Talk:Conservation of South Asian household shrines

Latest comment: 5 years ago by Nick Moyes in topic Article concerns

Article concerns edit

The following feedback was given to the creator if this page as part of New Page Review:

As a Leicester University Museums Studies graduate myself, I can really relate to this well-written essay on conservation practice. However, as a Wikipedia editor I have a concern that you have somewhat missed the mark for an encyclopaedia entry. It reads too much like a chapter from a Handbook of Curatorship, and needs to be less generic. Please shorten the sections on pests, RH, light etc, instead perhaps bullet pointing them, with see also links o relevant pages. Avoid giving lengthy practical advice- see WP:NOTMANUAL, or we could have hundreds of ethnography-related conservation articles repeating the same basic information, and that's not ok.
Nick Moyes (talk) 14:07, 17 June 2018 (UTC)Reply