Wikipedia

Wikipedia:Good articles/GAN Backlog Drives/March 2014

< Wikipedia:Good articles‎ | GAN Backlog Drives
(Redirected from Wikipedia:WikiProject Good articles/GAN Backlog Drives/March 2014)
WikiProject Good Articles: Open Tasks
This project identifies, organizes and improves good articles on Wikipedia.
March 2014
GAN Backlog Drive
Wikipedia:Good articles
Participants: 7
(As of March 20)
Articles reviewed: 33
(As of March 20)
· · ·

The 2014 March GAN Backlog Drive is a month-long effort to reduce the backlog of Good Article nominations. Please make sure that you read the whole Good Article review process before starting to review an article, and that you are very familiar with the GA criteria and the WP:Manual of Style. It is strongly recommended reading the essays What the Good article criteria are not and Reviewing good articles. If you have questions, leave a message on the drive's talk page. The drive will begin on March 1, 2014 at 0:00:01 (UST) and will end on March 31, 2014 at 23:59:59 (UST).

The goal of this backlog drive is to bring the number of outstanding Good Article nominations down as a low as possible while maintaining quality over quantity reviews. All nominations listed at WP:GAN are eligible to be reviewed. Awards will be given out at the end of the drive (please read below for more info).



Basic Guidelines
  1. Log completed Good Article reviews here. If you complete a GAN for an article, don't forget to sign your name in the table. Quick-fails will not be counted.
  2. No rubber-stamping of GANs. Be thorough and complete in your GANs, and make sure all the i's are dotted and the t's crossed. Generally Good article nominations tend to result in even better improvements to articles and can go a long way especially when approaching Featured Article standing.
  3. Provide constructive criticism. If you see a problem or problems in a certain article you're reviewing, don't be afraid to point that out and indicate to the nominator what's wrong. Instead of merely pointing to the problems, guide the nominator to possible ways of fixing those problems. Similarly, if the article is not of Good Article quality yet, don't be afraid to fail, but make sure you provide guidance as to how to get the article up to GA quality.
  4. Stick with it. An article isn't improved if it remains on hold for months. Instead, make the smaller corrections, make sure the primary writer is actively editing, and make the pass/fail judgment if concerns are/are not addressed in a timely matter. Watch the talk page and look to see what's being done and if anyone has questions.
  5. Have fun. We're here to help bring these articles up to their fullest potential and hence improving the overall quality of the encyclopedia. If you do not enjoy doing that, then there is no motivation to improve these articles and the encyclopedia as a whole.
 Help Guides

Following is a list of all the guidelines needed/required to review Good Article nominees:

Tools

When reviewing, you can use the following recommended tools:

Awards

All participants will have the opportunity to receive up to 3 barnstars (one per each of the following):

  • Participating in the Backlog Drive (reviewing articles)
  • Help ensure quality is priority by being part of the Review Team
  • Make a pledge (see below)

The 3 participants who have the most points at the end of the drive will receive the Golden, Silver, or Bronze Wikipedia Puzzle Piece Trophy, respectively.

Awards will only be given out once all reviews have been reviewed by the Review Team.

NOTE: Users who are found to have 2 or more insufficient reviews will not receive any awards.

Totals

Unlike previous drives, a new point system will be introduced for this drive. In general, older nominations are worth more points than newer nominations (see table below).

Nomination Age Points
Over 4 months 10 points
Over 3 months 8 points
Over 2 months 6 points
Over 1 month 4 points
2 - 4 weeks 2 points
Under 2 weeks 1 point
Quickfails* 0 points

* No matter how old the nomination is, if you quickfail the article, it is worth 0 points.

Article reviews started before April 1, 2014 but completed before [or by] April 30, 2014 are eligible to be counted into the running total. Reviews started before March 1, 2014 do not count.

HOWEVER, an exception can be made to this rule. If the deadline (April 30, 2014) to complete any outstanding reviews is nearing and good progression is being made by the nominator on addressing any concerns brought up by the reviewer, please do not close the review as you will be awarded the points for the review based on if the review is deemed as a sufficient review at the time (even if it is not complete). If there is insufficient progress, points will not be awarded.

NOTE: Users who are found to have 2 or more insufficient reviews will not receive any awards.

