Wikipedia:Peer review/Paul Hackett/archive1

Paul Hackett edit

A profile of the Democratic nominee in the special election in Ohio on August 2 that attracted national attention. Hackett, a lawyer who served in Iraq, ran a very strong campaign in a historically Republican district. Article has photos, maps, references. I'd really like to see this make featured status. It needs a good proofreading to start--I've looked at it so much, my eyes have glazed over and I know I'm not seeing problems. I am also submitting for peer review my article on the winning candidate, Jean Schmidt. (See Wikipedia:Peer review/Jean Schmidt/archive1 for that.) PedanticallySpeaking 19:16, August 17, 2005 (UTC)

All three images are claimed under fair use, so the image description pages will need fair-use rationales for why they can be used under fair use; see the image description pages at Jarmann M1884 for a good example of this. I'd also suggest removing one of the two photos of Paul Hackett, since fair-use images should be kept to a minimum. --Carnildo 21:34, 17 August 2005 (UTC)[reply]

So nothing to say about the actual content of the article, just criticism about the photographs? I've given a rationale for using the pictures. And there's two pictures, two. I really don't understand your criticism of the number. PedanticallySpeaking 17:43, August 19, 2005 (UTC)