Wikipedia : WikiProject Articles for creation/July 2021 Backlog Drive/Participants/AntanO
Super73 (135 days)
Fail . I have checked 75% of the references and found, so far, only TechCrunch as a useful source. All the others are product launch material, product launch marketing puffery reviews. The text is advertorial and I suspect UPE. While UPE does not disqualify acceptance it makes me look very much more closely at the welter of faux-references I see. I would have declined as failing WP:NCORP , and as an advert, referenced in WP:BOMBARD with a helping of WP:CITEKILL Fiddle Timtrent Faddle Talk to me [ reply ] Lean air (142 days)D (corp) Draft:Taituarā (135 days)
Pass fails sigcov. Good decline TheBirdsShedTears (talk ) 09:36, 2 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
List of Hindu comparative religionists (10 days)D (cv) Draft:One World Family Commune (66 days)
D (cv) Draft:Christ Communion
A International Meditation Centre (109 days)
D (cv) Draft:Linden House, London (107 days)
Pass good call on copyright violation. Theroadislong (talk ) 12:15, 16 July 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
Battle of Anderlecht (92 days)D (exists) Draft:The battle at Dysiaa (78 days)
A KH-178 105 mm Howitzer (24 days)
D (cv) Draft:MGS-25 Aleksandar (100 days):
Partial pass . CV found, yes, but it was sufficient to go for CSD or at least RevDel Fiddle Timtrent Faddle Talk to me [ reply ]
FV4202 (30 days)A M56A1 Coyote (65 days)
A KRI Tanjung Nusanive (973) (0 days)
Pass good clear simple pass. Fiddle Timtrent Faddle Talk to me [ reply ]
Wider Service Medal (110 days)D (cv) Draft:Torpedo (factory) (26 days)
A The Siege of Arkona (82 days)
D (cv) Draft:Legal Hundred (19 days)
D (exists) Draft:Mata Lakshmi Temple Lakhimpur Kheri (2 days)
A Edge of Hell (Kansas City) (61 days)
A Private art museum (45 days)
A Single Artist Museums (18 days)
A Effects of climate change on the water cycle (55 days)
A Deltaic Lobe (75 days)
A Space sustainability (118 days)
A Contay British Commonwealth War Graves Commission Cemetery (31 days)
A Biological wood oxidation (104 days)
A 2019 Judo Grand Slam Osaka (44 days)
A M2 Stinger (87 days)
D (bio) Draft:Todos Osmachka (1 day)
A Lyceum 1533 (LIT) (95 days)
A 2021 Women's Softball European Championship (18 days)
D (cv) List of Virgin Galactic launches (0 days)
A Lume-1 (18 days)
D (cv) List of Delta 4 launches (6 days)
D (cv) List of Atlas LV3B launches (9 days)
D (cv) Draft:KH-179 155mm towed howitzer (43 days)
A IBM WorkPad (18 days)
D (music) Draft:Agung Kembar (104 days)
Pass correct use of decline. TheBirdsShedTears (talk ) 09:36, 2 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
Draft:Antoons (1 day)A Young Lions Fiction Award (2 days)
A Historic Ely Elevator (53 days)
A Technion Faculty of Architecture (38 days)
A Operation Hera (50 days)
A BBI Judgement (64 days)
D (music) Draft:Afrie (90 days)
D (cv) Draft:Case of Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy (49 days)
D (not) Draft:List of diplomatic missions in Laayoune (75 days)
D (not) Draft:List of diplomatic missions in Dakhla (74 days)
A Adi Hutsa massacre (48 days)
D (bio) Draft:Surendra K.C. (0 days)
A 2022 Arizona Superintendent of Public Instruction election (65 days)
A Hale County High School (60 days)
A 2017 Payson flash floods (41 days)
Fail . This is an unfortunate accident, but I don't believe that a lawsuit years later is enough to show WP:PERSISTENCE . Clarityfiend (talk ) 11:08, 25 July 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
Cultural impact of Shakira (90 days)A Thoonakkadavu Dam (10 days)
A Zaoxi (39 days)
A Qiaodun (39 days)
A Pacific Park Villart (1 day)
A Syrian Public Security Police (88 days)
Pass sufficient to pass notability. Good accept. TheBirdsShedTears (talk ) 09:47, 2 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
International Flight Training School (54 days)A Religious trauma syndrome (36 days)
R (n) User:Righteous777/sandbox (0 days)
D (bio) User:Rohankumar222/sandbox (0 days)
A American College of Tax Counsel (65 days)
A List of Delta 4 launches (7 days)
A List of Atlas LV3B launches (10 days)
A List of Virgin Galactic launches (1 day)
A Californium(III) bromide (0 days)
A 2011 North Miami mayoral election (77 days)
A Shoalhaven Regional Gallery (26 days)
A Van Norman Dams (0 days)
A Replay Protected Memory Block (91 days)
D (v) Draft:644th Tank Destroyer Battalion (48 days)
A In-Car Payment System (5 days)
A TAI T929 ATAK 2 (2 days)
A International Federation of Pickleball (0 days)
D (music) Draft:International Staff Songsters of the Salvation Army (88 days)
D (cv) Draft:ZACHOR Holocaust Remembrance Foundation (20 days)
