- Irv Panciera (1952)
- Jim DiGiorno (1953–1955)
- John Livieri (1956)
- Gerry D'Avolio (1957)
- Harry Drivas (1958–1959)
- Tom Kopp (1960)
- Joe Klimas (1961)
- Lou Aceto (1962–1964)
- Dave Whaley (1965)
- Paul Gruner (1966)
- Pete Petrillo (1967)
- Rick Robustelli (1968–1970)
- Ray Tellier (1971–1972)
- Lou Mancari (1973)
- Bernie Palmer (1974–1976)
- Maron Clark (1977)
- Ken Sweitzer (1978–1981)
- Alan Arison (1979)
- Rob Trivella (1982)
- Larry Corn (1983)
- Chris Riley (1984)
- Peter Lane (1985–1986)
- Matt DeGennaro (1987–1990)
- Cornelius Benton (1991)
- Tom DeSarno (1992)
- Zeke Rodgers (1993–1994)
- Shane Stafford (1995–1998)
- Brian Hoffmann (1999)
- Luke Richmond (1999–2000)
- Ryan Tracey (2000)
- Chris Willis (2000)
- Keron Henry (2001)
- Dan Orlovsky (2001–2004)
- Matt Bonislawski (2005–2006)
- D. J. Hernandez (2005–2006)
- Dennis Brown (2005)
- Tyler Lorenzen (2007–2008)
- Zach Frazer (2008–2010)
- Cody Endres (2008–2010)
- Michael Box (2010)
- Johnny McEntee (2011)
- Chandler Whitmer (2012–2014)
- Tim Boyle (2013–2015)
- Casey Cochran (2013–2014)
- Bryant Shirreffs (2015–2017)
- Donovan Williams (2016)
- David Pindell (2017–2018)
- Michael Beaudry (2019)
- Jack Zergiotis (2019, 2021)
- Steven Krajewski (2021)
- Tyler Phommachanh (2021)
- Ta'Quan Roberson (2022–2023)
- Zion Turner (2022)
- Joseph Fagnano (2023)
|
