Wikipedia

Talk:Du hast

Latest comment: 9 years ago by 89.168.251.31 in topic Video
Learn more about this page

Does posting the lyrics or partial lyrics of a song violate copyright? edit

Latest comment: 17 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion
Partial lyrics seem to be fine (see The Beatles, which has sample tracks of some songs). Except for a very few songs I think the level of detail should limited to albums. --mav
Full lyrics does not violate copyright provided the lyrics are duplicated for the purposes of criticism or review. However, I think most people would agree that in this case the criticism/review isn't long or detailed enough to justify reproducing the song in its entirety, so legal trouble may result. Either significantly expand the article to include more discussion of specific lyrics in the song, or remove the lyrics not directly addressed by the existing article, or delete the article altogether. —Psychonaut 16:38, 6 Feb 2004 (UTC)
I think the criticism/review is long and detailed enough to justify reproducing the entrie lyrics in nits entirety. You really can't leave anything out and still make the same point. On the other hand, I think expanding the article would be a good thing, and then just about no one would have a problem with it any more. Anthony DiPierro 22:40, 6 Feb 2004 (UTC)

This looks fine to me. It's a transformative use (discussion rather than song), no more than required and can't replace the original work int eh marketplace (it's not complete lyrics and not a song people can listen to), so we'll pass the fair use tests easily. It's not a problem to use the whole of a work when that's what's required for the purpose. Jamesday 12:24, 7 Feb 2004 (UTC)

Is there any reason for the lyrics being all in upper case? I know the band shout, but I don't think we should. --Camembert

Fixed. --Chuck Smith

I've added a third column, containing the lyrics to the band's English version, which is a non-literal translation. This adds even more copyrighted content, but I think puts us very firmly in the context of scholarly criticism—we're comparing their own German and English versions with our own literal English translation of the German version, and commenting on the puns therein. --Delirium 00:38, Feb 7, 2004 (UTC)

Tabs: 

Rammstien (CORRECT!) Du Haust Mich BY:CHRIS MORGAN
Tuning: E B G D A E				          ~
~ = roll your tounge when the ~ is above the letters ex. Bistere
(you would roll the ere)
\ = slide down
/ = slide up  
pm = slightly muted with the palm
cg = cut off the note and go to next
c = cut off the note
INTRO:
|-E-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|-7-\-5---2---2- -222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--7-\-5--2--2--222---22--7-\-5--2--2--222--2222-
|-E-|-5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--5-\-3--0--0--000---00--5-\-3--0--0--000--0000-
			 |					          |
              cg					        cg
|-E-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5--2--2--222--22--7-\-5--2--2--222--2222--5-/-7--77--777--7777----STOP--------
|-E-|--5-\-3--0--0--000--00--5-\-3--0--0--000--0000--3-/-5--55--555--5555----STOP--------
		            |
		           cg

VERSE 1: Du.....Du haust......Du haust meash....... Du.....Du haust......Du haust meash....... 

Du.....Du haust......Du haust meash.......... Du.....Du haust......Du haust meash.............

CHORUS 1:
|-E-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|-7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--7-\-5--2--2--222---22--7-\-5--2--2--222--2222-
|-E-|-5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--5-\-3--0--0--000---00--5-\-3--0--0--000--0000-
			  |					           |
  cg					          cg
|-E-|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5--2--2--222--22--7-\-5--2--2--222--2222--5-/-7--77--777--7777----STOP-----
|-E-|--5-\-3--0--0--000--00--5-\-3--0--0--000--0000--3-/-5--55--555--5555----STOP------
		            |
		           cg
VERSE 2: Du.....Du haust......Du haust meash.....Du haust meash! Du haust meash gufragt, 

Du haust meash gufragt, Du haust meash gufragt und ich ahm  nishck|gey|zshaagt..........

