Key
- AP = Associated Press[1]
- UP = United Press: "selected for the United Press ... by sports editors and writers from all over the country"[2]
- FWAA = Football Writers Association of America[3]
- COL = Collier's Weekly: "chosen by Grantland Rice and 10 veteran football writers from all sections of the country"[4]
- CP = Central Press Association: "Mighty Army, Navy, and Ohio State dominated the 1944 Central Press Captains' All-American team, picked for the 14th straight season with the help of the nation's football captains. As in the past two years, service players are not included in the selections."[5][6]
- INS = International News Service[7]
- NEA = Newspaper Editors Association: "It still is the duty of every football writer, it seems, to pick an All-America team. Selecting one has become a futility that even a World War can't stop. So without further ado and with no apologies, here we go again."[8]
- LOOK = Look Magazine, selected by NBC sports reporter and commentator Bill Stern[9]
- WC = Walter Camp Football Foundation[10]
Bold = Consensus All-American[11]
- 1 - First Team Selection
- 2 - Second Team Selection
- 3 - Third Team Selection
Ends
- Phil Tinsley, Georgia Tech (AP-1; UP-2; FWAA-2; COL; INS-1; NEA; CP-1; LOOK; WC)
- Paul Walker, Yale (UP-2; FWAA-1; COL; INS-2; NEA; CP-1; LOOK)
- Jack Dugger, Ohio State (AP-3; UP-1; FWAA-1; INS-1; CP-2; WC)
- Hub Bechtol, Texas (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-1)
- Henry Walker, Virginia (AP-2)
- Leon Bramlett, Navy(AP-2)
- Barney Poole, Army (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-3; UP-1; INS-2; CP-2)
- Frank Bauman, Purdue (UP-3; FWAA-2)
- H. Martin, Navy (UP-3)
- Arthur Renner, Michigan (UP-4)
Tackles
- Don Whitmire, Navy (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-1; UP-1; FWAA-1; COL; INS-1; NEA; CP-1; LOOK; WC)
- John Ferraro, Southern California (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-1; UP-2; FWAA-1; COL; INS-1; NEA [g]; CP-1; WC)
- George Savitsky, Penn (College Football Hall of Fame) (UP-3; NEA)
- Bill Willis, Ohio State (College and Pro Football Hall of Fame) (AP-2; UP-1; FWAA-2; INS-2; LOOK)
- Milan Lazetich, Michigan (AP-2; UP-3; FWAA-2; INS-2; CP-2)
- Monte Moncrief, Texas A&M (AP-3)
- Robert McClure, Nevada (AP-3; UP-4)
- DeWitt "Tex" Coulter, Army (UP-2)
- George Owen, Wake Forest (UP-4)
- George Sullivan, Notre Dame (UP-4; CP-2)
Guards
- Bill Hackett, Ohio State (AP-1; UP-2; FWAA-1; COL; INS-2; CP-1; WC)
- Ben Chase, Navy (UP-1; FWAA-2; INS-1; CP-1; WC)
- Hamilton Nichols, Rice (AP-1)
- Joseph Stanowicz, Army (UP-1; FWAA-1; INS-1; CP-2)
- Clyde Flowers, Texas Christian (NEA)
- John Green, Army (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-2; COL; INS-2)
- William Hachten, California (AP-2; UP-4; LOOK)
- Ralph Serpico, Illinois (AP-3; UP-3; FWAA-2)
- Robert Dobelstein, Tennessee (AP-3)
- Pat Filley, Notre Dame (UP-2)
- Ellis Jones, Tulsa (UP-3; CP-2; LOOK)
- Ernie Knotts, Duke (UP-4)
Centers
- John Tavener, Indiana (College Football Hall of Fame) (UP-1; FWAA-1; INS-1; CP-1; LOOK)
- Caleb Warrington, Auburn (AP-1; UP-3; FWAA-2; COL; INS-2; NEA; WC)
- Felto Prewitt, Tulsa (AP-2)
- Robert St. Onge, Army (AP-3)
- John T. Martin, Navy (UP-2)
- Gordon Appleby, Ohio State (UP-4)
- Gordon Berlin, Washington (CP-2)
Quarterbacks
- Les Horvath, Ohio State (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-1; UP-1; FWAA-1; COL [fb]; INS-1; NEA; CP-1; LOOK; WC)
- Buddy Young, Illinois (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-2; UP-2; INS-2; CP-2; LOOK)
- Doug Kenna, Army (College Football Hall of Fame) (UP-3; COL; CP-2)
- Jim Hardy, Southern California (UP-4; FWAA-2)
- Frank Broyles, Georgia Tech (FWAA-2)
Halfbacks
- Glenn Davis, Army (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-1; UP-1; FWAA-1; INS-1; NEA; CP-1; WC)
- Bob Jenkins, Navy (AP-2; UP-1; FWAA-2; COL; INS-2; NEA; WC)
- Bob "Blonde Bomber" Fenimore, Oklahoma A&M (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-1; UP-3; FWAA-1; COL; INS-2; NEA; CP-2)
- Earl "Jug" Girard, Wisconsin (LOOK)
- Robert Kelly, Notre Dame (AP-3; UP-2; INS-2)
- Tom "Shorty" McWilliams, Mississippi State (AP-2; UP-2)
- Thomas Davis, Duke (AP-3; UP-4; CP-2)
- Harold Hamburg, Navy (AP-3; UP-3)
- Clyde "Smackover" Scott, Navy (College Football Hall of Fame) (UP-4)
Fullbacks
- Doc Blanchard, Army (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-1; UP-1; FWAA-1; INS-1; CP-1; LOOK; WC)
- Babe Dimancheff, Purdue (AP-2; UP-2; FWAA-2; INS-1; CP-1)
- Bob Wiese, Michigan/Navy (UP-3)
- Gordon Gray, Southern California (AP-3; UP-4)