Talk:Robert Aitken (sculptor)

Merge proposal

Since the requisite statement wasn't made, I'll put my 2 cents here. I'd say this article should be merged with Robert Ingersoll Aitken, not the other way around. Parenthetical disambiguations should only be used when absolutely necessary. Since his full name is a very common usage (much more common than first name, last name, and "sculptor" in parenthesis) it is the proper title for the article. Sorry that whoever wrote this article went to all that trouble when there was already an article under his full name, but that doesn't change the naming convention. Kafziel ^Talk 06:36, 10 April 2007 (UTC)

I am the editor responsible (or perhaps, irresponsible) for this page and have no problem merging it with Robert Ingersoll Aitken. I think a note should be left at the Robert Aitken discombobulation page about it, replacing the one for the (sculptor) so that folks looking for him without his middle name will get there. Heck, I'll even help with the merger. Carptrash 13:46, 10 April 2007 (UTC)

I made it a redirect so anyone who links to this page or searches for this will be automatically sent to the right place. Thanks for your help with the merge. Kafziel ^Talk 14:35, 10 April 2007 (UTC)