CHORUS 2:
|-E-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77--777--7777-
|-E-|--5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55--555--5555-
			     |
                             cg
        ~                               ~		               ~
Wville	sue        bistere	tota      shielenn,   tlroy  ere zien   fuere    hallen    tahgen

|-E-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-/-10---1010--101010-10-10---12-\-9---99---999---9999----
|-E-|--5-/--8---8-8----8-8-8--8--8---10-\-7---77---777---7777----
          			            |	          nie!
			          cg   

|-E-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|-7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--7-\-5--2--2--222---22--7-\-5--2--2--222--2222-
|-E-|-5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--5-\-3--0--0--000---00--5-\-3--0--0--000--0000-
		                |					          |
  			cg					         cg
								          ~		              ~
        nie!          		 Wville      sue        bistere         tota        shielenn,   

|-E-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77---777--7777---7-/-10--1010---101010-10-10-----
|-E-|--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55---555--5555---5-/--8----8-8-----8--8-8---8--8-
			  						 |
  						cg
           	          ~	      
         tlroy  ere zien   fuere          hallen        tahgen


|-E-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|---12-\-9---99---999---9999----7-\-5--2--2--222--22---7-\-5--2--2--222--2222
|-E-|---10-\-7---77---777---7777----5-\-3--0--0--000--00---5-\-3--0--0--000--0000
                  nie!					 |     nie!
						cg   

|-E-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|-7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77--777--7777-
|-E-|-5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55--555--5555-
		                |
  			cg

|-E-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-/-10---1010--101010-1010--12--\-9---99---999---9999--7-\-5--2--2--222--22-----
|-E-|--5-/--8-----8-8----8-8--8---8-8---10-\-7---77---777---7777--5-\-3--0--0--000--00-
           |						   |
			          cg						  cg

|-E-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5----2---2---222--2222--STOP------------------------------------------------
|-E-|--5-\-3----0---0---000--0000--STOP------------------------------------------------

VERSE 3: ........Du.....Du haust......Du haust meash....... Du.....Du haust......Du haust meash.......

CHORUS 3:

|-E-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|-7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77--777--7777-
|-E-|-5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55--555--5555-
			 |
		              cg
         Du                            Du haust     Du haust meash            Du haust meash! 

|-E-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-/-10---1010--101010-1010--12--\-9---99---999---9999--7-\-5--2--2--222--22-----
|-E-|--5-/--8-----8-8----8-8--8---8-8---10-\-7---77---777---7777--5-\-3--0--0--000--00-
           |						   |
			          cg						  cg

    Du haust meash gufragt           Du haust meash gufragt     Du haust meash gufragt und ich


|-E-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--7-\-5--2--2--222---22--7-\-5--2--2--222--2222---
|-E-|--5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--5-\-3--0--0--000---00--5-\-3--0--0--000--0000---
			 		             |					        
  		           cg
           ahm  nishck|gey|zshaagt

|-E-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77---777--7777---7-/-10--1010---101010-10-10--------
|-E-|--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55---555--5555---5-/--8----8-8-----8--8-8---8--8----
			  						 |
  									cg

|-E-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|---12--\-9---99---999---9999--7--STOP------------------------------------------------------
|-E-|----10-\-7---77---777---7777--5--STOP------------------------------------------------------

|-E-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77--777--7777-
|-E-|--5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55--555--5555-
			  |
  cg
           		      ~                                 ~		          ~
  Wville	sue    bistere  tota      shielenn,   tlroy  ere zien   fuere         hallen    tahgen

|-E-|-------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|-------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|-------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|-------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-/-10---1010--101010-10-10---12-\-9---99---999---9999-----
|-E-|--5-/--8-----8-8----8-8--8---8--8---10-\-7---77---777---7777-
          			            |	          nie!
			           cg   

|-E-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--7-\-5--2--2--222---22--7-\-5--2--2--222--2222-
|-E-|--5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--5-\-3--0--0--000---00--5-\-3--0--0--000--0000-
			  |					          |
  			cg					         cg				  
nie!          		 Wville      sue        bistum        totadere shi dazee   

|-E-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77---777--7777---7-/-10--1010---101010-10-10-----
|-E-|--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55---555--5555---5-/--8----8-8-----8--8-8---8--8-
			  						 |
  						cg
        eeleebuanow   khhenn      schletchen    tahgen

