. p. 1.
- Lyman, Rick (1 July 1985). "AN ACTOR PERCHED ON THE EDGE OF SUCCESS: SUDDENLY JUDD NELSON FINDS THAT DIRECTORS AND PRODUCERS ARE CALLING HIM". Philadelphia Inquirer. p. E.1.
- Haithman, Diane (8 May 1986). "Quiet Judd Nelson Plays It Tough Again". Chicago Tribune.
- Deansfirst=Laurie (2 May 1986). "LA CLIPS Blue City: film rejects novel's dark view". The Globe and Mail. p. D.5.
- Tough on top and mad below Lyttle, John. The Independent [London (UK)] 09 June 1995: 25.
- Kaye, Elizabeth (29 September 1985). "'Blue City': Ordinary People". Rolling Stone.
- WHATEVER HAPPENED TO THE: MISSING MOVIES OF 1985? BROESKE, PAT H. Los Angeles Times (1923-Current File) [Los Angeles, Calif] 19 Jan 1986: AB3.
- Broeske, Pat H. (11 May 1986). "BRAT WHAPPING". Los Angeles Times. p. Q14.
- Canby, Vincent (1986-05-02). "Movie Review - Blue City - FILM: 'BLUE CITY,' FLA. - NYTimes.com". Movies.nytimes.com. Retrieved 2012-08-16.
- "Blue City : DVD Talk Review of the DVD Video". Dvdtalk.com. Retrieved 2012-08-16.
- Wilmington, Michael (2 May 1986). "Nelson, Sheedy Misfire In High-concept 'Blue City'". Los Angeles Times.
- Razzies.com Archived July 16, 2012, at the Wayback Machine
- FOR A MOVIE STAR, SHE DOESN'T ACT THE PART Goldstein, Patrick. Los Angeles Times (1923-Current File) [Los Angeles, Calif] 13 May 1986: J1.