Wikipedia talk:Requested articles/Archive 3

Active discussions


In the interest of saving space on this metapage, I think descriptions of requested articles should be held to a minimum. I'd like to remove them all together, actually. What are your thoughts? Kingturtle 20:10, 17 Jan 2004 (UTC)

Short descriptions (2-3 words) are fine by me. Longer ones need to go (be shortened or dumped). →Raul654 22:08, Jan 18, 2004 (UTC)

I've had it - some of these descriptions are long enough to be stubs. I am going to automatically stub articles with extra-long descripts and move them to cleanup and/or need pages. Davodd 23:05, Feb 23, 2004 (UTC)


I don't know if anyone here has seen it, but I keep a list of all the articles I've ever requested (by date) over at User:Raul654/Requests. Since January 12, I've requested 39 articles. Exactly two were written. One was a blatant copyright violation and promptly removed. Does this page really have such slow turnover? →Raul654 19:55, Feb 13, 2004 (UTC)

Yup, always been that way. Shouldn't be too surprising; writers are more likely to follow their own interests than somebody else's. When it comes to disentangling navy ships, I seem to have all kinds of energy, but Arabic poetry? - not so much, :-) although I'll probably read the article when it exists. Stan 21:57, 13 Feb 2004 (UTC)

Removed Bjarmia from WP:RC to add Moral hierarchy - 戴&#30505sv 17:42, 14 Feb 2004 (UTC)

Could someone explain why this page has every topic listed twice? Acegikmo1 01:29, Feb 25, 2004 (UTC)

Fixed. 33° 02:02, 25 Feb 2004 (UTC)

Hygine catagory

I think this is needed, anyone agree? -Linuxx

Yes, because without it the world would not be a very good place to live in. Wiki_sosa

Pages with many unfinished links

I'd like to add a category or heading or page for existing pages that contain many "requested" links. For example someone interested in ladybirds could add just "ladybirds". The current (unsatisfactory) way would be to add to the biology section: Seven-spotted lady beetle, Two-spotted lady beetle, Convergent lady beetle, Spotted lady beetle, Twice-stabbed lady beetle, Mexican bean beetle, etc, etc. that's kinda long and much more annoying than just ladybird.

I'd create a wikipedia:List of articles with many unfinished links: page or heading myself but i dont know what to call it or where to put it. Pengo 11:25, 3 Mar 2004 (UTC)

This is now available at Wikipedia:WikiProject Red Link Recovery/Most red links. -- Beland 9 July 2005 01:43 (UTC)

Question about listing REDIRs on Requested articles page

Should redirects be listed here since they are live links, or should they be moved to cleanup? It seems like many of them become disambig pages, anyway. Davodd 00:11, Mar 6, 2004 (UTC)


Acegikmo1 23:41, 10 Jul 2004 (UTC)

Oh! I need someone to recreate the PictoChat article. HELP ME! <-( --Tornado Kid 20:20, 1 Sep 2004 (UTC) (a.k.a. WikiPediaAid)

Pins are nice @ Disney Resorts!

WikiPediaAid is wanting an article on Official Disney Pin Trading now!

I'm not sure under which category to request an article

I would like to request an article about Jasper Holmes but can't decide which heading to put him under on the request page. Just before the WW11 Battle of Midway, the US had no cryptographic way of determining Japan's code name for Midway. They had cracked Japan's JN-25 code and knew the target was AF, but didn't know where AF was located. Holmes, a young US naval officer, very cunningly tricked the Japanese into revealing that AF was Midway. Anyone got a suggestion on what category to use? (When I say category I don't mean category. Moriori 22:09, Sep 13, 2004 (UTC)

When did World War 11 occur? ;-) func(talk) 16:54, 15 Sep 2004 (UTC)
History I guess...but you seem to know enough about him to write an article yourself (or at least a stub). Adam Bishop 00:11, 14 Sep 2004 (UTC)
I guess you're right. Stub it is. Cheers. Moriori 00:18, Sep 14, 2004 (UTC)
This information, including the offcer's name, is already at Battle of Midway#US Intelligence, I suppose you are aware of that. Andrewa 12:19, 14 Sep 2004 (UTC)
Of course. But if any codebreaker deserves his own page, it is Holmes. His lateral thinking did much to win the naval war in the Pacific. I'm looking for material. E-mailed the US Navy yesterday, but no reply yet. Cheers. Moriori 20:27, Sep 14, 2004 (UTC)


I'd like to put up a request for fylocode, the proposed alternative for Linnaeus' system of classifying living organisms. I suppose it should be requested under biology or something similar, but I can't find it. Where would be the best place? D.D. 00:13, 24 Oct 2004 (UTC)

We already have an article on it, except that we call it phylocode in English. --Heron 12:33, 20 Nov 2004 (UTC)

Democracy and liberalism

Why is democracy not liberalism?

Request for article(s)

on British India administration & provincial organisation. Lucio Mas 06:34, 28 Nov 2004 (UTC)


Does anyone know what the total estimated number of Jews is????

You'd have been better off asking in Wikipedia:Reference Desk, but Whitaker's 2002 edition gives a figure of "over 12.5 million Jews world-wide; in Great Britain and Ireland there are an estimated 285,000 adherents and about 365 synagogues". This figure appears to be a religious definition (rather than a harder-to-define ethnic one), but doesn't go into detail. Shimgray 14:21, 10 Dec 2004 (UTC)


Any clues?--Jirate 03:05, Dec 11 2004 (UTC)

How are the few requests in the open tasks template determined?

I'm wondering what (or who) determines the couple of requested articles that appear in the "Community portal" page. I sometimes work pick a few "red links" and create new articles. I noticed three of the requests that have shown up recently are small places in Vermont which is where I used to live. I've already done an article for "Cabot Creamery", and I'm kind of wondering if Barre Granite is enough of a topic to need an article, and Killington Peak is next. Morris 04:46, Dec 31, 2004 (UTC)

It's totally based on whatever editor happens to notice that Template:Opentasks needs updating, and goes and grabs some unwritten articles from here. You'r welcome to do it yourself. Just add Template:Opentask to your watchlist, and update it when it needs it. JesseW 01:06, 3 Jan 2005 (UTC)
<Jun-Dai 05:48, 4 Jan 2005 (UTC)>Are we expected to pick them more or less at random, or is it acceptable and even welcomed that someone enter an item that they really want to see written?</Jun-Dai>

I just prioritized the queue there according to Wikipedia:Most wanted articles and Wikipedia:Articles requested for more than two years. Hopefully most people who update the page will simply use those lists, since that will probably benefit the site most. If you want to post a pet project, I don't think anyone will revert you, at least not right away. Certainly that's been common practice up till now, and is still common practice for most of the lines there. (Though I've been more systematic, rotating through the alphabet to avoid letting any single request linger too long.) -- Beland 9 July 2005 02:16 (UTC)

Return to the project page "Requested articles/Archive 3".