User:Gerda Arendt/ACE 2021

This is NOT a voters' guide, just my private quick evaluation, looking at the candidates' answers to my one and only question, and how I saw them previously (Precious, when, for what).

Question from Gerda Arendt

For new candidates: Would you have listened to SarahSV (aka SlimVirgin) in this case?

For a current arb: You accepted the RexxS case. I would have listened to SarahSV (aka SlimVirgin). In a similar situation, would you perhaps change your mind?

Related discussions: User talk:Hammersoft#Precious anniversary and follow-ups on the talk. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 13:36, 15 November 2021 (UTC)

2022 update: Hammersoft has the archive of 2021 here. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 07:04, 9 February 2022 (UTC)

Answers

Candidate	nom day	answer day	answers	Precious no.	Precious reason	experience	sup	elected
Worm That Turned	8 Nov		no question	203	support	arb	Y	Y
Beeblebrox	12 Nov	15 Nov	"Admin conduct cases are as unpleasant as they are necessary."	553	"move along"	arb		Y
Banedon	13 Nov	16 Nov	"No." explained
Wugapodes	15 Nov	16 Nov	"the kind of empathetic considerations that Sarah wanted to be considered"	1513	dialogues, linguistic and legal	admin	Y	Y
Donald Albury	15 Nov	16 Nov	"I would be ready to listen to and consider any advice she might offer me."	2638	places in Florida	admin	Y	Y
Opabinia regalis	16 Nov		no question	1164	biochemistry	former arb	Y	Y
Cabayi	16 Nov	16 Nov	"The case needed to be accepted."			admin		Y
Guerillero	16 Nov		"When RexxS stopped editing 2 days later and it looked like he de facto retired, I would have moved to suspend the case. Charging on with the case did nobody any good."	751	Toil, tools, tradition and trust	admin	Y
Izno	16 Nov	17 Nov	"I think I would have !voted to accept the case"	1477	gnome	admin		Y
Thryduulf	16 Nov	16 Nov	"at the time I encouraged the committee to accept the case"	576	thinking of options	former arb
Enterprisey	16 Nov	18 Nov	"Given the involved line of inquiry and RexxS's final response to Newyorkbrad, I don't think I would have agreed with SV." + reasoning			admin		Y

Results