| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Imposition vs. derived |
13 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Imposition vs. derived
|
| Criticism section |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Criticism section
|
| Reverts |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Reverts
|
| Criticism section again |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Criticism section again
|
| Hadith of "unverifiable veracity" |
3 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Hadith of "unverifiable veracity"
|
| Universal Declaration of Human Rights |
9 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Universal Declaration of Human Rights
|
| Business about shaking by the throat |
8 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Business about shaking by the throat
|
| General observations on this article |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#General observations on this article
|
| The Caliph Umar changed the word jizyah to sadaqah to improve its connotation from "tribute" to "friendly charity". |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#The Caliph Umar changed the word jizyah to sadaqah to improve its connotation from "tribute" to "friendly charity".
|
| Arabic root of the word jizyah |
18 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Arabic root of the word jizyah
|
| Requested move to jizya |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Requested move to jizya
|
| Removed quote about letter attributed to Muhammad |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Removed quote about letter attributed to Muhammad
|
| The Hedaya's definition of jizyah |
32 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#The Hedaya's definition of jizyah
|
| No other histories (Muslim or secular) |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#No other histories (Muslim or secular)
|
| Gil the Jew |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Gil the Jew
|
| Definitions belong in the definition section |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Definitions belong in the definition section
|
| 4th revert |
7 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#4th revert
|
| Explanation of my Edits. |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Explanation of my Edits.
|
| Amendments |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Amendments
|
| Moshe Gil |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Moshe Gil
|
| Explanation for changes |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Explanation for changes
|
| History section |
10 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#History section
|
| What exactly is disputed? |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#What exactly is disputed?
|
| Yay !! a brand new Yuber revert war. |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Yay !! a brand new Yuber revert war.
|
| Yuber back AGAIN? |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Yuber back AGAIN?
|
| Protected |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Protected 2
|
| Rearrangement of the article |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 1#Rearrangement of the article
|
| Ongoing mediation |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Ongoing mediation
|
| oldid=43164168 |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#oldid=43164168
|
| Jesus? |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Jesus?
|
| Question |
8 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Question
|
| Sura 9:29 |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Sura 9:29
|
| Jizya camel incident |
9 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Jizya camel incident
|
| Criticism's not very critical |
8 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Criticism's not very critical
|
| The neutrality has been compromised |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#The neutrality has been compromised
|
| Jizya collection in parts of Egypt |
18 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Jizya collection in parts of Egypt
|
| Khomeini speech |
4 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Khomeini speech
|
| I am going to take this Out |
11 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#I am going to take this Out
|
| Sources Required! |
19 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Sources Required!
|
| Other article |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Other article
|
| Aminz's insertions |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Aminz's insertions
|
| In contrast to Zakat |
44 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#In contrast to Zakat
|
| Truthpedia's latest edits |
19 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Truthpedia's latest edits
|
| Apologetics |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Apologetics
|
| Good deletions |
4 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 2#Good deletions
|
| Zakat again |
13 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Zakat again
|
| Comment on the above sources |
9 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Comment on the above sources
|
| Other references |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Other references
|
| Jizya in the Nineteenth Century |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Jizya in the Nineteenth Century
|
| Moshe Gil, pg. 28 |
83 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Moshe Gil, pg. 28
|
| Or else` |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Or else`
|
| Jizye |
3 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Jizye
|
| Recent whitewashing |
8 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Recent whitewashing
|
| Lead |
3 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Lead
|
| Choudhury |
14 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Choudhury
|
| Hadith |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 3#Hadith
|
| Moshe Gil's quote |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 4#Moshe Gil's quote
|
| Hadith |
34 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 4#Hadith
|
| Moshe Gil's quote again |
87 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 4#Moshe Gil's quote again
|
| Two cities |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 4#Two cities
|
| Civility in edit summaries |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 4#Civility in edit summaries
|
| An alternate version |
30 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 4#An alternate version
|
| Constitution of Medina |
82 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 4#Constitution of Medina
|
| Modern Pakistan |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Modern Pakistan
|
| Criticism section |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Criticism section
|
| Maliki School |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Maliki School
|
| Some POV concerns |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Some POV concerns
|
| appel a l'aide |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#appel a l'aide
|
| Proposal to remove the discrimination sidebar |
11 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Proposal to remove the discrimination sidebar
|
| Proposal to Make Current |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Proposal to Make Current
|
| Twenty-first century addition should be added |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Twenty-first century addition should be added
|
| Tagged for source |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Tagged for source
|
| Explaining revert |
4 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Explaining revert
|
| Improperly/unspecifically cited sources |
5 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Improperly/unspecifically cited sources
|
| Punishment for non-payment |
4 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Punishment for non-payment
|
| Two issues. |
18 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Two issues.
