Talk:Kurt Maschler Award

Latest comment: 10 years ago by P64 in topic Coverage

Administered edit

What does it mean to be "administered" by Book Trust and "run" by Tom Maschler --in the words of the cited source; administered and "overseen" in our words? --P64 (talk) 01:00, 26 June 2012 (UTC)Reply

For some period of time Tom Maschler was the head of publisher Jonathan Cape, according to our biography. While expanding this article today I have learned that Cape published three or four of the KMAward-winning books. --P64 (talk) 18:42, 21 July 2012 (UTC)Reply

Sources edit

We should find a more reliable source than ref name=bizland. That webpage lists

  • "1992 Raymond Briggs The Man illustrated by Julia MacRae" -- actually ill. Briggs, publ. MacRae
  • "1991 Colin McNaughton Guess Who's Just Moved in Next Door" -- which is U.S. title of Have You Seen Who's Just Moved in Next Door to Us?

My source is single WorldCat records that I have located and consulted one by one primarily to identify the first ed. publishers.

Where I believe I have located a first ed. WorldCat record I have provided the id as a comment in the publisher field (!-- oclc=59945578 --).

--P64 (talk) 18:42, 21 July 2012 (UTC)Reply

Coverage edit

Last year I added some coverage with [ref name=bizland] to several of the biographies of Maschler Award winners. This weekend I expanded some and did several others.

These are notes to be replaced by some summary after I re/visited all the biographies. "mere" means that the Maschler Award is named without any explanation (minimally, "integrated writing and illustration").

Illustrator and writer (7 awards, 6 biogs)

Browne - prose full + 3 book listings as "the Emil"
Burningham - prose full
Blake - prose full
McNaughton - prose full
Briggs - prose full
Cole - prose full

Illustrator only (11 more awards, 10 more people, 6 biogs, 4 redlinks)

Foreman - adequate book listing
Davidson - prose full
J. Ahlberg - prose adequate
Keeping - adequate award listing
Browne —see above—-
Oxenbury - prose full + 2 book listings

Writer only (11 more awards, 10 more people, 7 biogs, 3 redlinks)

Carter, ed/translator - ENTIRELY MISSING
Hughes (1968) - ENTIRELY MISSING (appropriate in the biog?)
A. Ahlberg - adequate note that does not underscore Allan & Janet collaboration
Causley - adequate book listing
Carroll (1865) - ENTIRELY MISSING (appropriate in the biog)
Waddell - adequate book listing
Mayne - adequate award listing

I am not sure which writers are equal partners in a relevant sense. I did not provide the same "full" coverage in any of their biographies.

Books (18 awards, 5 articles)

Granpa (film adaptation) - prose full (new section on the book)
Iron Man - prose full
Jolly Postman - prose full
The Man - prose full
Alice (2 awards) - adequate in section Publication timeline, 1988 and 1999

--P64 (talk) 02:59, 7 October 2013 (UTC)Reply