|-E-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|---12-\-9---99---999---9999----7-\-5--2--2--222--22---7-\-5--2--2--222--2222-
|-E-|---10-\-7---77---777---7777----5-\-3--0--0--000--00---5-\-3--0--0--000--0000-
                  nie!					 |     nie!
						cg   
|-E-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77--777--7777-
|-E-|--5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55--555--5555-
			  |
  cg
           		      ~                                 		          
Wville   sue    bistere	     tota      shielent      roy    ere       kkhhhhiiiiiiiiiiiiiiieeeeeeenn

|-E-|----------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|----------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|----------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|----------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-/-10---1010--101010-10-10---12-\-9---99---999---9999--------
|-E-|--5-/--8-----8-8----8-8--8---8--8---10-\-7---77---777---7777----
          			            |	          nie!
			          cg   
|-E-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-B-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-G-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-D-|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|-A-|--7-\-5---2---2---222--22---7-\-5----2---2--222--2222--5-/-7--77--777--7777--5-/-7--77--777--7777-
|-E-|--5-\-3---0---0---000--00---5-\-3----0---0--000--0000--3-/-5--55--555--5555--3-/-5--55--555--5555-
 |
  cg

This was copied from the article - may be a copyvio? Certainly seems excessive. Secretlondon 23:01, 4 Mar 2004 (UTC)

(Who posted this shit?) Wow dude, at least learn some German before you start...doing whatever the hell you were trying to do...--Wikiwøw ­­ 20:35, 18 October 2006 (UTC)Reply

lol.Tabs are too confusing so here is the chords(note this is,too,confusing) 

                                  ~Main ®iff~
                         .     . slide .       . barre here

X-------X-------|<-----------| tuning machines

X--------X----------|<-----------| Tuning machines

continue until it reverses the slide chords so it raises the pitch ~chörus~ 

(lick)to this to this 1 this chord

X<3----X<2----X<3-----X<1-----X--------------------------

X---X----X---X------X------X-----------------------

Single Infobox edit

Latest comment: 18 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion

I moved the info box to the bottom of the page in a new section (Single). It is better there because the lyrics no longer overlap it. --Der Sporkmeister 23:53, 24 October 2005 (UTC)Reply

Malformed HTML edit

Latest comment: 17 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion

The first paragraph of this entry seems to have some malformed HTML. I wasn't quite sure what the intent of the first paragraph was. Someone may wish to fix this.--Silverhand 18:05, 6 July 2006 (UTC)Reply

Animutation flash file edit

Removed because it doesn't seem encyclopedic to me to just leave it there. --Addict 2006 16:18, 19 November 2006 (UTC)

"Willst du, bis zum Tod der Scheide, ..." edit

Latest comment: 11 years ago3 comments3 people in discussion
  • "Willst Du, bis zum Tod, der scheide, ..." = "Do you want (Are you willing), until the death that divorces, ..."
  • "Willst Du, bis zum Tod der Scheide, ..." = "Do you want (Are you willing), until the vagina's death, ..."

Attend to the subtleties ;-)

87.167.51.174 03:01, 18 January 2007 (UTC)Reply


you can clearly hear that till is singing "bis zum tod, der scheidet" which means "until the death that divorces" — Preceding unsigned comment added by 94.216.100.28 (talk) 18:01, 25 July 2012 (UTC)Reply

Sorry, but I don't think it's that clear to me. Besides, in the German booklet it only says WILLST DU BIS ZUM TOD DER SCHEIDE... Unfortunately it's written upper case, but without commas. So I think this is clearly a wordplay with the death of vagina and the subjunctive of the verb scheiden. I would translate it as "...the death, that would divorce". --92.231.42.231 (talk) 13:33, 1 August 2012 (UTC)Reply

Translation/interpretation edit

Latest comment: 11 years ago3 comments3 people in discussion

The whole interpretation section is uncalled for, it rambles on way too much. I understand whoever wrote this was trying to make things clear, but the whole 'hate' interpretation is not correct. It is simply us Brits (Americans) hearing the German incorrectly, saying the 'hast' means hate is like saying the mich means milk. I don't think i am the correct person to try and fix this, but either is has to be re-written or removed. RobertsZ 17:17, 29 April 2007 (UTC)Reply

