Talk:Soo Line 2718

Latest comment: 6 years ago by Rhadow in topic Original research

Original research edit

This excellent article about a particular locomotive is all original research. The article has no references that indicate the existence of the locomotive or any of the details, apparently painstakingly collected since 2007. The article fails WP:V. This particular locomotive is partially described in a brochure [1]. Evidently its existence is enough to ascribe notability WP:N. The article ought to say why it is notable and deserves to be in an encyclopedia. Ten years should be long enough to add these details to the article. It is up to the editor adding text to provide references. Rhadow (talk) 12:07, 10 October 2017 (UTC)Reply