D (bio) Draft:Sripad Bhakti Madhava Puri Maharaja (113 days)
R (n) Draft:Anmol Bist
D (nn, not) User:Rajkumarseo85/sandbox/Vijay Raja Homes (0 days)
Pass Appears a piece of ad. Good decline with WP:NOT TheBirdsShedTears (talk ) 09:45, 2 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
Draft:Biloxi Pro Hockey (0 days)
Pass Full agree. TheBirdsShedTears (talk ) 09:45, 2 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ] Revolt of Hasan Khan Salar (0 days)
Pass : good accept. — Bilorv (talk [ reply ] Super-pressure Balloon-borne Imaging Telescope (SuperBIT) (0 days)D (not) Draft:Kyokushin Karate Zambia (3 days)
D (not) Draft:Delhi Football Club (4 days)
D (not) Draft:Mannfiltred
D (exists) Draft:List of awards and nominations received by Thuppakki (0 days)
D (exists) Draft:List of accolades received by The Fault in Our Stars (0 days)
Fail : doesn't seem like a good decline reason as splits don't always need discussion and the IP couldn't just create the article directly, so why not use AFC for an uncontroversial split? The content wasn't verbatim from The Fault in Our Stars (film) , but had substantial original material. I would have added a {{Copied }} template on the draft talk page per Wikipedia:Copying within Wikipedia (and have done so now), but at least noting the article it was copied from in a comment probably satisfies the absolute minimum. I would have accepted; a decline could possibly be reasonable if the rationale was strong. — Bilorv (talk [ reply ]
Draft:Bhimarjun Acharya (0 days)R (n) Draft:پەیجی زانستی کۆمپیوتەر (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Puntsagiin Tsagaan (0 days)
D (nn, npov) Draft:Independent Party (Florida) (53 days)
Comment : I wouldn't have used npov here. Haven't properly evaluated whether nn is appropriate. — Bilorv (talk [ reply ]
82nd Motorized Infantry Brigade (People's Republic of China) (0 days)A 2016 in South Korean television (0 days)
A Battle near the Irghiz River (0 days)
A 202nd Division (People's Republic of China) (0 days)
A 204th Division (People's Republic of China) (0 days)
A 92nd Motorized Infantry Brigade (People's Republic of China) (0 days)
A 182nd Division (People's Republic of China) (0 days)
A Inaji (0 days)
D (not, nn) Draft:Tiki Man (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Trap Baby (0 days)
A Kingdom of Dust: Beheading of Adam Smith (0 days)
A Badhangarhi temple (0 days)
A 1985 Bangladesh cyclone (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Franki Love (0 days)
D (not) Draft:The Teachings of Bhagavad Gita: Timeless Wisdom for the Modern Age (0 days)
D (v) Draft:1947 Sirhind Train Massacre (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Ignjatije Bjelić (0 days)
D (music) Draft:Danushka Kumarathunga (10 days)
A Drugmulla (11 days)
D (dup) Draft:Jarjangi 2 (12 days)
D (music) Draft:Louie $ativa (14 days)
Pass no sources Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
Draft:State Financial Monitoring Service of Ukraine (15 days)
Pass potentially notable, but article is in very poor shape. some links at bottom but not clear that they support much, if any of the content in the article. Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ] Paul Ulibarri (16 days)A Line 16 (Guangzhou Metro) (52 days)
D (bio) Draft:Raju Kendre (0 days)
Pass I would have failed as npov/ad myself without bothering to assess the sources, but I agree with the outcome. Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
Draft:Athletics Unlimited Softball (0 days)
Pass Not ideal to have the freeform text for the decline rather than using the standard notability message, but still the right outcome. Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ] Draft:1947 Sirhind Train Massacre (0 days)D (bio) Draft:Oyinkansola Alabi (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Carter Pilcher (0 days)
Pass Not notable. Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
Draft:How do? (0 days)
Pass Weird OR about a phrase. Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ] Draft:Fabio Kanczuk (0 days)
Pass h-index ~15, not notable per NPROF, sources provided don't meet GNG. Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ] Draft:1947 Sirhind Train Massacre (0 days)D (bio) Draft:Firoz Ladak (0 days)
Pass total vanity article. Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
Draft:Tarun Upaday (0 days)
Pass I would have declined as nbio (doesnt really read like an ad) but I agree on the outcome. Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ] Draft:Jose Hurtado (0 days)
Pass not notable Calliopejen1 (talk ) 06:37, 11 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ] Draft:Ljubomir Zuković (0 days)R (e) Draft:1947 Sirhind Train Massacre (0 days)