You are mistaken; hasst (hate) and hast (have) are pronounced exactly the same, and the ambiguity is clearly intentional. Learn some German... DES (talk) 14:40, 16 December 2007 (UTC)Reply
Yes, he's right (but! They sing in a local dialect (du haust), where the two may be more clearly differentiated!). The article uses an almost Anglo-Saxon style of English, which has the advantage of being closer to the German. However, the archaic effect of the translations is absent in the original, which is perfectly normal modern German.


i dont think that they sing in a local dialect, even a german like me cant hear a difference between "du hast" and "du hasst" (" you have/you hate") — Preceding unsigned comment added by 94.216.98.131 (talk) 18:14, 26 July 2012 (UTC)Reply

Title capitalization edit

Latest comment: 16 years ago5 comments3 people in discussion

I notice a slow-paced move war going on, here. For the record, German song titles follow a sentence-like capitalization scheme. If we plan on preserving that, then "Du hast" is the correct title of the page. If that's not our aim, do as you like. – Luna Santin (talk) 10:26, 30 April 2007 (UTC)Reply

I didn't actually know that there was a move-war going on, I just came across the article and felt it should be moved. If you feel it should indeed by a lower-case "Hast" then go ahead and move it back. ≈ The Haunted Angel 10:28, 30 April 2007 (UTC)Reply
I personally would probably prefer the lowercase, but somehow or other this doesn't seem to have been discussed, before. "Move-war" is probably an overstatement -- hasn't been moved in about two weeks, and I rather suspect everyone is doing this with the best of intentions. ;) If this gets someone else's attention (especially if they're thinking about moving it one way or the other) then I think the thread is worth having on here. – Luna Santin (talk) 10:33, 30 April 2007 (UTC)Reply
As the title of a German work, it follows Chinese capitalization rules. German composition titles are capitalized in the same way as everything else in German: The first word is capitalized, and are most nouns, but everything else is lowercase. There is no German equivalent to the English title case. ProhibitOnions (T) 15:25, 1 May 2007 (UTC)Reply
Alright then, fixed. ≈ The Haunted Angel 16:27, 1 May 2007 (UTC)Reply

Trivia edit

Latest comment: 16 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion

I have cleaned up the trivia section a little bit, and added a flag in accordance with the Wikipedia guidelines. However, I have not removed the section. Is there anyone who can confirm whether or not "Revenge TV" should point to the page Sharpe's_Revenge_(TV_programme)? Benwedge 20:56, 5 November 2007 (UTC)Reply

Hate or Have edit

Latest comment: 12 years ago3 comments3 people in discussion

To 81.179.225.11:

I removed the following text you added to this article.

The Hast bit of Du Hast is correct and does actually translate properly to hate. It is dependant on a rule called the dative case. With a Du word the word ending is a t. Hate in german in the infinative form is hass. When it is placed with Du it becomes Hast. Have in the infinative is haben. With du with it, it becomes hast. Du Hast= you hate but also = you have. This all depends on the context

Here's why:

Hass is the noun version of the word hate. Hassen (to hate) is the infinitive of the verb version. Hast is not a form of hassen. Hast is a form of the verb haben (to have), as you said.

Hast = Have

Hasst = Hate

the interpretation on this is incorrect, Rammstein made an english version of this song and the lyrics the own band uses is Du Hast = You Hate / not you have. That's from the band themselves. someone should edit to reflect that

Please see the previous discussions as well as the article itself - 'hast' means 'have' - the English version is just that: a version, not a translation. ≈ The Haunted Angel 19:23, 5 November 2008 (UTC)Reply
That's *SO* ridiculous. You clearly don't know German. Hast mean have AND hate, and the CONTEXT in this case is HATE. It's either a correct translation or nothing. 'Version'??? Get out. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 216.235.10.210 (talk) 13:53, 21 July 2010 (UTC)Reply
Haha, I think YOU don't know german, if I was you, I'd consultate leodict or something like that instead of making ridiculous statemants ;) 85.2.130.243 (talk) 11:54, 8 August 2011 (UTC)Reply

Hell... edit

Latest comment: 15 years ago2 comments1 person in discussion

Oh dear, what happened to this article? "until death splits us"?! In the middle, like amoeba? In the paragraph "Lyrics" it is translated more accurately as "death separates you" - although it would be more appropriate to substitute for the wedding formula usually used in English... that would be "until death do us part", iIuc?

