Talk:Carlsbad Programme/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: CPA-5 (talk · contribs) 13:08, 27 September 2019 (UTC)

• Is the official name of the event really in German? If not then translate it.
• The Karlsbader Programm (German: Karlsbader Programm, Czech: Karlovy Vary program) Unlink German.
• of the first Czechoslovak Republic on April 24th, 1938 in Karlsbad (Modern-day Karlovy Vary) In Europe we use DD/MM/YYYY the only nations who use MM/DD/YYYY are the US, Canada and sometimes Israel too.
• Following pressure from Nazi Germany, Britain and France during Unlink both France and Britain because of common terms.
• the territory of the modern-day Czech Republic and Slovakia Little bit vague here. I thought that Czechoslovakia also parts of lands had in modern-day Ukraine?
• included the predominantly German-speaking Sudetenland Unlink German because of common term.
• We have here two "however"s in a short article like this. Maybe remove the second, however.
• The Sudeten Germans didn't want to belong to a Czechoslovak --> "The Sudeten Germans did not want to belong to a Czechoslovak"
• they were used to being part of the Austrian monarchy Link the Austrian monarchy.
• and they didn't suddenly want to be a minority in a state --> "and they did not suddenly want to be a minority in a state"
• "Sudeten Germans" is overlinked.
• be citizens of Czechoslovakia Unlink Czechoslovakia because it looks like an overlink.
• "Sudetenland" is overlinked.
• Sudeten German National Socialist Party v. Sudeten German Party standardise their usage.
• Third Reich in March 1938, Hitler made himself --> "Third Reich in March 1938, Adolf Hitler made himself"
• On the 24th April 1938, at an SdP party congress --> "On 24 April 1938, at an SdP party congress" We do not use ordinals in dates.
• party congress on the 24th April 1938 in the city Same as above.
• Czechoslovakia, to begin not later than the 1st of October --> "Czechoslovakia, to begin not later than 1 October"
• part of army maneuvers.[11][12] On the 4th or 5th of September --> "part of army maneuvers.[11][12] On 4 or 5 September"
• the Sudeten Germans weren't intent on conciliation --> "the Sudeten Germans were not intent on conciliation"
• On the 12th September, Hitler made a speech --> "On 12 September, Hitler made a speech"
• On the 13th September, after internal violence --> "On 13 September, after internal violence"
• in Berchtesgaden on the 15th September and agreed --> "in Berchtesgaden on 15 September and agreed"
• and on the 21st September, Czechoslovakia capitulated --> "and on 21 September, Czechoslovakia capitulated"
• On the 28th September, Hitler met with the --> "On 28 September, Hitler met with the"
• On the 29th September, the Munich Agreement was signed by Germany, Italy Pipe Italy and we do not use ordinals in dates.

Infobox

• There's none.

Images

• File:Konrad Henlein v Karlových Varech 1937.jpg How do we know it is copy-right free? I mean we do not know who was the author and when he died. Maybe he died in the 60s? Could you also give the image a link to the image?
• The rest looks good to me.

Sources

• Add a |language=German in the first ref
• Ref 2 is the same as ref 1.
• Split the "References" section in two and add all the books in the "bibliography" section. Add also page numbers in the "References" as the article's citation.
• Michael's ISBN should be linked.
• Ref 4 is a dead link. And it hasn't an access-date, date, or a title.
• Ref 5, 6, 7, 9, 12, 14, 15, 17 and 18 do not have a link or a book code. This is a major issue.
• Some ISBNs have hyphens and others don't maybe standardise them.

That's it for now. The sources are a major issue here if these comments are addressed then I'll have another review whether the sources are good placed and reliable or not. Cheers. CPA-5 (talk) 13:08, 27 September 2019 (UTC)

@KhakePakeVatan and CPA-5: How are we going with this? AIRcorn (talk) 07:28, 1 December 2019 (UTC)

@Aircorn I've been very busy with school work over the past few weeks and haven't been able to finish fixing the issues with the sources section. But, I'll be done in a few days and will get onto it asap. KhakePakeVatan (talk) 11:17, 1 December 2019 (UTC)

Thanks. AIRcorn (talk) 18:01, 1 December 2019 (UTC)

• If you want I can close it KhakePakeVatan if you need more time? Cheers. CPA-5 (talk) 22:14, 10 December 2019 (UTC)

CPA-5 Yeh, I think that would be better as I unfortunately just don't have time right now. I'm extremely busy. Thanks a lot though. KhakePakeVatan (talk) 03:02, 11 December 2019 (UTC)