MissExplorer
NRHP: Carpenter #2 is actually listed on the NRHP, but as part of the Natchez-on-Top-of-the-Hill historic district, not individually, so it doesn't appear on the NRHP listing because it's within a district. This is very common, but the building is considered a contributing element (#671) and is therefore listed on the NRHP.--MissExplorer (talk) 04:57, 21 December 2009 (UTC)
A recent edit of yours to the Threefoot Building article added Claude H. Lindsley as the principal architect of the building, claiming he appeared in many sources. I've researched the building a lot and have never come across his name; could you please provide a reference for me? I won't revert the edit, but I think such a claim should be cited in the article. Thanks! --Dudemanfellabra (talk) 05:29, 8 January 2010 (UTC)
- I know that the National Register nomination ascribes the building only to Frank Fort, but I really don't understand how that misinformation entered the official record. The plaque in the lobby, which appears to be original to the building, names C.H. Lindsley of Jackson as architect and Frank Fort of Meridian as "Associate." In addition, the enginners (Gardner & Howe and C.A. Peerman), along with all the contractors and directors of the Threefoot Company appear on the plaque. C.H. Lindsley is also named as the architect in the Atlantic Terra Cotta Co. advertisements in the July 1931 Pencil Points and the May 1931 issue of Southern Architect and Building News. If you'd like, I could send you copies of those 1931 citations or a picture of the plaque? Just let me know, as I am fairly new to the Wikipedia world and certainly don't want to get into trouble.MissExplorer (talk) 21:31, 12 January 2010 (UTC)
- Oh, so are you a native of Meridian? I am as well, but I guess I've never taken the time to go inside the lobby or anything. I've only taken pictures from the outside. While I'm not saying you're lying, local knowledge is not enough to warrant any addition to a Wikipedia article. Usually you need what's called reliable source (click on the wikilink for an explanation) to add information, and it should be visible to others. If you could take a picture of the plaque and upload it to the Commons, that would be great, or if you could find the Pencil Points or Southern Architect and Building News editions that name Lindsley as the principal architect, that would be great. For now, I'll trust your word and won't revert your edit, but a source is really needed to add that kind of information.
- That said, welcome to Wikipedia haha. It's really not that hard to get in the swing of things around here.. pretty much you can scower the internet looking for sources that say things about whatever you want to write about and cite those sources in the article. (Before you added Lindsley's name, I added some information from a few articles in the Meridian Star about Cheri Barry's epic fail on the Threefoot Building restoration deal, so if you want to look back in the page history of that article to see what I'm talking about, go ahead.) There are many helpful people out here, so if you have a question about anything just ask; I'll be glad to answer anything, and so will many other people. There are also some helpful links on the Main Page that tell you what to do in certain situations (though I confess I use User:Dudemanfellabra/Sandbox2 as my custom main page because I think it looks better and is more helpful).
- Like I said, if you have any questions, don't be afraid to ask. Happy editing! --Dudemanfellabra (talk) 22:19, 12 January 2010 (UTC)