Talk:The Suite Life Sets Sail

Reception

I removed the following statements: "It received generally favorable reviews. Mila Fairchild from TV.com rated it with a six out of ten, saying that while it is an excellent start, it lacks the information to tell "what happened to Maddie", and that it is a "little reluctant to dress as a boy"."

The first citation to Commonsensemedia.org is a review of the series as a whole, not of this episode. The second citation to Mila Fairchild is just a fan review, which is credited not to "Mila Fairchild" but to "FrigginGodess". Furthermore, saying that the episode is a "little reluctant to dress as a boy" doesn't make sense because episodes aren't people and don't wear clothes. Nor is it an accurate quote from the review, which says, "It's kinda reducdant [sic] to dress as a boy. I mean, yeah, it fills in the spot, but, look; that other girl left. Surely, they would know!" "Reducdant" isn't a word, and I don't know what the reviewer meant. Maybe "redundant" instead? --Metropolitan90 (talk) 21:32, 1 December 2013 (UTC)