Mechanical biological treatment

A mechanical biological treatment (MBT) system is a type of waste processing facility that combines a sorting facility with a form of biological treatment such as composting or anaerobic digestion. MBT plants are designed to process mixed household waste as well as commercial and industrial wastes.

Process

Process flow chart

The terms mechanical biological treatment or mechanical biological pre-treatment relate to a group of solid waste treatment systems. These systems enable the recovery of materials contained within the mixed waste and facilitate the stabilisation of the biodegradable component of the material.^[1]^[2] Twenty two facilities in the UK have implemented MBT/BMT treatment processes.^[3]

The sorting component of the plants typically resemble a materials recovery facility. This component is either configured to recover the individual elements of the waste or produce a refuse-derived fuel that can be used for the generation of power.

The components of the mixed waste stream that can be recovered include:

Terminology

MBT is also sometimes termed biological mechanical treatment (BMT), however this simply refers to the order of processing (i.e., the biological phase of the system precedes the mechanical sorting). MBT should not be confused with mechanical heat treatment (MHT).

Mechanical sorting

Wet material recovery facility, Hiriya, Israel

The "mechanical" element is usually an automated mechanical sorting stage. This either removes recyclable elements from a mixed waste stream (such as metals, plastics, glass, and paper) or processes them. It typically involves factory style conveyors, industrial magnets, eddy current separators, trommels, shredders, and other tailor made systems, or the sorting is done manually at hand picking stations. The mechanical element has a number of similarities to a materials recovery facility (MRF).^[4]

Some systems integrate a wet MRF to separate by density and flotation and to recover and wash the recyclable elements of the waste in a form that can be sent for recycling. MBT can alternatively process the waste to produce a high calorific fuel termed refuse derived fuel (RDF). RDF can be used in cement kilns or thermal combustion power plants and is generally made up from plastics and biodegradable organic waste. Systems which are configured to produce RDF include the Herhof and Ecodeco processes. It is a common misconception that all MBT processes produce RDF; this is not the case, and depends strictly on system configuration and suitable local markets for MBT outputs.

Biological processing

Twin stage and upflow anaerobic sludge blanket digestion (UASB) anaerobic digesters

The "biological" element refers to either:

Anaerobic digestion harnesses anaerobic microorganisms to break down the biodegradable component of the waste to produce biogas and soil improver. The biogas can be used to generate electricity and heat.

Biological can also refer to a composting stage. Here the organic component is broken down by naturally occurring aerobic microorganisms. They break down the waste into carbon dioxide and compost. There is no green energy produced by systems employing only composting treatment for the biodegradable waste.

In the case of biodrying, the waste material undergoes a period of rapid heating through the action of aerobic microbes. During this partial composting stage the heat generated by the microbes result in rapid drying of the waste. These systems are often configured to produce a refuse-derived fuel where a dry, light material is advantageous for later transport and combustion.

Some systems incorporate both anaerobic digestion and composting. This may either take the form of a full anaerobic digestion phase, followed by the maturation (composting) of the digestate. Alternatively a partial anaerobic digestion phase can be induced on water that is percolated through the raw waste, dissolving the readily available sugars, with the remaining material being sent to a windrow composting facility.

By processing the biodegradable waste either by anaerobic digestion or by composting MBT technologies help to reduce the contribution of greenhouse gases to global warming.

Usable wastes for this system:

Possible products of this system:

Renewable fuel (biogas) leading to renewable power
Recovered recyclable materials such as metals, paper, plastics, glass etc.
Digestate - an organic fertiliser and soil improver
Carbon credits – additional revenues
High calorific fraction refuse derived fuel - renewable fuel content dependent upon biological component
Residual unusable materials prepared for their final safe treatment (e.g., incineration or gasification) and/or landfill

Further advantages:

Small fraction of inert residual waste
Reduction of the waste volume to be deposited to at least a half (density > 1.3 t/m³), thus the lifetime of the landfill is at least twice as long as usual
Utilisation of the leachate in the process
Landfill gas not problematic as biological component of waste has been stabilised
Daily covering of landfill not necessary

Consideration of applications

MBT systems can form an integral part of a region's waste treatment infrastructure. These systems are typically integrated with kerbside collection schemes. In the event that a refuse-derived fuel is produced as a by-product then a combustion facility would be required. This could either be an incineration facility or a gasifier.

