User:StarryGrandma/Example articles

Examples of articles in various areas and information for reviewing articles.

General comments edit

Notability edit

Individual approaches to editing edit

Editing in controversial areas edit

"Anyone can edit here" - but there are rules edit

Writing an article edit

Citing sources edit

Academics edit

  • Owen Astrachan - professor of computer science, field curriculum and teaching methods, low publication and citations for professors doing this sort of thing. Instead on meeting panels, special sessions, etc. at meetings of groups like ACM SIGCSE as recorded in his cv and in the Bulletin.
  • Catherine L. Besteman - anthropologist
  • Martha Copp - stub with enough to show notability including reasonable list of selected publications
  • Rae Helen Langton - professor of philosophy whose CV provided extensive autobiographical information
  • John Swinton (theologian)
  • Margaret Hotchkiss - very nice research section

From DGG's talk page - Basic cleanup steps for professors (and much of it applies to all bios) Oct 2014

For help in writing an article see User:StarryGrandma/Writing an article about a professor or researcher.

An example of a photo from the public relations department of a university

On WP:Notability (academic) edit

Fellows (professional organizations) edit

My comment at AfD for Adem Yetim:

  • There may be some confusion about the meaning of being a Fellow of a professional society where the term is a membership level and of being a Fellow of other professional societies where the term Fellow is reserved for honorary awards. The BCS Fellow is a membership level for senior people in the profession. A person applies for it themselves; there is an application fee. Fellows pay higher dues. This is different from the American computing societies. Fellow is an honorary award given to a limited number of members. A person does not apply for it but must be nominated by others. There are no fees. Receiving it has no effect on dues. See ACM Fellows and IEEE Fellows. BCS does have an equivalent award, Distinguished Fellow of the British Computer Society. (Oct 2021)

Examples of non-honorary fellows

Authors edit

Useful reviewer comments edit

Children's books edit

Useful reviewer comments edit

Companies edit

Useful reviewer comments edit

References edit

  • International directory of company histories - print, also a database avail at some libraries. See use in Honeywell from here.

Computing edit

Women in computing edit

Applicable to women in many fields, in response to Google's Ideological Echo Chamber see "The e-mail Larry Page should have written to James Damore". The Economist. Vol. 424, no. 9054. 19 August 2017.

Organizations edit

Revealing editor comments edit

Schools edit

While the Notability documents don't say this, there is a statement at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Common outcomes#Schools that says "Most independently accredited degree-awarding institutions and high schools are being kept except when zero independent sources can be found to prove that the institution actually exists." (Retrieved February 2015)

Scientific articles edit

References edit

On Articles for Deletion edit

On Articles for Creation edit

Ask for two references test edit

Some of these are new and editors might respond, others are old review requests

On New Page Patrol and Draft namespace edit