|
| Lack of proper sources |
3 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Lack of proper sources
|
| Various disputes related to edits made by user RLoutfy |
95 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#Various disputes related to edits made by user RLoutfy
|
| Summary |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Summary
|
| On the Qur'an subsection |
22 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#On the Qur'an subsection
|
| Edit vandalism per RLoutfy. |
40 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 6#Edit vandalism per RLoutfy.
|
| Arnold as source |
10 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 6#Arnold as source
|
| 50% rate |
45 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 6#50% rate
|
| RLoutfy's POV edits |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#RLoutfy's POV edits
|
| A contradiction |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#A contradiction
|
| Hadith Source (section needs review) |
11 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Hadith Source (section needs review)
|
| Stable version until consensus is reached |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 5#Stable version until consensus is reached
|
| Etymology and meaning (section needs review) |
14 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Etymology and meaning (section needs review)
|
| The Royal Aal Al-Bayt Institute For Islamic Thought and NOENG |
11 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 6#The Royal Aal Al-Bayt Institute For Islamic Thought and NOENG
|
| Removal of total revenue numbers |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 6#Removal of total revenue numbers
|
| Removal of 50% of produce as jizya rate |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 6#Removal of 50% of produce as jizya rate
|
| Jizya less than zakat |
22 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#Jizya less than zakat
|
| Jizya versus kharaj |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#Jizya versus kharaj
|
| "Poorly cited" deletion |
5 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#"Poorly cited" deletion
|
| Rationale section |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#Rationale section
|
| the exemptions to jizya in the lede |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#the exemptions to jizya in the lede
|
| RFC for one of the opening sentences in the lede |
51 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#RFC for one of the opening sentences in the lede
|
| Section organization |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#Section organization
|
| Is the "Comparison between Zakat and Jizya under Islamic law" table necessary? |
5 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#Is the "Comparison between Zakat and Jizya under Islamic law" table necessary?
|
| Removal of hadith section |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 7#Removal of hadith section
|
| Abu Yusuf and the exemption of monks from jizya |
14 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Abu Yusuf and the exemption of monks from jizya
|
| Add the jizya tax to the series and portal on discrimination |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Add the jizya tax to the series and portal on discrimination
|
| Payment of the jizya by new converts to Islam until 720? |
3 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Payment of the jizya by new converts to Islam until 720?
|
| Jizya and conversion to Islam |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Jizya and conversion to Islam
|
| is it historically true? |
23 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#is it historically true?
|
| Ameliorating this paragraph in the lede |
7 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Ameliorating this paragraph in the lede
|
| Associated Taxes, unnecessary section? |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Associated Taxes, unnecessary section?
|
| Return of jizya |
4 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Return of jizya
|
| ‘Minor’ detail |
5 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#‘Minor’ detail
|
| Khalid b. aI-Walid and the jizya as means to spare the blood |
7 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 8#Khalid b. aI-Walid and the jizya as means to spare the blood
|
| Translations: Ar -> En |
12 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 9#Translations: Ar -> En
|
| Al-Nawawi on the treatment of the dhimmis |
21 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 9#Al-Nawawi on the treatment of the dhimmis
|
| Rewriting the 'Rate of jizya tax' subsection |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 9#Rewriting the 'Rate of jizya tax' subsection
|
| English translation of Qu'ran 9:29 |
51 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 9#English translation of Qu'ran 9:29
|
| Al-Buti translation |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 9#Al-Buti translation
|
| Indeed, in the view of the majority of Fuqahā (Islamic jurists), the jizya is levied on non-Muslims in order to humiliate them for their unbelief. |
8 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 9#Indeed, in the view of the majority of Fuqahā (Islamic jurists), the jizya is levied on non-Muslims in order to humiliate them for their unbelief.
|
| taxes levied on non-Muslim subjects were among the main sources of revenues collected by some Islamic polities |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 9#taxes levied on non-Muslim subjects were among the main sources of revenues collected by some Islamic polities
|
| العبرة بالمقاصد والمعاني لا بالألفاظ والمباني |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 9#العبرة بالمقاصد والمعاني لا بالألفاظ والمباني
|
| Five pence |
6 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 10#Five pence
|
| Did you say "protection" ? |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 10#Did you say "protection" ?
|
| Ibn Qayyim on ‘an yadin wa-hum ṣāghirūn |
2 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 10#Ibn Qayyim on ‘an yadin wa-hum ṣāghirūn
|
| Orphaned references in Jizya |
1 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 10#Orphaned references in Jizya
|
| Multiple Issues and Vandalism by islamic apologist editors |
5 |
Talk:Jizya/Archive 10#Multiple Issues and Vandalism by islamic apologist editors
|
| Sources |
2 |
Talk:Jizya#Sources
|
| Timeline of antisemitism has an RfC |
1 |
Talk:Jizya#Timeline of antisemitism has an RfC
|
| This article needs a paragraph to portray secular view of jizya |
1 |
Talk:Jizya#This article needs a paragraph to portray secular view of jizya
|