And what is this vagina crap? This is the usual wedding formula used in German - and for once the text is not ambiguous, just because this is such a well-know formula... not only is this weird vagina interpretation violating WP:OR, it is also most probably incorrect. The "Lyrics" part is pretty good, but the much longer "Interpretation" part is useless - I tried to edit it, but am giving up and am removing it... e.g. "The wedding vow is sung word-by-word many times, each line with subtle ironic meanings:" - followed by the 1st lines of "du has(s)t", which do *NOT* contain the wedding vow, which only comes later in the song... I also wouldn't say it's a pun - it's just ambiguous... The fun about this song is, that the apparent meaning of the words changes every time they are repeated and added to - but this is not a pun in the classic sense, I'd say... It is also NOT ironic - irony normally means you mean the opposite what you say, but this is obvious to the listener/reader ("NICE weather outside" at 0°F and snow/wind/small animals falling from the sky) - this is not what we have here. I did retain the translation, though - re-adding the missing "hate" translations. Cheers, Iridos (talk) 07:40, 27 December 2008 (UTC)Reply

doh... they do indeed sing something like "zum tod der scheide" once... never noticed. Still think it's over-interpreting, though... I'll re-think about it :) Iridos (talk) 07:58, 27 December 2008 (UTC)Reply

Guitar Hero 5 edit

Latest comment: 14 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion

Should it be mentioned that this is in the newly released Guitar Hero 5? —Preceding unsigned comment added by 67.165.83.246 (talk) 21:51, 12 September 2009 (UTC) 7Reply

Original Research in Lead? edit

Latest comment: 14 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion

I tagged some possibly true, but unsourced, material in the lead, particularly the part comparing this song to Just One Fix. The riffs don't sound that similar apart from the large amount of palm muting, so I'm inclined to think this is original research. But if the band or a music critic noted the similarity at some point, then by all means cite it and keep it in. The same goes for the band citing Ministry as an influence. While it's probably true given the type of music they play, if they said it, we should be able to cite it. -204.12.173.240 (talk) 05:20, 11 March 2010 (UTC)Reply

Tense translation of "Du hast mich gefragt und ich hab' nichts gesagt" edit

Latest comment: 11 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion

In the article, the following is written:


The refrain "Willst du bis der Tod euch scheidet, treu ihr sein für alle Tage?" translates to "Do you[singular] want, until death separates you[plural], to be faithful to her for all time?" Instead of answering with "ja" (yes), the singer says "nein" (no), finally breaking his silence earlier in the song: "Du hast mich gefragt, und ich hab' nichts gesagt." This is in the present perfect and translates to "You have asked me, and I have said nothing," but is usually translated in the past tense to, "You asked me, and I said nothing."


The way I see it, this is a pretty irrelevant statement, seeing as spoken German rarely ever uses the preterite past tense, which in this case would be "Du fragtest mich, und ich sagte nichts." (Which, to me, sounds somewhat bookish.) Spoken German almost always uses the helping verb + participle (present perfect) form of past tense (Ich bin dorthin gegangen, das hab ich niemals gesehen, etwas is halt schiefgelaufen.), which usually carries over to songs. In song lyrics, the "present perfect" is also much more common, the preterite alternative being used much more rarely. In addition to all this, there is no difference between the statements "Ich bin dorthin gegangen", which utilizes present perfect, and "Ich ging dorthin", which utilizes preterite. (At least, not to me or any other native German speaker whom I know.). Should this be deleted or should clarification be added to why it's translated thus? Or does it not particularly matter? Vanthaera (talk) 03:01, 12 July 2012 (UTC)Reply

Video edit

Latest comment: 9 years ago1 comment1 person in discussion

Does anyone have any idea what's going on in the video?89.168.251.31 (talk) 21:33, 29 May 2014 (UTC)Reply

Add topic
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Du_hast&oldid=1207043196"