Wikipedia:Peer review/Hong Kong action cinema/archive1

Hong Kong action cinema edit

Please list anything that could possibly prevent this article from becoming featured. is it comprehensive? how is the referencing? the writing quality? anything else? thx. Zzzzz 20:17, 24 March 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Having started and done a lot of work on Cinema of Thailand, I must say I'm flat-out impressed by Hong Kong action cinema. It's something to aspire to. References are solid (wish I had books), writing is accessible. Toward the end, I think there could be some more updating done - Jet Li making "his last martial arts epic" (Fearless), Jackie Chan still plugging away with The Myth. But hope seen with a return to form with SPL: Sha Po Lang. Maybe mention some up-and-coming HK action stars who will finally assume the mantle of Bruce-Jackie-Jet. Who are they? Wu Jing? Donnie Yen? Wisekwai 22:48, 24 March 2006 (UTC)[reply]

thx for the comments. updates are made with respect to jet li & jackie chan's latest activities. i dont think there is *any* hk action star to assume that mantle though - the 2 you mention are still not big stars after many years; if anybody it would be Tony Jaa who is so-far unconnected with hk cinema. anyway, its important to avoid original research for this article, so i think such speculation should be avoided. any other issues? Zzzzz 18:45, 29 March 2006 (UTC)[reply]