The definition of an insufficient review for the purpose of this drive: An insufficient review is any completed review where there are still errors in the article that are not mentioned in the review that would cause the article to fail/require to be fixed by the nominator. Quickfails and reviews not completed before the deadline do not count as an "insufficient review".

Review Team

In order to ensure that quality is kept over quantity, all reviews from participants will need to be approved as a quality review before any awards are given out. For this to be done in a timely manner, we need as much help as we can.

If you would like to be part of the Review Team, please add your name below.

Also, please read the "For Review Team only" section under the "Directions" on the totals page.

Review Team Members

  1. Dom497
  2. Royroydeb
  3. The Rambling Man
  4. ThaddeusB
To update your totals or add your name to the list, click here.
Totals

J Milburn edit

  1. When Your Heart Stops Beating (10) Checked The Rambling Man (talk)
  2. A Very Gaga Holiday (1) Checked The Rambling Man (talk)
  3. Southern Cross (wordless novel) (1) Checked The Rambling Man (talk)

Points: 12

Barnstar Given: Yes

Royroydeb edit

  1. Ethel Sands (4) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  2. Volví a Nacer (10) Red XN Article was not properly reviewed The Rambling Man (talk)
  3. Poena cullei (10) Checked ThaddeusB (talk)
  4. Milan Baroš (1) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  5. Sri Aurobindo (1) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  6. Peter Ostrum (0) Red XN Not completed on time Dom497 (talk)
  7. Marie of Romania (0) Red XN Not completed on time Dom497 (talk)
  8. 2003–04 Arsenal F.C. season (0) Red XN Not completed on time Dom497 (talk)

Points: 26

Barnstar Given: Yes

Sturmvogel_66 edit

  1. Una-class submarine (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  2. P-9 Project (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  3. Bardas (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  4. Béla I of Hungary (6) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  5. Peter, King of Hungary (6) Checked The Rambling Man (talk)
  6. Italian battleship Impero (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  7. Garnet Malley (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  8. Project Alberta (2) Checked The Rambling Man (talk)
  9. The Life of Mary Baker G. Eddy and the History of Christian Science (6) Checked The Rambling Man (talk)


Points:25

Barnstar Given: Yes

ThaddeusB edit

  1. GISHWHES (8) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  2. Cryolophosaurus (6) Checked The Rambling Man (talk)

Points:14

Barnstar Given: Yes

The Rambling Man edit

  1. Joshua King (footballer) (10) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  2. Anky van Grunsven (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  3. Welcome to the Universe Tour (10) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  4. Munir Hussain (commentator) (4) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  5. Megan Rapinoe (10) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  6. Pleasure Beach Bridge (4) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  7. Songs of Experience (album) (4) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  8. T2 3-D: Battle Across Time (10) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  9. AJ Ahmed (10) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  10. Last Tango in Halifax (10) Checked ThaddeusB (talk)
  11. Katherine Clark (6) Checked ThaddeusB (talk)
  12. Wildlife (La Dispute album) (8) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  13. John Johnson (footballer) (2) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  14. Haseeb Ahsan (4) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  15. Congress Street Bridge (Connecticut) (4) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  16. Initiations (Star Trek: Voyager) (6) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  17. Imelda (film) (4) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  18. The Bells of Saint John (6) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  19. East Washington Avenue Bridge (4) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  20. Black Country Communion (8) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  21. Daybreaker (Architects album) (8) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  22. Astraea (album) (6) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  23. Edinburgh International Climbing Arena (4) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  24. Egypt at the 2012 Summer Olympics (8) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  25. Dust My Broom (6) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  26. Mulgrew Miller (8) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  27. Sally Kellerman (4) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  28. Antes de las Seis (4) Checked Dom497 (talk)
  29. Bobby Timmons (8) Checked Dom497 (talk)

Points: 181

Barnstar Given: Yes

Wilhelmina Will edit

  1. HMS Euryalus (1901) (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  2. HMS Good Hope (1901) (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  3. HMS Monmouth (1901) (1) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  4. Battle of Logorište (10) Checked RRD13 (talk)
  5. Wynton Kelly (6) Checked ThaddeusB (talk)

Points: 19

Barnstar Given: Yes

Newyorkadam edit

  1. Flotilla (video game) (1) Checked The Rambling Man (talk)

Points: 1

Barnstar Given: Yes
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Good_articles/GAN_Backlog_Drives/March_2014&oldid=1193459676"