D (blank) Draft:Institute of Information Management, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan
Pass Only title and an empty ref section. Good decline TheBirdsShedTears (talk ) 09:49, 2 August 2021 (UTC)[ reply ]
D (adv) Draft:Bella Vita Organic (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Sara Parker Pauley (1 day)
D (v) Draft:Mithila University (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Malvi Malhotra (0 days)
D (corp) Draft:Kramski Group (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Sarjun KM (0 days)
D (blank) Draft:Smiley (musician) (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Joilson Junior de Melo (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Jeremy Schwartz (0 days)
D (adv) Draft:Continuous Innovation Framework (0 days)
D (essay) Draft:Harun M Hassan (0 days)
R (n) Draft:Smiley (musician) (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Laurie Marsden (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Srha Asghar (0 days)
D (not) Draft:Plexiglas (company) (0 days)
D (essay) Draft:David Michery (0 days)
D (adv) Draft:Departmental Council of Lot (0 days)
D (not) Draft:Bheemili-Bhogapuram coastal highway (0 days)
R (n) Draft:Sandeep Burdak (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Nandita Bakhshi (0 days)
D (adv) Draft:Tetrate (0 days)
D (blank) User:Bandit1155/sandbox (0 days)
D (bio) Rony (rapper) (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Jesus Maria Escobar (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Rob Jamieson (0 days)
D (essay) Draft:Quarantined Student-Youth Network (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Pantural (0 days)
R (n) Draft:William B. Kinkead (15 days)
D (music) Draft:Nadodi Mannan (soundtrack) (13 days)
D (bio) Draft:Miša Dimitrijević (13 days)
D (adv) Draft:One Radio Manila (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Robert John Jamieson (0 days)
R (n) User:PixelStudiosChennai/sandbox (0 days)
D (v) Draft:Mason McTavish (0 days)
D (music) Draft:Kay Nine Tha Boss (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Will Wight (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Varun Joshi (0 days)
D (not) Draft:Jammu Kashmir Professional football League (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Ferhat Şaşkın (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Tony Miller (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Toqeer Gilani (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Ken Ehrlich (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Art Resnick (0 days)
R (n) Draft:The Digi Jugad (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Sybil Evans (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Jyothi Ganesh (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Pravachan Traize
D (bio) Draft:Ken Ehrlich (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Mehedi Hasan Ariyan (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Priyanka Mondal (0 days)
D (v) Draft:Hazrat Syed Shah Jalaluddin Hussaini (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Ayan Nayak (0 days)
D (adv) Draft:Alkhabar-TV Syria (0 days)
D (adv) Draft:Enablers Pakistan (58 days)
D (v) Draft:W A Sunshine (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Satguru Mata Sudiksha (67 days)
D (not) Draft:Secklow Sounds (59 days)
D (v) Draft:Basuki Bihari North (0 days)
D (adv) Draft:Fetish (band) (87 days)
A 2021–2022 Rugby Europe Super Cup (0 days)
D (not) Draft:Heartbreaker (Michael Jackson song) (0 days)
R (n) Draft:Technologyinsight.tech (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Mathew Guest (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Gitali Devi (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:George Heinsohn (0 days)
D (bio) Saïd Djabelkhir (0 days)
D (not) 1979–80 Duquesne Dukes men's basketball team (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Sant Niranjan Dass (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:ESI Phutura (0 days)
A Hachikazuki (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Wonpil (0 days)
D (v) Draft:Energy Minerals (253 days)
D (bio) Draft:Anushka Gunasinghe (0 days)
A Database Center for North Korean Human Rights (13 days)
D (not) Draft:Jellyfish Pictures (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Nandlal Jaswantlal (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Tamara Alpeeva (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Hans Georg Näder (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:"Katy K" Kattelman (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Daler Sharipov (journalist) (0 days)
D (bio) Draft:Mike Dunbar (political activist) (0 days)