Alternatively MBT solutions can diminish the need for home separation and kerbside collection of recyclable elements of waste. This gives the ability of local authorities, municipalities and councils to reduce the use of waste vehicles on the roads and keep recycling rates high.

Position of environmental groups

Friends of the Earth suggests that the best environmental route for residual waste is to firstly maximise removal of remaining recyclable materials from the waste stream (such as metals, plastics and paper). The amount of waste remaining should be composted or anaerobically digested and disposed of to landfill, unless sufficiently clean to be used as compost.

A report by Eunomia^[5] undertook a detailed analysis of the climate impacts of different residual waste technologies. It found that an MBT process that extracts both the metals and plastics prior to landfilling is one of the best options for dealing with our residual waste, and has a lower impact than either MBT processes producing RDF for incineration or incineration of waste without MBT.

Friends of the Earth does not support MBT plants that produce refuse derived fuel (RDF), and believes MBT processes should occur in small, localised treatment plants.^[6]

References

^ "Welcome to the Mechanical Biological Treatment Web Site". Cambridge, UK: Enviros Consulting. Archived from the original on 9 November 2007. Retrieved 22 November 2006.
^ "Mechanical Biological Treatment". Uley, Gloucestershire, England: Juniper Consultancy Services Ltd. Archived from the original on 14 December 2005.
^ Cook, Ed; Wagland, Stuart; Coulon, Frédéric (December 2015). "Investigation into the non-biological outputs of mechanical-biological treatment facilities". Waste Management. 46: 212–226. doi:10.1016/j.wasman.2015.09.014. PMID 26394679 – via ELSEVIER Science Direct.
^ MECHANICAL BIOLOGICAL TREATMENT Position Paper (PDF), SITA UK, May 2004, archived from the original (PDF) on 8 September 2006, retrieved 22 November 2006
^ Hogg, Dominic (3 May 2006), A Changing Climate for Energy from Waste? Final Report for Friends of the Earth (PDF), Eunomia Research & Consulting, archived from the original (PDF) on 15 July 2007
^ Briefing: Mechanical and Biological Treatment (MBT) (PDF), London, England, UK: Friends of the Earth, September 2008, archived from the original (PDF) on 21 May 2009

External links

Waste-to-Resources World's largest conference on mechanical biological treatment (MBT) of municipal solid waste (MSW) and material recovery facilities (MRF)
Environment Agency Waste Technology Data Centre An independent UK government review of advanced waste treatment technologies.
Kuehle-Weidemeier et al. (2007) Plants for Mechanical-Biological Waste Treatment Summary of the evaluation of all German MBT plants in the introduction phase 2005–2006. By order of the German EPA (Umweltbundesamt)
Juniper MBT report An independent study of MBT technologies commissioned with the use of UK landfill tax credits.
SEPA MBT Planning Information Sheet Fact Sheet for Scottish Planning Considerations
Compostinfo An independent comprehensive bibliography and review web site focusing on "mixed waste" sources
GTZ (2003) Sector project mechanical-biological waste treatment. Final report
Mechanical-biological waste treatment concept of FABER-AMBRA - Scientific results and videos

[1] "Welcome to the Mechanical Biological Treatment Web Site". Cambridge, UK: Enviros Consulting. Archived from the original on 9 November 2007. Retrieved 22 November 2006.

[2] "Mechanical Biological Treatment". Uley, Gloucestershire, England: Juniper Consultancy Services Ltd. Archived from the original on 14 December 2005.

[3] Cook, Ed; Wagland, Stuart; Coulon, Frédéric (December 2015). "Investigation into the non-biological outputs of mechanical-biological treatment facilities". Waste Management. 46: 212–226. doi:10.1016/j.wasman.2015.09.014. PMID 26394679 – via ELSEVIER Science Direct.

[4] MECHANICAL BIOLOGICAL TREATMENT Position Paper (PDF), SITA UK, May 2004, archived from the original (PDF) on 8 September 2006, retrieved 22 November 2006

[5] Hogg, Dominic (3 May 2006), A Changing Climate for Energy from Waste? Final Report for Friends of the Earth (PDF), Eunomia Research & Consulting, archived from the original (PDF) on 15 July 2007

[6] Briefing: Mechanical and Biological Treatment (MBT) (PDF), London, England, UK: Friends of the Earth, September 2008, archived from the original (PDF) on 21 May 2009

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]