| Number | Name | Position | Date first cap obtained | Opposition | Identified as |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 | H.J.C. Turner | forward | 1871-03-27 | v Scotland at Edinburgh | Henry John Cecil Turner |
| 34 | P. Wilkinson | halfback | 1872-02-05 | v Scotland at The Oval | Percival Wilkinson |
| 63 | A.W. Pearson | fullback | 1875-02-15 | v Ireland at The Oval | Alexander William Pearson |
| 68 | J.E. Paul | forward | 1875-03-08 | v Scotland at Edinburgh | Josiah Edward Paul |
| 69 | J.V. Brewer | forward | 1875-12-13 | v Ireland at Dublin | Jeaffreson Vennor Brewer |
| 71 | A.J. Bulteel | forward | 1875-12-13 | v Ireland at Dublin | Andrew Bulteel |
| 90 | P.L.A. Price | halfback | 1877-02-05 | v Ireland at The Oval | Petley Price |
| 153 | G. Standing | forward | 1882-12-16 | v Wales at Swansea | Not yet identified (strong indication this is Graham Standing) |
| 172 | F. Moss | forward | 1885-01-03 | v Wales at Swansea | Frank Moss |
| 240 | W.B. Thomson | fullback | 1892-01-02 | v Wales at Blackheath | Wardlaw Brown Thomson |
| 289 | W. Whiteley | forward | 1896-01-04 | v Wales at Blackheath | W. Bobby Whiteley |
| 379 | T.J. Willcocks | forward | 1902-01-11 | v Wales at Blackheath | Not yet identified scrum says Thomas Henry Willcocks |
| 459 | R. Gilbert | forward | 1908-01-18 | v Wales at Bristol | Not yet identified scrum says Dick Gilbert (rugby) |
