Talk:1947 Croydon Dakota accident

Latest comment: 11 years ago by Petebutt in topic A Rose by any other name

A Rose by any other name edit

I have modified this

Douglas C-47A Skytrain (Dakota) {{#tag:ref|Although officially Dakota relates to aircraft flown by British commonwealth forces it was also the common name for any of the Douglas C-47/DC-3 family in use in the United Kingdom and the British Commonwealth. The aircraft in the accident was a former United States Air Force C-47A Skytrain but was referred to in contemporary sources as a Dakota.|group=N}}

Why compound the error by using the US military designation.

  1. The aircraft WAS a Douglas C-47A Skytrain
  2. Dakota was not used with the US military designation

So the text can read

Douglas C-47A Skytrain (Dakota) {{#tag:ref|Although officially Dakota relates to aircraft flown by British commonwealth forces it was also the common name for any of the Douglas C-47/DC-3 family in use in the United Kingdom and the British Commonwealth. The aircraft in the accident was a former United States Air Force C-47A Skytrain but was referred to in contemporary sources as a Dakota.|group=N}}

or

Douglas Dakota (C-47A Skytrain) {{#tag:ref|Although officially Dakota relates to aircraft flown by British commonwealth forces it was also the common name for any of the Douglas C-47/DC-3 family in use in the United Kingdom and the British Commonwealth. The aircraft in the accident was a former United States Air Force C-47A Skytrain but was referred to in contemporary sources as a Dakota.|group=N}}

Take your pick!!Petebutt (talk) 06:32, 24 May 2012 (UTC)Reply