Talk:Chemistry/GA1

Latest comment: 15 years ago by Gary King in topic GA Review

GA Review edit

Hi, unfortunately this article fails to meet the Good Article criteria. Issues include:

  • Inline citations go after punctuation marks, per WP:FN.
  • Remove obvious self-referencing phrasing, such as "system (see subdisciplines)." – when this article is printed out on paper, this information will not be useful.
  • Far too much information goes unreferenced, especially the "Basic concepts", which takes up about half of the article.

Feel free to resubmit this article for a renomination after it has improved.

Gary King (talk) 22:26, 30 June 2008 (UTC)Reply