Talk:Céline Bara

Latest comment: 6 years ago by Jean-Jacques Georges in topic Promotional page

Promotional page edit

As I have just rewritten the French entry and would like to point the issues about this article which is rather promotional in tone. Céline Bara has never been a major player in France's (modest) porn industry and probably wouldn't meet WP:PORNBIO with her career alone. However, she does - barely - meet WP:GNG for two reasons : first, the fact that she and her husband assaulted a colleague with a gun in 2001, second and most importantly because she ran for parliament in 2012, which caused a short-lived buzz around her in the French media. Apart from that, she has no major claims to notability - her porn career has been marginal at best since the 2001 assault case, as she has been doing mostly amateur "non-profit" porn - since her "atheistic" advocacy has never attracted much attention outside her 2012 election campaign. This page, however short, gives the impression that she is a notable porn star/ militant atheist in France, which is definitely not the case. She is indeed a curious figure, but a marginal one at best. There seems to have been some sort of cross-wiki effort to promote her (and, incidentally, her husband) and it may be useful to rewrite the page to make it look more neutral and realistic. Jean-Jacques Georges (talk) 08:02, 3 August 2017 (UTC)Reply

I just did my best to neutralize the page and add reliable sources. If I made grammatical mistakes, feel free to correct me. Jean-Jacques Georges (talk) 14:54, 4 August 2017 (UTC)Reply